News reporting · Which? · 2026-10-30
A same-day comparison by Which? found that five finger-prick kits placed one tester in three different categories.
Which? tried five home vitamin D tests on the same person, using a different finger for each kit. A laboratory tested a sample drawn from a vein that day. The home kits produced three different categories of result.
The consumer organisation found the colour charts difficult to interpret and noted differences in the thresholds used to define a sufficient level. Its report includes responses from companies involved and links to separate research on the evidence and instructions supplied with self-tests.
The Boots and MyHealthChecked kits appeared to be the same product based on the reference numbers, manufacturer details and performance information Which? compared. Yet one kit put the tester in a sufficient range and the other indicated a lower level.
