Vitamin D3 for Life

Live Enlightened

Article

Short-Term Fluctuation and Long-Term Stability of Vitamin D Status: Full Study

Previous related pageSeasonal Fluctuations in Vitamin D LevelsNext related pageShort-Term Fluctuation and Long-Term Stability of Vitamin D Status: Study Summary
Study at a glance

How do vitamin D blood levels change over time?

This evidence review examines how vitamin D blood levels change over months and years. Studies repeatedly measured 25-hydroxyvitamin D, the form commonly used to assess vitamin D status. The question was whether short-term changes prevent a measurement from providing useful information about a longer-term pattern.

How large were seasonal changes in vitamin D levels?

In a Swedish blood-donor study, average levels in the wider donor group were 81.9 nmol/L in July and 47.4 nmol/L in February. Repeated samples from a smaller group also showed levels rising through spring and summer. Longer studies of older adults found that seasonal changes could be larger than the average change across several years. The timing of a test therefore matters.

Did vitamin D patterns remain over several years?

Yes, partly. People with relatively higher levels often remained higher than others years later, especially when samples were collected in the same season. That did not mean their actual blood levels stayed unchanged. Studies also found that repeated measurements could better represent a longer-term pattern and that changes in supplement use could alter that pattern.

Can one vitamin D test represent the whole year?

A single result can describe the current blood level without representing the whole year or a permanent personal level. Laboratory variation also contributes to differences between results. Repeated tests need context too: season, supplement changes and other circumstances can affect comparisons. The evidence supports partial long-term consistency alongside real short-term changes, not perfect stability.

Read the full article below ↓

Vitamin D status can move substantially over weeks or months while still retaining a recognisable longer-term pattern within the same person. This apparent contradiction is central to understanding Short-Term vs Long-Term Vitamin D Status. Circulating 25-hydroxyvitamin D [25(OH)D] responds to changing ultraviolet-B exposure, season, supplementation and behaviour, so one measurement can rise or fall considerably. Yet longitudinal studies also show that people often preserve part of their relative position over years, particularly when measurements are compared at similar times of year. Short-term variability and long-term stability are therefore not opposing descriptions. They operate on different timescales. For a shorter version of this evidence review, see Short-Term Fluctuation and Long-Term Stability of Vitamin D Status: Study Summary.

Vitamin D status is dynamic rather than fixed

A serum or plasma 25(OH)D result is a measurement made at a particular point on a moving physiological trajectory. Its value reflects vitamin D reaching the circulation from recent and accumulated sources, including cutaneous production, food, supplements and release from body stores. It is therefore useful as a status biomarker, but it should not be treated as though the measured concentration were a permanent characteristic of the individual. The distinction between a circulating measurement and the broader biological state is developed further in What Vitamin D Levels Represent.

The most conspicuous source of short-term and medium-term movement is season. At temperate latitudes, changing solar elevation and ultraviolet-B availability alter cutaneous vitamin D production over the year. Behaviour changes at the same time: clothing, outdoor activity, holidays and time spent indoors can reinforce or weaken the environmental signal. The result is a recurring annual rhythm rather than a flat concentration. This physiological background is covered directly in Seasonal Fluctuations in Vitamin D Levels.

Repeated measurements show large seasonal movement within individuals

Klingberg and colleagues studied seasonal vitamin D variation in healthy adults in Gothenburg, Sweden. Their cross-sectional population included 540 blood donors, while 75 thrombocyte donors supplied repeated samples for the intra-individual analysis. Because thrombocyte donors could give samples frequently, the investigators obtained 300 repeated samples, with some individuals contributing as many as 11 measurements. This made it possible to observe the direction and speed of within-person seasonal movement rather than merely comparing different groups sampled in winter and summer.

The annual contrast was substantial. Mean serum 25(OH)D in the wider donor population was 81.9 nmol/L in July and 47.4 nmol/L in February, a 73% difference. In the repeated-measure group, 25(OH)D increased by an average of about 8 nmol/L per month between April and August. These changes demonstrate why a result obtained during a rising spring-summer phase cannot automatically be treated as equivalent to the same person’s winter state. The concentration is biologically real, but the timing is also biologically real.

This matters when apparent changes between two results are interpreted. Some movement reflects genuine biological variation rather than disease progression, laboratory failure or a lasting change in the person’s underlying vitamin D pattern. The site-wide distinction between biological, analytical and contextual sources of change is addressed in Variability in Vitamin D Measurements.

Seasonal variation can be larger than long-term drift

Longitudinal evidence from the Longitudinal Aging Study Amsterdam provides another useful timescale comparison. In adults followed for years, average long-term change in 25(OH)D was relatively modest compared with the recurring seasonal swing. In the younger cohort, aged 55 to 65 years at baseline, mean 25(OH)D increased by about 4 nmol/L over six years. In the older cohort, aged 65 to 88 years, mean concentrations declined by about 4 nmol/L over thirteen years. Seasonal variation was approximately plus or minus 12 nmol/L in the younger cohort and plus or minus 7 nmol/L in the older cohort.

That comparison is important because it separates two different forms of change. A person’s concentration may move appreciably within an annual cycle even when the underlying multi-year trajectory changes much more slowly. A winter-to-summer comparison can therefore exaggerate the appearance of long-term change, while same-season comparisons are better positioned to reveal whether the underlying trajectory itself has moved.

Same-season sampling reveals longer-term tracking

Hofmann and colleagues examined 29 cancer-free participants in the Prostate, Lung, Colorectal, and Ovarian Cancer Screening Trial using serum collected at baseline, one year and five years. Crucially, serial samples from each person were taken in the same calendar month each year, on average within a 13-day window. This design largely separated longer-term within-person variation from the much larger confounding effect that would arise if one sample were taken in winter and another in summer.

Across the five-year period, the within-person coefficient of variation was 14.9%, with an intraclass correlation coefficient of 0.71. Rank correlations were 0.65 from baseline to one year, 0.61 from one to five years and 0.53 from baseline to five years. These are not measures of perfect stability. They show that substantial individual movement remains possible. At the same time, they indicate that a meaningful part of the between-person ranking persisted when season was held approximately constant.

An especially informative observation was that averaging the baseline and one-year measurements improved the correlation with the five-year measurement to 0.65, compared with 0.53 for baseline alone. Repeated observation can therefore improve representation of an underlying longer-term state because transient deviations in either direction have less influence on the estimate.

Larger cohorts confirm moderate long-term intra-individual variation

Meng and colleagues extended this question in 672 postmenopausal women whose 25(OH)D measurements were taken approximately five years apart. Mean concentrations increased from 60.0 to 67.8 nmol/L between the two study periods. The intra-individual coefficient of variation was 24.6%, the intraclass correlation coefficient was 0.59 and the Spearman correlation was 0.61. These results indicate moderate rather than absolute long-term reproducibility.

Season materially influenced that reproducibility. Among women sampled in the same season at both time points, the Spearman correlation was 0.68 and the intraclass correlation coefficient was 0.64. Among women sampled in different seasons, the corresponding values were lower, at 0.49 and 0.48. The study therefore shows directly that part of what looks like long-term instability is actually created by comparing different positions in the annual vitamin D cycle.

Supplement use also changed reliability. Women who altered vitamin D supplement use between measurements tended to show greater within-person variation than those whose exposure pattern remained stable. Long-term vitamin D status is therefore not a hidden fixed value waiting to be revealed by better measurement. It is itself influenced by sustained behaviour. Stability means persistence under broadly similar conditions, not biological immobility.

Short-term fluctuation and long-term status answer different questions

The evidence supports a distinction between the concentration present today and the pattern that characterises the person over a longer interval. The first may be useful when the immediate question concerns the current circulating state. The second is more relevant when asking whether vitamin D availability has been persistently low, adequate or changing over months and years.

This distinction also explains why no single numerical result can establish the entirety of Functional Vitamin D Status. Functional interpretation involves more than temporal averaging, but timescale is one component of the problem. A concentration obtained during a seasonal peak or trough may accurately report the blood concentration at that moment while still giving an incomplete picture of sustained exposure and physiological context.

A stable ranking does not mean an unchanged concentration

Intraclass correlations and rank correlations are sometimes misunderstood as evidence that concentrations do not change. They answer a different question. If people who tend to have higher concentrations remain relatively high compared with other people, reproducibility can be substantial even though everybody’s absolute concentration moves seasonally. Conversely, a person can cross a clinical threshold without completely losing their longer-term relative position.

This is one reason categorical labels can appear less stable than continuous measurements. A relatively modest shift near a threshold can move someone from one category to another even though the biological difference between the two measurements is small. Interpretation of this problem connects with Vitamin D Thresholds vs Targets, because a threshold classification and a continuous physiological trajectory are not the same object.

Measurement noise must be separated from biological movement

Not every difference between two results is caused by altered vitamin D physiology. Laboratory methods, assay imprecision and pre-analytical conditions can contribute variation. Even when the same assay is used, biological variation remains. The repeat-measure studies discussed here deliberately used controlled laboratory procedures to reduce analytical noise, helping to demonstrate that meaningful within-person temporal variation exists independently of measurement error. The broader distinction is considered in Biological Noise in Vitamin D Testing.

This does not make serial testing automatically superior in every situation. Repeated measurements answer a different question and must themselves be interpreted in relation to season, intervention, illness, supplementation and analytical method. Two poorly contextualised measurements can create a misleading trend just as one poorly contextualised measurement can create a misleading snapshot.

What the longitudinal evidence supports

Taken together, the evidence rejects two simplistic models. The first is that vitamin D status is so volatile that a blood measurement tells us almost nothing beyond that day. The second is that one 25(OH)D value represents a permanent personal set point. Neither is supported. Seasonal and behavioural effects cause genuine short-term and medium-term movement, yet same-season repeated measurements show that a meaningful longer-term component often persists.

The practical consequence is that timing belongs inside interpretation. When the question is whether a person’s underlying pattern has changed, season-matched measurements and repeated observations are more informative than comparing arbitrary dates. When the question is the current concentration, a single measurement may still be useful, but it should not automatically be expanded into a claim about the preceding or following year. This is one of the central limitations discussed in Limitations of Vitamin D Blood Tests.

The evidence from this Full Study is integrated with the complementary single-measurement evidence in Vitamin D Status Over Time: Fluctuation, Stability and Single-Measurement Limits: Evidence Synthesis.

Scientific sources

Hofmann JN, Yu K, Horst RL, Hayes RB, Purdue MP. Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers & Prevention. 2010;19(4):927-931. PMID 20332255. PMCID PMC2857993. Long-term Variation in Serum 25-Hydroxyvitamin D Concentration among Participants in the Prostate, Lung, Colorectal, and Ovarian Cancer Screening Trial.

Meng JE, Hovey KM, Wactawski-Wende J, Andrews CA, LaMonte MJ, Horst RL, Genco RJ, Millen AE. Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers & Prevention. 2012;21(6):916-924. PMID 22523182. PMCID PMC3372646. Intraindividual variation in plasma 25-hydroxyvitamin D measures 5 years apart among postmenopausal women.

van Schoor NM, Knol DL, Deeg DJH, Peters FPAMN, Heijboer AC, Lips P. Osteoporosis International. 2014. PMID 24570295. Longitudinal changes and seasonal variations in serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D levels in different age groups: results of the Longitudinal Aging Study Amsterdam.

Klingberg E, Oleröd G, Konar J, Petzold M, Hammarsten O. Endocrine. 2015;49(3):800-808. PMID 25681052. PMCID PMC4512566. DOI 10.1007/s12020-015-0548-3. Seasonal variations in serum 25-hydroxy vitamin D levels in a Swedish cohort.

Related reading

Original sources

Source

Long-term Variation in Serum 25-Hydroxyvitamin D Concentration among Participants in the Prostate, Lung, Colorectal, and Ovarian Cancer Screening Trial

Hofmann JN, Yu K, Horst RL, Hayes RB, Purdue MP.

Publication details

Hofmann JN, Yu K, Horst RL, Hayes RB, Purdue MP. Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers & Prevention. 2010;19(4):927-931. PMID 20332255. PMCID PMC2857993. Long-term Variation in Serum 25-Hydroxyvitamin D Concentration among Participants in the Prostate, Lung, Colorectal, and Ovarian Cancer Screening Trial.

Read more →
Source

Intraindividual variation in plasma 25-hydroxyvitamin D measures 5 years apart among postmenopausal women

Meng JE, Hovey KM, Wactawski-Wende J, Andrews CA, LaMonte MJ, Horst RL, Genco RJ, Millen AE.

Publication details

Meng JE, Hovey KM, Wactawski-Wende J, Andrews CA, LaMonte MJ, Horst RL, Genco RJ, Millen AE. Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers & Prevention. 2012;21(6):916-924. PMID 22523182. PMCID PMC3372646. Intraindividual variation in plasma 25-hydroxyvitamin D measures 5 years apart among postmenopausal women.

Read more →
Source

Longitudinal changes and seasonal variations in serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D levels in different age groups: results of the Longitudinal Aging Study Amsterdam

van Schoor NM, Knol DL, Deeg DJH, Peters FPAMN, Heijboer AC, Lips P.

Publication details

van Schoor NM, Knol DL, Deeg DJH, Peters FPAMN, Heijboer AC, Lips P. Osteoporosis International. 2014. PMID 24570295. Longitudinal changes and seasonal variations in serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D levels in different age groups: results of the Longitudinal Aging Study Amsterdam.

Read more →