Primary relevance to vitamin D Vitamin D is a stated subject of this paper.
Vitamin D is a stated subject of this paper; the supporting source evidence is shown below.
Why this paper is included
Supporting source evidence:
The majority of differences (11/16) led to more favourable estimates of vitamin D efficacy compared to estimates derived from unadjusted intention-to-treat analyses using all randomised participants.
Source: Abstract. View original paper
Relevance classification does not establish study quality, causation or editorial approval.
Study design Randomised controlled trial.
Randomised controlled trial
Assigns participants or groups to comparison interventions by chance.
Meta-analysis unclear · Blinding unclear / not reported · Research setting awaiting verification
How this paper was classified
Automatic source-based classification; awaiting editorial verification. This is not a quality score.
A Case Study of Discordant Overlapping Meta-Analyses: Vitamin D Supplements and Fracture
Source: Article title.
The recommended approach to analysis of a randomised controlled trial is an unadjusted intention-to-treat analysis using all randomised participants with data from the final study timepoint .
Source: Methods.
What the study types mean
- Systematic review
- Uses explicit methods to identify, assess and summarise research on a defined question.
- Scoping review
- Maps the extent and characteristics of research on a topic.
- Narrative review
- Discusses existing research; systematic-review methods have not been established by this classification.
- Review / evidence synthesis
- Reviews existing research; the exact review methods need further assessment.
- Randomised controlled trial
- Assigns participants or groups to comparison interventions by chance.
- Non-randomised intervention study
- Examines an intervention without random allocation.
- Cohort study
- Examines exposures and outcomes over time within a defined group.
- Case-control study
- Compares people with an outcome against people without it, examining exposures.
- Cross-sectional study
- Examines a population at a particular point in time.
- Observational study
- Observes exposures and outcomes without assigning the exposure; the subtype is not established here.
- Case report
- Describes an individual case.
- Case series
- Describes a group of individual cases.
- Secondary analysis
- Analyses existing study data; this paper is not automatically another independent trial.
- Laboratory study
- Investigates biological processes in a laboratory setting.
- Qualitative study
- Examines experiences or meanings using qualitative methods.
- Genetic instrumental-variable study
- Uses genetic variation as an instrument to investigate relationships; this is not a randomised treatment trial.
- Study protocol
- Describes planned methods and is not evidence that the planned study has reported results.
- Multiple reported designs
- More than one design is explicitly reported; examine the supporting methods.
- Study design awaiting verification
- The available source does not establish a sufficiently clear study design.
Meta-analysis combines numerical results from studies. Blinding describes who was unaware of treatment allocation. Neither is a separate quality grade. Study design, vitamin D relevance and document format are independent filters.
Abstracts
A Case Study of Discordant Overlapping Meta-Analyses: Vitamin D Supplements and Fracture
Randomised controlled trial · PLoS ONE · 2014
Original publication title
A Case Study of Discordant Overlapping Meta-Analyses: Vitamin D Supplements and Fracture
© 2014 Bolland, Grey
Original publication · Publisher record · CC BY 4.0
Source wording retained. Formatting, section navigation and display-title punctuation adapted for this research record.
At a glance
Abstract: What background does the paper provide?
Overlapping meta-analyses on the same topic are now very common, and discordant results often occur. To explore why discordant results arise, we examined a common topic for overlapping meta-analyses: vitamin D supplements and fracture.
Source: BackgroundAbstract: Methods and Findings
We identified 24 meta-analyses of vitamin D (with or without calcium) and fracture in a PubMed search in October 2013, and analysed a sample of 7 meta-analyses in the highest ranking general medicine journals. We used the AMSTAR tool to assess the quality of the meta-analyses, and compared their methodologies, analytic techniques and results. Applying the AMSTAR tool suggested the meta-analyses were generally of high quality. Despite this, there were important differences in trial selection, data extraction, and analytical methods that were only apparent after detailed assessment. 25 trials were included in at least one meta-analysis.
Four meta-analyses included all eligible trials according to the stated inclusion and exclusion criteria, but the other 3 meta-analyses “missed” between 3 and 8 trials, and 2 meta-analyses included apparently ineligible trials. The relative risks used for individual trials differed between meta-analyses for total fracture in 10 of 15 trials, and for hip fracture in 6 of 12 trials, because of different outcome definitions and analytic approaches. The majority of differences (11/16) led to more favourable estimates of vitamin D efficacy compared to estimates derived from unadjusted intention-to-treat analyses using all randomised participants.
The conclusions of the meta-analyses were discordant, ranging from strong statements that vitamin D prevents fractures to equally strong statements that vitamin D without calcium does not prevent fractures.
Source: Methods and FindingsAbstract: Conclusions
Substantial differences in trial selection, outcome definition and analytic methods between overlapping meta-analyses led to discordant estimates of the efficacy of vitamin D for fracture prevention. Strategies for conducting and reporting overlapping meta-analyses are required, to improve their accuracy and transparency.
Source: ConclusionsAuthors’ abstract
Background
Overlapping meta-analyses on the same topic are now very common, and discordant results often occur. To explore why discordant results arise, we examined a common topic for overlapping meta-analyses: vitamin D supplements and fracture.
Methods and Findings
We identified 24 meta-analyses of vitamin D (with or without calcium) and fracture in a PubMed search in October 2013, and analysed a sample of 7 meta-analyses in the highest ranking general medicine journals. We used the AMSTAR tool to assess the quality of the meta-analyses, and compared their methodologies, analytic techniques and results. Applying the AMSTAR tool suggested the meta-analyses were generally of high quality. Despite this, there were important differences in trial selection, data extraction, and analytical methods that were only apparent after detailed assessment. 25 trials were included in at least one meta-analysis.
Four meta-analyses included all eligible trials according to the stated inclusion and exclusion criteria, but the other 3 meta-analyses “missed” between 3 and 8 trials, and 2 meta-analyses included apparently ineligible trials. The relative risks used for individual trials differed between meta-analyses for total fracture in 10 of 15 trials, and for hip fracture in 6 of 12 trials, because of different outcome definitions and analytic approaches. The majority of differences (11/16) led to more favourable estimates of vitamin D efficacy compared to estimates derived from unadjusted intention-to-treat analyses using all randomised participants.
The conclusions of the meta-analyses were discordant, ranging from strong statements that vitamin D prevents fractures to equally strong statements that vitamin D without calcium does not prevent fractures.
Conclusions
Substantial differences in trial selection, outcome definition and analytic methods between overlapping meta-analyses led to discordant estimates of the efficacy of vitamin D for fracture prevention. Strategies for conducting and reporting overlapping meta-analyses are required, to improve their accuracy and transparency.
Publication and source details
Original title: A Case Study of Discordant Overlapping Meta-Analyses: Vitamin D Supplements and Fracture
Mark J. Bolland; Andrew Grey
PLoS ONE · 2014
* E-mail: m.bolland@auckland.ac.nzCompeting Interests: Neither author has any conflicts of interest to declare.
Conceived and designed the experiments: MB AG. Analyzed the data: MB AG. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: MB AG. Wrote the paper: MB AG.
Repository JATS snapshot; version as supplied
Source retrieved: 2026-11-11T07:38:47.174209+00:00
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0115934 · PMC4281138