Vitamin D3 for Life

Live Enlightened

Research libraryVitamin D3 For Life
Study design and methods

Secondary relevance to vitamin D This paper mainly addresses another topic and also reports a vitamin D analysis, result or scientific synthesis.

This paper mainly addresses another topic and also reports a vitamin D analysis, result or scientific synthesis.

Why this paper is included

Supporting source evidence:

Of these 16 factors, 12 (75%) had odds ratios (ORs) with 95% CIs not crossing 1: insufficient vitamin D intake (OR 7.15, 95% CI 3.77-13.54), head position preference (OR 4.75, 95% CI 3.36-6.73), bottle-only feeding (OR 4.65, 95% CI 2.70-8.00), reduced tummy time (OR 3.51, 95% CI 1.71-7.21), sleeping position (OR 3.12, 95% CI 2.21-4.39), fewer motor milestones reached by the age of 6 months (OR 2.56, 95% CI 1.66-3.96), obesity (OR 2.45, 95% CI 1.02-5.90), maternal education level (OR 1.66, 95% CI 1.17-2.37), male sex (OR 1.51, 95% CI 1.07-2.12), formula feeding (OR 1.51, 95% CI 1.00-2.27), head circumference (OR 1.22, 95% CI 1.06-1.40), and mechanical ventilation (OR 1.10, 95% CI 1.00-1.14).

Source: Abstract. View original paper

Relevance classification does not establish study quality, causation or editorial approval.

Study design Systematic review.

Systematic review

Uses explicit methods to identify, assess and summarise research on a defined question.

Meta-analysis reported · Blinding not applicable to this review · Research setting awaiting verification

How this paper was classified

Automatic source-based classification; awaiting editorial verification. This is not a quality score.

Assessing the Evidence for Nonobstetric Risk Factors for Deformational Plagiocephaly: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Source: Article title.

Assessing the Evidence for Nonobstetric Risk Factors for Deformational Plagiocephaly: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Source: Article title.

View supporting evidence in the original paper

What the study types mean
Systematic review
Uses explicit methods to identify, assess and summarise research on a defined question.
Scoping review
Maps the extent and characteristics of research on a topic.
Narrative review
Discusses existing research; systematic-review methods have not been established by this classification.
Review / evidence synthesis
Reviews existing research; the exact review methods need further assessment.
Randomised controlled trial
Assigns participants or groups to comparison interventions by chance.
Non-randomised intervention study
Examines an intervention without random allocation.
Cohort study
Examines exposures and outcomes over time within a defined group.
Case-control study
Compares people with an outcome against people without it, examining exposures.
Cross-sectional study
Examines a population at a particular point in time.
Observational study
Observes exposures and outcomes without assigning the exposure; the subtype is not established here.
Case report
Describes an individual case.
Case series
Describes a group of individual cases.
Secondary analysis
Analyses existing study data; this paper is not automatically another independent trial.
Laboratory study
Investigates biological processes in a laboratory setting.
Qualitative study
Examines experiences or meanings using qualitative methods.
Genetic instrumental-variable study
Uses genetic variation as an instrument to investigate relationships; this is not a randomised treatment trial.
Study protocol
Describes planned methods and is not evidence that the planned study has reported results.
Multiple reported designs
More than one design is explicitly reported; examine the supporting methods.
Study design awaiting verification
The available source does not establish a sufficiently clear study design.

Meta-analysis combines numerical results from studies. Blinding describes who was unaware of treatment allocation. Neither is a separate quality grade. Study design, vitamin D relevance and document format are independent filters.

Full studies

Assessing the Evidence for Nonobstetric Risk Factors for Deformational Plagiocephaly: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Systematic review · Interactive Journal of Medical Research · 2024

Original publication title

Assessing the Evidence for Nonobstetric Risk Factors for Deformational Plagiocephaly: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Christopher Robert Timothy Hillyar; Natalie Bishop; Anjan Nibber; Frances Jean Bell-Davies; Juling Ong

©Christopher Robert Timothy Hillyar, Natalie Bishop, Anjan Nibber, Frances Jean Bell-Davies, Juling Ong. Originally published in the Interactive Journal of Medical Research (https://www.i-jmr.org/), 18.09.2024.

Original publication · Publisher record · CC BY 4.0

Source wording retained. Formatting, section navigation and display-title punctuation adapted for this research record.

Authors’ conclusion

In summary, this study provides the most comprehensive meta-analytic assessment of nonobstetric factors associated with DP published to date. It offers 11 evidence-based recommendations that can be adopted by health care systems globally to reduce the prevalence of DP. Future research should focus on investigating factors for which the literature is conflicting but quantitative data are lacking to enable meta-analyses to be performed; for example, maternal age was the only factor reported to be protective against DP, but conflicting studies reported that there was no association without providing quantitative data.

Thus, maternal age as a protective factor for DP should be investigated further to provide quantitative data for meta-analytic approaches to determine its protective effect. Further research should also address the nature of specific relationships between risk factors and DP; for example, both bottle-only feeding and formula feeding have been associated with DP. Studies should focus on understanding the nature of this relationship, that is, whether this relationship is due to mechanical forces associated with bottle-feeding or whether a reduction in, or lack of, breast milk intake or a lack of complimentary foods alongside breast milk results in nutritional differences that impact skull development [66].

As our study also highlighted an association between obesity and DP, research on other early-life or environmental exposures should be conducted to elucidate their effects on growth and development, particularly skull growth and head shape [67,68]. Finally, randomized controlled trials, although considered the gold standard study design for obtaining reliable evidence of an intervention’s effectiveness, should not be conducted for the interventions herein that relate to risk factors for DP development that have already been assessed through meta-analysis.

However, randomized controlled trials could provide further evidence for an intervention: if ethically appropriate: where the evidence for a particular risk factor is relatively weak, such as when only a single cohort study has provided the evidence for a risk factor’s influence on the development of DP.

An extract from the source publication. Read it in context.

At a glance

Abstract: What objectives does the paper state?

The aims of this systematic review and meta-analysis were to critically assess the evidence for nonobstetric risk factors for DP and to make evidence-based recommendations for reducing the prevalence of DP.

Source: Objective

Study methods

What methods does the paper describe?

The study protocol, analysis, and reporting were conducted in line with the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) 2020 guidelines [20-22]. The protocol was registered with PROSPERO (CRD42020204979).

Search Strategy

A search of PubMed and Web of Science was performed covering the period from August 21, 2010, to August 21, 2022 (this included an initial search from August 21, 2010, to August 20, 2020, and an update search from August 21, 2010, to August 20, 2022, to ensure that the list of included studies was as up to date as possible). The combination of PubMed and Web of Science provides >97.5% coverage of published literature [23,24].

To balance comprehensive coverage with a pragmatic approach to ensure that the study was completed with limited available resources, additional databases were not searched, and hand searching and gray literature searches were also not performed. The search terms included “plagiocephaly” AND “risk factor.”

Study Eligibility

Study titles and abstracts were screened and assessed for relevance by a single reviewer (CRTH, NB, or AN). Specifically, original studies were included if they assessed risk factors for DP. Studies in a non-English language, those involving nonhuman subjects, and low-quality or nonoriginal studies (meeting abstracts, reviews, case series, case reports, and editorials) were excluded. Duplicates were identified by assessing study titles and removed manually by CRTH. Full-text review was performed after screening by a single reviewer (CRTH, NB, or AN).

Studies not reporting nonobstetric risk factors for DP were excluded. Studies reporting preventive measures such as tummy time were included. However, studies involving treatments such as physical therapy and helmet therapy were not included. As screening was performed by a single reviewer, there were no discrepancies to be resolved.

Data Extraction and Reporting

Data extraction and reporting followed the PRISMA guidelines. However, due to resource limitations, data from eligible full-text articles were extracted by a single reviewer (CRTH, NB, or AN). The main outcomes of interest were odds ratios (ORs) and risk ratios (RRs) with 95% CIs, or significant associations, for risk factors for DP (or biomarkers for DP; eg, oblique diameter difference index). These outcomes were split into factors that were associated with DP and those that were not. Other items extracted from the eligible studies included authors, country of study, funding source, study design, study aims, total participants, percentage female, population assessed, age at baseline, and selection criteria.

Meta-Analysis

A meta-analysis of ORs and RRs for factors associated with DP was performed. The inconsistency index (Ι2) and a Q statistic for chi-square significance for specific df were calculated to assess interstudy heterogeneity. Both fixed effects and random effects were reported. P values for 95% CIs were calculated. Excel (Microsoft Corp) and Prism (GraphPad Software) were used for statistical analysis.

Funnel Plots

Publication bias was assessed using funnel plots of ORs and RRs for DP risk factors against study precision (1/SE). The Egger test for asymmetry was conducted using linear regression, with P<.05 indicating publication bias [25].

Source: Methods Source: Methods Source: Methods Source: Methods Source: Methods Source: Methods

Results: Demographic Factors

Age

The study by van Cruchten et al [9] reported a negative correlation between age and oblique diameter difference index (a biomarker for DP). However, the study by Sheu et al [38] (which assessed factors associated with a 9-fold increase in plagiocephaly between 1999 and 2007 in Texas, United States) reported no association between age and DP. Finally, the study by Roberts et al [37], which assessed DP in children with ventriculoperitoneal shunts, reported that being aged 12 to 16 years at the time of shunt insertion was associated with DP.

Sex

Of the 19 studies, 4 (21%) demonstrated an association between male sex and DP [33,36,39,44], 1 (5%) reported borderline association [37], and 7 (37%) reported no association between male sex and DP [9,28-30,32,35,38]. Of these 12 studies, 6 (50%) [29,30,33,36,39,43] reported ORs, and a meta-analysis of these ORs revealed interstudy heterogeneity (I2=68.5%; Q statistic=15.89; df=6).

The pooled fixed and random effects ORs for DP related to male sex were 1.71 (95% CI 1.43-2.04; P<.001) and 1.51 (95% CI 1.07-2.12; P=.02), respectively (Figure 2A [29,30,33,36,39,43]). Asymmetry analysis of the funnel plot excluded publication bias (P=.12; Figure 2B).

Figure 2

Meta-analysis and funnel plot for male sex. (A) Forest plot of odds ratios for deformational plagiocephaly related to male sex with fixed and random effects. (B) Funnel plot with linear regression test of asymmetry. The blue line indicates random effects. *Mild to moderate deformational plagiocephaly (DP; univariate analysis); **severe DP (univariate analysis).

Figure image at the original source: open the original paper. This file is not included in this text import.

Race

Race was investigated by Tang et al [40], who included a cohort of children with brachial plexus palsy. In this group, race was not associated with DP that developed after brachial plexus injury.

Source: Demographic Factors Source: Demographic Factors Source: Demographic Factors

Results: Developmental Factors

Developmental Delay

Developmental delay was investigated as a risk factor for DP by van Cruchten et al [9], who concluded that developmental delay was not associated with DP.

Developmental Dysplasia of the Hip

Developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) was investigated as a risk factor for DP by Valkama et al [41], who assessed the prevalence of DP in children with DDH. DDH was associated with DP compared to controls without DDH.

Head Circumference

Head circumference was investigated by Solani et al [39], who concluded that it was associated with DP (OR 1.22, 95% CI 1.06-1.40).

Motor Milestones

Reaching fewer motor milestones by age 6 months was investigated as a risk factor by 2 (11%) of the 19 included studies [27,30]. The first study reported that reaching fewer motor milestones by age 6 months was associated with DP (adjusted OR [aOR] 2.35, 95% CI 1.25-4.42) [27]. The second study found an association between delay in motor development and DP [30]. A meta-analysis of the ORs from these studies identified no interstudy heterogeneity (I2=0%; Q statistic=1.67; df=3; Figure 3A [27,30]).

The pooled fixed and random effects ORs for DP related to delayed motor milestones were both 2.56 (95% CI 1.66-3.96; P<.001). Asymmetry analysis of the funnel plot excluded publication bias (P=.18; Figure 3B).

Figure 3

Meta-analysis and funnel plot for reaching fewer motor milestones by age 6 months. (A) Forest plot of odds ratios for deformational plagiocephaly related to reaching fewer motor milestones by age 6 months with fixed and random effects. (B) Funnel plot with linear regression test of asymmetry. The blue line indicates fixed effects. *Adjusted OR (aOR) for deformational plagiocephaly (DP; multivariate analysis); **odds ratio (OR) for mild to moderate DP (only univariate analysis available); ***aOR for severe DP (multivariate analysis).

Figure image at the original source: open the original paper. This file is not included in this text import.

Overweight and Underweight

Being overweight at diagnosis of DP was investigated as a risk factor for DP by Kim et al [30], who reported that being overweight at diagnosis was not associated with DP. The same study reported that being underweight at diagnosis was also not associated with DP.

Source: Developmental Factors Source: Developmental Factors Source: Developmental Factors Source: Developmental Factors Source: Developmental Factors

Results: Dietary Factors

Bottle-Only Feeding

Bottle-only feeding was investigated by Kim et al [30], who demonstrated that bottle-only feeding was associated with DP (aOR 4.65, 95% CI 2.70-8.00).

Breast Feeding

The duration of exclusive breast feeding was investigated by Aarnivala et al [27], who demonstrated that the duration of exclusive breast feeding was not associated with DP.

Formula Feeding

Formula feeding was investigated by Weernink et al [43], who reported that children who developed DP by age 2 to 4 months were more likely to be formula fed (aOR 1.51, 95% CI 1.00-2.27).

Vitamin D Intake

Vitamin D intake in infants was investigated by Weernink et al [43], who reported that children who developed DP by age 2 to 4 months were more likely to have insufficient vitamin D intake (aOR 7.15, 95% CI 3.77-13.54).

Source: Dietary Factors Source: Dietary Factors Source: Dietary Factors Source: Dietary Factors

Results: Maternal Factors

Maternal Age

Of the 19 included studies, 3 (16%) demonstrated an association between maternal age and DP [28,32,43]. However, 3 (16%) of the 19 studies reported no association [30,38,40]. Only 1 (17%) of these 6 studies reported an OR indicating that increased maternal age was a protective factor for the development of DP (OR 0.94, 95% CI 0.91-0.97) [43].

Maternal Education Level

Of the 19 included studies, 3 (16%) demonstrated an association between maternal education level and DP [33,38,43], and 1 (5%) reported no significant association [28]. Only 2 (67%) of the 3 studies reported ORs [33,43]. Of these 2 studies, 1 (50%) indicated that low maternal education level was an adverse factor in the development of DP (aOR 1.97, 95% CI 1.19-3.26) [43], while 1 (50%) suggested that postsecondary education was not a protective factor (OR 0.71, 95% CI 0.43-1.16) [33].

The OR from the former was used in a meta-analysis with the inverse OR from the latter, which demonstrated no interstudy heterogeneity (I2=0%; Q statistic=0.86; df=1; Figure 4 [33,43]). The pooled fixed effects OR for DP related to low education level was 1.66 (95% CI 1.17-2.37; P<.005).

Figure 4

Meta-analysis for maternal education level. *Reciprocal odds ratio (OR) for postsecondary education.

Figure image at the original source: open the original paper. This file is not included in this text import.

Maternal Language Barriers

The study by Ballardini et al [28] investigated whether infants with mothers who experience a language barrier when receiving medical advice had a higher rate of DP. The study suggested that maternal language barrier was not associated with DP in the infant.

Maternal Race and Country of Origin

Of the 19 included studies, 3 (16%) investigated whether DP was associated with maternal race and country of origin [28,38,43]. All 3 studies suggested that maternal race and country of origin was not associated with DP in the infant.

Length of Time in the Country of Study

The study by Mawji et al [33] investigated whether the length of time spent by mothers in the country in which the study was conducted was associated with DP. The study reported that length of time in the country of study was not associated with DP.

Pacifier Use

Pacifier use by mothers in healthy infants was investigated as a risk factor for DP by Aarnivala et al [27], who reported that pacifier use was not associated with DP.

Tummy Time Instructions

The study by Ballardini et al [28] investigated whether DP was associated with mothers receiving instructions about tummy time. The study reported that receiving instructions about tummy time was not associated with DP.

Source: Maternal Factors Source: Maternal Factors Source: Maternal Factors Source: Maternal Factors Source: Maternal Factors Source: Maternal Factors Source: Maternal Factors

Summary of Nonobstetric Factors Associated With DP

Results: Summary of Nonobstetric Factors Associated With DP

A summary of 16 nonobstetric factors associated with DP is presented in Table 2. ORs are provided for 12 (75%) of these 16 nonobstetric factors.

Table 2

Odds ratios (ORs) for factors associated with deformational plagiocephaly. ORs are reported from single studies unless marked with a superscript (“a” or “b”) indicating pooled ORs from fixed or random effects meta-analyses.

FactorsOR (95% CI)References
Insufficient vitamin D intake7.15 (3.77-13.54)[42]
Head position preference4.75a (3.36-6.73)[33,34]
Bottle-only feeding4.65 (2.70-8.00)[30]
Reduced tummy time3.51 (1.71-7.21)[30]
Sleeping position3.12 (2.21-4.39)[28,33,39]
Fewer motor milestones by age 6 mo2.56a (1.66-3.96)[27,30]
Obesity (BMI >97th percentile)2.45 (1.02-5.90)[30]
Maternal education level1.66a (1.17-2.37)[33,43]
Male sex1.51b (1.07-2.12)[29,30,33,36,43]
Formula feeding1.51 (1.00-2.27)[43]
Head circumference1.22 (1.06-1.40)[39]
Mechanical ventilation1.10 (1.00-1.14)[34]
Chronic lung disease grade IINRc[34]
DDHdNR[41]
Maternal ageNR[28,32,43]
Time spent supineNR[27]

aOR from a fixed effects meta-analysis where interstudy heterogeneity was <50%.

bOR from a random effects meta-analysis where interstudy heterogeneity was ≥50%.

cNR: not reported.

dDDH: developmental dysplasia of the hip.

Source: Summary of Nonobstetric Factors Associated With DP Source: Summary of Nonobstetric Factors Associated With DP

Discussion: Limitations of This Study

To ensure the completion of the study, additional databases were not searched, and hand searching and gray literature searches were also not performed. This inevitably limited the comprehensiveness of this study, although no systematic review can claim to be truly comprehensive because this would necessitate continual inclusion of newly published studies. The search terms were designed to be specific yet pragmatic to ensure the completion of the work with limited resources; thus, some studies may have been overlooked. Due to resource limitations, it was not possible to record more detailed reasons for the exclusion of screened articles other than not reporting risk factors for DP.

Resource constraints also prevented the screening process from being conducted by 2 independent reviewers. Instead, abstract and full-text screening was performed by a single reviewer. This impacts the reproducibility of the study due to the increased potential for errors in study selection when screening is undertaken by a single reviewer. That said, because the selection criteria were clearly set out, errors due to the application of these criteria during the screening process are likely to have had minimal impact on the study outcomes.

In addition, it was not feasible, due to resource limitations, to contact study authors to attempt to collect raw data if a study did not report ORs for a risk factor. This may have limited the data that could have been used in meta-analysis. If contacting authors had been feasible, more factors could potentially have been analyzed quantitively to resolve discrepancies between the included studies. This represents a significant limitation of our study.

These factors may, in part, account for the apparent disparities reported in our results compared to other literature. These disparities include the apparent lack of association between developmental delay and DP [9], while demonstrating a significant association between reaching fewer motor milestones and DP [27,30]. A recent systematic review by Martinuik et al [62] included 19 studies that assessed the association between developmental delay and DP. Notwithstanding the fact that the authors included multiple studies that used the same study population more than once, a positive association between developmental delay and DP was reported in a majority of the studies [62].

The fact that our study did not demonstrate a similar association may, in part, be due to the inclusion of studies that assessed different populations, as well as methodological limitations in our search strategy that limited the identification of studies that may have met our eligibility criteria. Another study of a large primary care cohort of 77,108 patients has provided further evidence in support of an association between developmental delay and DP [63]. That said, the literature remains conflicting, with other studies unable to demonstrate an association between presence or degree of developmental delay and DP [64].

Commentators have highlighted the fact that most studies are retrospective and observational by design, and this limits conclusions about the correlative versus causative relationship between developmental delay and DP [65].

Another disparity reported in our study is that torticollis was not associated with DP [9,26,38]. A number of literature reviews have previously reported an association between congenital muscular torticollis and DP [8,59]. Although these studies were published a decade or so ago, it logically follows that if other positional factors, such as head position preference and sleeping position, have been found in more contemporaneous studies to be significantly associated with DP [28,33,34,39], then torticollis would also be expected to be found to be associated with DP.

These conflicts reported in the literature may be due to the limitations of individual study design or differences between different study populations. Therefore, we recommend interpreting with caution the lack of association between torticollis and DP reported in our study, given the lack of a mechanistic explanation that reconciles this result with other positional factors that were found to be associated with DP.

In this review, we have included a study involving patients who developed plagiocephaly after ventriculoperitoneal shunt insertion [37]. Although the authors characterized the plagiocephaly as “positional,” implying that external forces had caused the skull deformity, an alternative hypothesis is that shunt-associated plagiocephaly is a different disease entity from DP [37]. This study has been included for comprehensiveness [37], but the results should be interpreted with caution alongside those of other studies.

Finally, another limitation includes the lack of a Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) assessment of evidence quality, which impacts the certainty of the conclusions and recommendations set out in this study.

Source: Limitations of This Study Source: Limitations of This Study Source: Limitations of This Study Source: Limitations of This Study Source: Limitations of This Study

Results

Overview

The searches of PubMed and Web of Science yielded 159 articles; after removing 35 (22%) duplicates, 124 (78%) articles were screened based on abstract content. Of these 124 articles, 77 (62.1%) were not relevant. Full-text screening of the remaining 47 articles resulted in the exclusion of 20 (43%) irrelevant articles (these did not report nonobstetric risk factors for DP), 3 (6%) non-English articles, and 5 (11%) articles that were not accessible. Thus, of the initial 159 articles, 19 (11.9%) were eligible for inclusion in this study (Figure 1).

The characteristics of the included studies are presented in Table 1.

Figure 1

PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) 2020 flow diagram for study eligibility and inclusion.

Figure image at the original source: open the original paper. This file is not included in this text import.
Table 1

Characteristics of the included studies.

Study; countryFunding sourceStudy designStudy aimsParticipants, n (% female)Population assessedAge at baselineSelection criteriaOutcomesFactors associated with DPa Factors not associated with DP
Aarnivala et al [26]; FinlandAlma and KA Snellman Foundation and The Foundation for Pediatric Research, FinlandRetrospective cohort studyTo assess risk factors for the development of DP and torticollis155 (51)Healthy newborns<72 h from birthHealthy newborns born between February 2012 and September 2013; newborns were excluded if they had chromosomal anomalies, cleft lip or palate, or craniosynostosisORsb and RRsc for risk factors for DPNRdRisk of developing DP was not associated with torticollis
Aarnivala et al [27]; FinlandAlma and KA Snellman FoundationProspective cohort studyTo assess risk factors for cranial deformation by measuring cranial asymmetry from age 3 to 12 mo using 3D stereophotogrammetry99 (47)Healthy newbornsRecruited at birthHealthy newborns included at birth residing within 20 minutes’ driving distance from Oulu University Hospital; infants with craniosynostosis, cleft lip and palate, or syndromic features were excludedORs and RRs for risk factors for DPDP at age 6 mo associated with position preference and imbalance in head rotation at age 3 mo; at age 6 mo, DP associated with reaching fewer motor milestones at age 6 mo; at age 12 mo, DP associated with position preference at age 3 mo and imbalance in head rotation at age 3 mo and 6 mo; at age 12 mo, DP associated with fewer motor milestones and spending more time supine on the floor at age 6 mo; position preference at age 3 mo associated with DP at age 12 mo; at age 6 mo, DP associated with position preference at age 3 mo and fewer motor milestones reached at age 6 mo; at age 12 mo, DP associated with position preference at age 3 moPosition preference at age 6 mo was not associated with DP at age 12 mo; there was no association between DP at age 12 mo and imbalance in head rotation at age 3 mo; no association with DP was also observed for primary sleeping position, time spent in carrier, bouncers, or car seats, time spent prone on the floor, pacifier use, illness history (acute otitis media and conditions requiring prolonged hospitalization), and duration of full breastfeeding
Ballardini et al [28]; ItalyPediatric department of the University of Ferrara in Ferrara, ItalyProspective cohort studyTo assess prevalence and risk factors for DP in full-term infants283 (53)Healthy newbornsAll infants: mean 11.6 (range 9.4-12.9) wk; infants with DP: mean 11.7 (range 10.0-12.8) wk; infants without DP: mean 11.6 (range 9.4-12.9) wkHealthy infants born at term presenting at a public immunization clinic in Ferrara at age 8 to 12 wk were included; infants affected by craniosynostosis, malformations, or neurological diseases or those admitted to the NICUe were excludedORs and RRs for risk factors for DPMaternal and infant risk factors associated with DP included maternal age, supine sleeping position, and head position preferenceMaternal and infant risk factors not associated with DP included infant sex, maternal origin, maternal education level, breast milk feeding, changing crib end, tummy time, and instruction about tummy time
Ifflaender et al [29]; GermanyThe Else Kröner-Fresenius FoundationCross-sectional studyTo assess head shape to determine the prevalence of symmetrical and asymmetrical head deformities and identify possible risk factors195 (48)Healthy newbornsMean postmenstrual age: 38.4 (SD 0.9) wkPreterm infants discharged from an intermediate care unit of a tertiary neonatal clinic in Dresden from April 2011 to January 2013 were included; all infants were included that were present on the ward at the time of measurement; those with peripheral cannula at the scalp or requiring supplemental oxygen, were excludedORs and RRs for risk factors for DPCranial vault asymmetry index ([diagonal A: diagonal B and diagonal A] × 100, where diagonal A >diagonal B) at term-equivalent age was higher (4.1%, IQR 1.9%-6.5%) in very preterm infants compared to late preterm infants and term infants; moderate or severe DP at term-equivalent age was associated with intracranial hemorrhage in preterm infants; duration of total respiratory support was higher in cases of DP compared to controls; duration of continuous positive airway pressure therapy was longer in cases of DP than in controlsNo association with DP was observed for sex, bronchopulmonary dysplasia, necrotizing enterocolitis, and duration of intermittent mandatory ventilation
Kim et al [30]; South KoreaNRCase-control studyTo determine risk factors for DP and its severity, including the association between DP and infant obesity as defined by BMI135 (40)Infants with cranial deformation on physical examination, with age: and sex-matched controls randomly selected from the national health screening system for infants and children (confirmed to have no cranial deformation on physical examination)2-12 moInfants aged 2-12 mo at the time of diagnosis of DP were included; infants with neuroimaging results positive for craniosynostosis were excluded; infants with insufficient clinical data, congenital muscular torticollis, congenital anomalies (eg, craniofacial or chromosomal anomalies), or birth injury were also excluded; age: and sex-matched controls (confirmed to have no cranial deformation on physical examination) were randomly selected from the national health screening systemORs and RRs for risk factors for DPFactors associated with DP included bottle-only feeding, reduced tummy time when awake, delayed motor development, and obesity at diagnosisFactors not associated with DP included; infant male sex; maternal age; macrocephaly at birth; and macrocephaly, underweight, or overweight at the time of diagnosis
Leung et al [31]; AustraliaNRProspective cohort studyTo assess association between DP and head orientation or head strength94 (59)Healthy newbornsMean 21.40 (SD 2.29) dHealthy newborns, born at full term (37-42 wk) between June 2011 and July 2013; infants were excluded for reasons related to low birth weight (<2500 g), congenital muscular torticollis, craniosynostosis, neurological insult, or other medical or orthopedic conditionsCorrelation between risk factor severity and DP severityDP at age 9 wk was associated with asymmetrical head orientation duration at age 3 wk and 6 wk; DP at age 9 wk was significantly associated with asymmetrical head orientation strength at age 3 wk and 6 wkNo association between DP and latency to turn head
Maniglio et al [32]; ItalyNRProspective cohort studyTo assess factors associated with DP to improve screening strategies to identify infants at risk of developing severe deformation4337 (NR)Infants with DP and controls without DP6-12 wkInfants born at the San Pietro Fatebenefratelli Hospital in Rome between January 2017 and September 2018 were included; infants with congenital deformations, born before 24 wk gestation, and infants who needed long intensive care treatment were excludedORs for risk factors for DPMaternal age was associated with DPMale sex was not associated with DP
Mawji et al [33]; CanadaThe Faculty of Graduate Studies at the University of Calgary in Calgary, Alberta, provided CAD $3000 (US $2670) for data collectionProspective cohort studyTo assess potential risk factors for DP in infants aged 7-12 wk in Calgary440 (40.7)Healthy full-term infants7-12 wk Healthy full-term infants (born at ≥37 wk gestation) ranging from age 7 to 12 wk who presented for immunization at a 2-mo well-child clinic in Calgary were includedORs and RRs for risk factors for DPSignificant difference in incidence of DP in infants placed supine to sleep compared with sleep in other positions (including prone; side; or a combination of supine, prone, or side); DP also associated with head position preference (right and left), maternal education level, and supine sleep positionNo association of DP with average length of time in Canada; infant feeding position; length of tummy time received; male infant sex; and mothers who had a language barrier
Nuysink et al [34]; NetherlandsNRProspective cohort studyTo assess predictive factors for DP in infants at corrected age >6 mo120 (45.8)Newborns admitted to the NICU at gestational age <30 wk or birthweight <1000 g<1 wkEligible infants were born in or referred to the level III neonatal intensive care unit within 1 week of birth between January 2009 and October 2010; infants born at gestational age <30 wk or birth weight <1000 g who visited the neonatal follow-up clinic were included; infants diagnosed with a disease or dysfunction leading to symptomatic asymmetry, such as a central nervous system disorder or congenital malformation, were excludedORs for risk factors for DPAssociation between DP and mechanical ventilation and chronic lung disease grade II in the neonatal periodNR
Launonen et al [35]; FinlandThe University of Oulu Scholarship Foundation, the Orthodontic Section of the Finnish Dental Association Apollonia, the Emil Aaltonen Foundation, the Alma, and KA Snellman Foundation, the Finnish Medical Foundation, and the Foundation for Pediatric Research in FinlandCase-control studyTo use 3D stereophotogrammetry to assess cranial growth, molding, and incidence of DP in preterm children compared to term-born children68 (32)Healthy newbornsPreterm (mean gestational age): 32.7 wk; term (mean gestational age): 40.0 wkInfants were considered eligible if they had no cheilopalatoschisis, craniosynostosis, or dysmorphic features and if they resided within Oulu region, Finland; all participants were born between 2012 and 2015 at Oulu University Hospital; the control group was randomly selected from a previously collected nonintervention cohort by computer-based random selection and matched for sexOCLRf mean differenceNRNo difference in head shape (OCLR) between preterm and full-term children or between sexes
Pogliani et al [36]; ItalyNRRetrospective cohort studyTo assess risk factors for DP at birth413 (50)Healthy newborns<72 h from birthNeonates at gestational age >33 wk born between May 2011 and January 2012; newborns with extreme low birth weight or presenting with major congenital malformations needing NICU transfer were excluded; children of mothers with a documented TORCHg infection were also excludedORs and RRs for risk factors for DPAssociation between DP and male sexNR
Roberts et al [37]; United KingdomNRRetrospective cohort studyTo test the hypothesis that ventriculoperitoneal shunt insertion significantly increases contralateral DP339 (42)Children aged 0-16 y with ventriculoperitoneal shuntsNRChildren aged 0-16 y with at least 1 follow-up scan from the surgical database at the pediatric neurosurgery department of Birmingham Children’s Hospital between 2006 and 2013; children without imaging were excludedORs and RRs for risk factors for DPDP was associated with occipital shunt placement; a statistically significant difference in the probability of becoming plagiocephalic between neonates and children aged 12-16 y was observed; boys were more likely to develop shunt-associated plagiocephaly than girlsNo difference in DP between neonates and infants, neonates and children aged 3-5 y, neonates and children aged 1-3 y, and neonates and children aged 5-12 y
Sheu et al [38]; United StatesCooperative agreement from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (U01DD000494) and Title V Maternal and Child Health Block Grant funds from the Health Resources and Services AdministrationRetrospective cohort studyTo assess factors that may explain a 9-fold increase in plagiocephaly in Texas from 1999 to 20076295 (38)Infants with DPNRCases identified using the Texas Birth Defects Registry with a definite diagnosis of DP (British Paediatric Association code 754.050), born between January 1, 1999, and December 31, 2007; cases of plagiocephaly with craniosynostosis were excludedMean difference or percentage difference for risk factors for DPLower maternal education level was associated with DPNo association of DP with maternal age or race and ethnicity, infant sex; mean age at DP diagnosis did not significantly change over time
Solani et al [39]; IranGrant funding from the Vice-Chancellor for Research, Kashan University of Medical Sciences, Kashan, IranCase-control studyTo determine the risk factors of positional plagiocephaly in healthy infants300 (NR)Healthy Iranian infants8-12 wkHealthy full-term (gestational age >37 wk) infants aged 8-12 wk who were referred to the pediatric neurology clinic at Shahid Beheshti Hospital in Kashan, affiliated with Kashan University of Medical Sciences, were includedORs for risk factors for DPFactors associated with DP included male sex, head circumference, and supine sleeping positionFirmness of headrest was not associated with DP
Tang et al [40]; United StatesNRProspective cohort studyTo assess the prevalence of DP in infants with NBPPh and spontaneous recovery from DP28 (50)Full-term infants aged >3 mo and <1 y with NBPPMean 3 (SD 3) moFull-term infants aged >3 mo and <1 y with NBPP; infants with neurological or congenital comorbidities in addition to NBPP, helmet therapy for plagiocephaly, and surgical procedures related to NBPP were excluded; infants with craniosynostosis were also excludedMean difference or percentage difference for risk factors for DPNRMaternal age and race (Black or White) were not associated with DP
Valkama et al [41]; FinlandNRCase-control studyTo assess the prevalence of DP in children with DDHi120 (56)Children with DDH with or without DPChildren with DDH: mean 8.0 (SD 1.4) y; matched controls: mean 7.9 (SD 1.3) yChildren with DDH from among newborn infants born at the Oulu University Hospital in Oulu, Finland, were included; preterm children and children with disabilities were excludedORs and RRs for risk factors for DP10.3% of the children with DDH and only 1.5% of the control children had DPOCLR was equal between children with DDH and controls; no association between side of DDH and DP
Van Vlimmeren et al [42]; NetherlandsGrant from the Scientific Committee of The Royal Dutch Association for Physiotherapy (BU002/10)Prospective cohort studyTo assess skull shape in healthy newborns until age 5.5 y in children with position preference at 7 wk and those without and in children with position preference who received pediatric physical therapy intervention and those who did not380 (53)Healthy newborns<48 h from birthHealthy newborns (gestational age ≥36 wk) born between December 2004 and September 2005 at Hospital Bernhoven; children with congenital muscular torticollis (Kaplan type 2 and 3), dysmorphism, or syndromes were excludedMean difference or percentage difference for risk factors for DPAssociation between DP and position preferenceNo association between potential risk factors (nursing, feeding, sleeping, and playing positioning habits) at age 7 wk and skull deformity at age 24 mo and 5.5 y; a trend toward significance between time spent playing prone (tummy time) at age 7 wk and the ODDIj percentage at age 24 mo
Weernink et al [43]; NetherlandsZonMw, the Netherlands Organization for Health Research and Development (170.992.501)Case-control studyTo assess the influence of adherence to recommendations for vitamin D supplement intake of 10 μg/d (400 IU) in the first months of life (child) on the occurrence of DP of the child at age 2-4 mo823 (46)Infants with DP and those without2-4 moChildren born between November 22, 2009, and June 9, 2010, with mild to severe DP from the Helmet Therapy Assessment in Deformed Skulls study; controls were included from a 2010 survey on infant milk feedingORs and RRs for risk factors for DPInsufficient vitamin D supplement intake during early infancy was associated with DP; maternal sociodemographic factors associated with DP included mother’s age and mother’s education level; infant factors associated with DP included male sex, formula feeding, and milk formula consumption after birthMaternal sociodemographic factors not significantly associated with DP included mother’s country of birth (other than the Netherlands); infant factors not associated with DP included time child spent outdoors
Van Cruchten et al [9]; NetherlandsNRCohort studyTo assess the impact of risk factors on the type and severity of DP184 (30.4)Infants seen at outpatient clinic with a parental concern for DP3-14 moExclusion criteria consisted of children aged >14 mo or <3 mo and other forms of cranial deformation, such as cranial synostosisDifferences in ODDI for risk factors for DPNegative correlation between age and ODDI; positive correlation between ODDI and position preference right and position preference left No association between ODDI and developmental delay, family history of DP, sex, and torticollis

aDP: deformational plagiocephaly.

bOR: odds ratio.

cRR: risk ratio.

dNR: not reported.

eNICU: neonatal intensive care unit.

fOCLR: oblique cranial length ratio.

gTORCH: toxoplasmosis, other (including infections such as syphilis, varicella-zoster, and parvovirus B19), rubella, cytomegalovirus, and herpes simplex virus.

hNBPP: neonatal brachial plexus palsy.

iDDH: developmental dysplasia of the hip.

jODDI: oblique diameter difference index.

Demographic Factors

Age

The study by van Cruchten et al [9] reported a negative correlation between age and oblique diameter difference index (a biomarker for DP). However, the study by Sheu et al [38] (which assessed factors associated with a 9-fold increase in plagiocephaly between 1999 and 2007 in Texas, United States) reported no association between age and DP. Finally, the study by Roberts et al [37], which assessed DP in children with ventriculoperitoneal shunts, reported that being aged 12 to 16 years at the time of shunt insertion was associated with DP.

Sex

Of the 19 studies, 4 (21%) demonstrated an association between male sex and DP [33,36,39,44], 1 (5%) reported borderline association [37], and 7 (37%) reported no association between male sex and DP [9,28-30,32,35,38]. Of these 12 studies, 6 (50%) [29,30,33,36,39,43] reported ORs, and a meta-analysis of these ORs revealed interstudy heterogeneity (I2=68.5%; Q statistic=15.89; df=6).

The pooled fixed and random effects ORs for DP related to male sex were 1.71 (95% CI 1.43-2.04; P<.001) and 1.51 (95% CI 1.07-2.12; P=.02), respectively (Figure 2A [29,30,33,36,39,43]). Asymmetry analysis of the funnel plot excluded publication bias (P=.12; Figure 2B).

Figure 2

Meta-analysis and funnel plot for male sex. (A) Forest plot of odds ratios for deformational plagiocephaly related to male sex with fixed and random effects. (B) Funnel plot with linear regression test of asymmetry. The blue line indicates random effects. *Mild to moderate deformational plagiocephaly (DP; univariate analysis); **severe DP (univariate analysis).

Figure image at the original source: open the original paper. This file is not included in this text import.
Race

Race was investigated by Tang et al [40], who included a cohort of children with brachial plexus palsy. In this group, race was not associated with DP that developed after brachial plexus injury.

Developmental Factors

Developmental Delay

Developmental delay was investigated as a risk factor for DP by van Cruchten et al [9], who concluded that developmental delay was not associated with DP.

Developmental Dysplasia of the Hip

Developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) was investigated as a risk factor for DP by Valkama et al [41], who assessed the prevalence of DP in children with DDH. DDH was associated with DP compared to controls without DDH.

Head Circumference

Head circumference was investigated by Solani et al [39], who concluded that it was associated with DP (OR 1.22, 95% CI 1.06-1.40).

Motor Milestones

Reaching fewer motor milestones by age 6 months was investigated as a risk factor by 2 (11%) of the 19 included studies [27,30]. The first study reported that reaching fewer motor milestones by age 6 months was associated with DP (adjusted OR [aOR] 2.35, 95% CI 1.25-4.42) [27]. The second study found an association between delay in motor development and DP [30]. A meta-analysis of the ORs from these studies identified no interstudy heterogeneity (I2=0%; Q statistic=1.67; df=3; Figure 3A [27,30]).

The pooled fixed and random effects ORs for DP related to delayed motor milestones were both 2.56 (95% CI 1.66-3.96; P<.001). Asymmetry analysis of the funnel plot excluded publication bias (P=.18; Figure 3B).

Figure 3

Meta-analysis and funnel plot for reaching fewer motor milestones by age 6 months. (A) Forest plot of odds ratios for deformational plagiocephaly related to reaching fewer motor milestones by age 6 months with fixed and random effects. (B) Funnel plot with linear regression test of asymmetry. The blue line indicates fixed effects. *Adjusted OR (aOR) for deformational plagiocephaly (DP; multivariate analysis); **odds ratio (OR) for mild to moderate DP (only univariate analysis available); ***aOR for severe DP (multivariate analysis).

Figure image at the original source: open the original paper. This file is not included in this text import.
Overweight and Underweight

Being overweight at diagnosis of DP was investigated as a risk factor for DP by Kim et al [30], who reported that being overweight at diagnosis was not associated with DP. The same study reported that being underweight at diagnosis was also not associated with DP.

Dietary Factors

Bottle-Only Feeding

Bottle-only feeding was investigated by Kim et al [30], who demonstrated that bottle-only feeding was associated with DP (aOR 4.65, 95% CI 2.70-8.00).

Breast Feeding

The duration of exclusive breast feeding was investigated by Aarnivala et al [27], who demonstrated that the duration of exclusive breast feeding was not associated with DP.

Formula Feeding

Formula feeding was investigated by Weernink et al [43], who reported that children who developed DP by age 2 to 4 months were more likely to be formula fed (aOR 1.51, 95% CI 1.00-2.27).

Vitamin D Intake

Vitamin D intake in infants was investigated by Weernink et al [43], who reported that children who developed DP by age 2 to 4 months were more likely to have insufficient vitamin D intake (aOR 7.15, 95% CI 3.77-13.54).

Maternal Factors

Maternal Age

Of the 19 included studies, 3 (16%) demonstrated an association between maternal age and DP [28,32,43]. However, 3 (16%) of the 19 studies reported no association [30,38,40]. Only 1 (17%) of these 6 studies reported an OR indicating that increased maternal age was a protective factor for the development of DP (OR 0.94, 95% CI 0.91-0.97) [43].

Maternal Education Level

Of the 19 included studies, 3 (16%) demonstrated an association between maternal education level and DP [33,38,43], and 1 (5%) reported no significant association [28]. Only 2 (67%) of the 3 studies reported ORs [33,43]. Of these 2 studies, 1 (50%) indicated that low maternal education level was an adverse factor in the development of DP (aOR 1.97, 95% CI 1.19-3.26) [43], while 1 (50%) suggested that postsecondary education was not a protective factor (OR 0.71, 95% CI 0.43-1.16) [33].

The OR from the former was used in a meta-analysis with the inverse OR from the latter, which demonstrated no interstudy heterogeneity (I2=0%; Q statistic=0.86; df=1; Figure 4 [33,43]). The pooled fixed effects OR for DP related to low education level was 1.66 (95% CI 1.17-2.37; P<.005).

Figure 4

Meta-analysis for maternal education level. *Reciprocal odds ratio (OR) for postsecondary education.

Figure image at the original source: open the original paper. This file is not included in this text import.
Maternal Language Barriers

The study by Ballardini et al [28] investigated whether infants with mothers who experience a language barrier when receiving medical advice had a higher rate of DP. The study suggested that maternal language barrier was not associated with DP in the infant.

Maternal Race and Country of Origin

Of the 19 included studies, 3 (16%) investigated whether DP was associated with maternal race and country of origin [28,38,43]. All 3 studies suggested that maternal race and country of origin was not associated with DP in the infant.

Length of Time in the Country of Study

The study by Mawji et al [33] investigated whether the length of time spent by mothers in the country in which the study was conducted was associated with DP. The study reported that length of time in the country of study was not associated with DP.

Pacifier Use

Pacifier use by mothers in healthy infants was investigated as a risk factor for DP by Aarnivala et al [27], who reported that pacifier use was not associated with DP.

Tummy Time Instructions

The study by Ballardini et al [28] investigated whether DP was associated with mothers receiving instructions about tummy time. The study reported that receiving instructions about tummy time was not associated with DP.

Medical and Surgical Factors

Bronchopulmonary Dysplasia

Bronchopulmonary dysplasia was investigated as a risk factor for DP by Ifflaender et al [29], who included a cohort of infants born prematurely. The study reported that bronchopulmonary dysplasia was not associated with DP.

Chronic Lung Disease

Chronic lung disease grade II was investigated by Launonen et al [34], who also assessed DP risk factors in infants born prematurely. The study reported that chronic lung disease grade II was associated with DP.

Family History of DP

Family history of DP was investigated by van Cruchten et al [9]. The study suggested that family history of DP was not associated with DP.

History of Illness

History of illness was investigated by Aarnivala et al [27]. The study suggested that history of illness was not associated with DP.

Intracranial Hemorrhage

Intracranial hemorrhage was investigated by Ifflaender et al [29], who assessed DP risk factors in infants born prematurely. The study reported that intracranial hemorrhage was not associated with DP.

Macrocephaly

Macrocephaly at birth was investigated by Kim et al [30]. The study suggested that macrocephaly at birth was not associated with DP. Macrocephaly at diagnosis of DP was also investigated, and it was found that this factor too was not associated with DP (OR 1.38, 95% CI 0.63-3.04) [30]. A lack of association was reported for subgroups with mild to moderate DP (OR 1.48, 95% CI 0.62-3.53) and severe DP (OR 1.19, 95% CI 0.04-3.58) [30].

Mechanical Ventilation

Of the 19 included studies, 2 (11%) demonstrated an association between mechanical ventilation and the development of DP in preterm infants [29,34]. Of these 2 studies, 1 (50%) reported an OR of 1.10 (95% CI 1.00-1.14) for mechanical ventilation [34]. The other study also suggested that the duration of total respiratory support (continuous positive airway pressure and intermittent mandatory ventilation) and the duration of continuous positive airway pressure alone were associated with DP, while intermittent mandatory ventilation alone was not associated with DP [29].

Necrotizing Enterocolitis

Necrotizing enterocolitis was investigated by Ifflaender et al [29], who included a cohort of infants born prematurely. The study reported that necrotizing enterocolitis was not associated with DP.

Obesity

Obesity at diagnosis of DP was investigated by Kim et al [30]. Obesity at diagnosis of DP was defined as BMI >97th percentile. The study concluded that obesity at diagnosis of DP was associated with DP (aOR 2.45, 95% CI 1.02-5.90). The study also suggested that obesity at diagnosis of DP was associated with severe DP (aOR 4.10, 95% CI 1.42-11.90) but was not associated with mild to moderate DP (aOR 2.29, 95% CI 0.86-6.05).

Occipital Shunt Placement

Occipital shunt placement was investigated by Roberts et al [37], who concluded that occipital shunt placement was associated with DP compared to frontal shunt placement.

Torticollis

Torticollis was investigated by 3 (16%) of the 19 included studies, all of which reported no association between torticollis and DP [9,26,38].

Positional and Environmental Factors

Carriers, Bouncers, Car Seats, and Headrests

Time spent in carriers, bouncers, and car seats was investigated by Aarnivala et al [27], who reported that time spent in carriers, bouncers, and car seats was not associated with DP. Firmness of headrest was investigated by Solani et al [39], who reported that firmness of headrest was not associated with DP (OR 1.31, 95% CI 0.72-2.37).

Change of Crib End

Change of crib end (ie, alternating the infant’s sleeping position by placing their head at different ends of the crib) was investigated as a risk factor for DP by 2 (11%) of the 19 included studies [33,42]. Both studies suggested that change of crib end was not associated with DP.

Feeding Position

Feeding position was investigated as a risk factor for DP by 2 (11%) of the 19 included studies [33,42]; both demonstrated that feeding position was not associated with DP.

Latency in Head Turning

Latency in head turning was investigated by Leung et al [31], who concluded that latency in head turning was not associated with DP.

Playing Position

Playing position was investigated by van Vlimmeren et al [42], who demonstrated that playing position was not associated with DP.

Head Position Preference

Head position preference was investigated by 6 (32%) of the 19 included studies, all of which demonstrated an association between head position preference and DP [9,27,28,31,33,42]. Of these 6 studies, 2 (33%) [33,34] reported ORs, and a meta-analysis of these ORs revealed negligible interstudy heterogeneity (I2=27.6%; Q statistic=2.76; df=3) (Figure 5A [33,34]). The pooled fixed and random effects ORs for DP related to head position preference were 4.75 (95% CI 3.36-6.73; P<.001) and 4.96 (95% CI 3.10-7.93; P<.001), respectively.

Asymmetry analysis of the funnel plot excluded publication bias (P=.28; Figure 5B).

Figure 5

Meta-analysis and funnel plot for head position preference. (A) Forest plot of odds ratios for deformational plagiocephaly related to head position preference with fixed and random effects. (B) Funnel plot with linear regression test of asymmetry. The blue line indicates fixed effects.

Figure image at the original source: open the original paper. This file is not included in this text import.
Sleeping Position

Sleeping position (supine vs prone) was investigated by 3 (16%) of the 19 included studies [28,33,39]. Of these 3 studies, 2 (67%) demonstrated an association between supine sleeping and DP [33,39], while 1 (33%) reported a protective effect from prone sleeping (OR 0.13, 95% CI 0.03-0.40) or side sleeping (OR 0.22, 95% CI 0.05-0.71) [28]. The ORs from 2 (67%) [33,39] of the 3 studies were used with the inverse OR from the third study [28] in a meta-analysis, which demonstrated negligible interstudy heterogeneity (I2=19.1%; Q statistic=2.47; df=3; Figure 6A [28,33,39]).

The pooled fixed and random effects ORs for DP related to sleeping position were 3.12 (95% CI 2.21-4.39; P<.001) and 3.22 (95% CI 2.14-4.84; P<.001), respectively. Asymmetry analysis of the funnel plot excluded publication bias (P=.20; Figure 6B).

Figure 6

Meta-analysis and funnel plot for supine sleeping position. (A) Forest plot of odds ratios for deformational plagiocephaly related to supine sleeping position with fixed and random effects. (B) Funnel plot with linear regression test of asymmetry. The blue line indicates fixed effects. *Supine versus prone; **reciprocal prone versus supine; ***reciprocal side versus supine.

Figure image at the original source: open the original paper. This file is not included in this text import.
Time Spent Prone on the Floor

The study by Aarnivala et al [27] investigated time spent prone on the floor and reported no association with DP.

Tummy Time

Tummy time was investigated by 4 (21%) of the 19 included studies [28,30,33,42]. Of these 4 studies, 1 (25%) reported an association between reduced tummy time when awake and DP (aOR 3.51, 95% CI 1.71-7.21) [30]. The remaining studies (3/4, 75%) reported that tummy time was not associated with DP but provided no ORs [28,33,42].

Time Spent Outdoors

Time spent outdoors was investigated by Weernink et al [43], who reported no association with DP.

Time Spent Supine on the Floor

Time spent supine on the floor was investigated as a risk factor for DP by Aarnivala et al [27], who reported that children with DP at age 12 months spent more time supine on the floor at age 6 months.

Summary of Nonobstetric Factors Associated With DP

A summary of 16 nonobstetric factors associated with DP is presented in Table 2. ORs are provided for 12 (75%) of these 16 nonobstetric factors.

Table 2

Odds ratios (ORs) for factors associated with deformational plagiocephaly. ORs are reported from single studies unless marked with a superscript (“a” or “b”) indicating pooled ORs from fixed or random effects meta-analyses.

FactorsOR (95% CI)References
Insufficient vitamin D intake7.15 (3.77-13.54)[42]
Head position preference4.75a (3.36-6.73)[33,34]
Bottle-only feeding4.65 (2.70-8.00)[30]
Reduced tummy time3.51 (1.71-7.21)[30]
Sleeping position3.12 (2.21-4.39)[28,33,39]
Fewer motor milestones by age 6 mo2.56a (1.66-3.96)[27,30]
Obesity (BMI >97th percentile)2.45 (1.02-5.90)[30]
Maternal education level1.66a (1.17-2.37)[33,43]
Male sex1.51b (1.07-2.12)[29,30,33,36,43]
Formula feeding1.51 (1.00-2.27)[43]
Head circumference1.22 (1.06-1.40)[39]
Mechanical ventilation1.10 (1.00-1.14)[34]
Chronic lung disease grade IINRc[34]
DDHdNR[41]
Maternal ageNR[28,32,43]
Time spent supineNR[27]

aOR from a fixed effects meta-analysis where interstudy heterogeneity was <50%.

bOR from a random effects meta-analysis where interstudy heterogeneity was ≥50%.

cNR: not reported.

dDDH: developmental dysplasia of the hip.

Source: Results Source: Results Source: Results Source: Results Source: Results Source: Results Source: Results Source: Results

Discussion: Conclusions

In summary, this study provides the most comprehensive meta-analytic assessment of nonobstetric factors associated with DP published to date. It offers 11 evidence-based recommendations that can be adopted by health care systems globally to reduce the prevalence of DP. Future research should focus on investigating factors for which the literature is conflicting but quantitative data are lacking to enable meta-analyses to be performed; for example, maternal age was the only factor reported to be protective against DP, but conflicting studies reported that there was no association without providing quantitative data.

Thus, maternal age as a protective factor for DP should be investigated further to provide quantitative data for meta-analytic approaches to determine its protective effect. Further research should also address the nature of specific relationships between risk factors and DP; for example, both bottle-only feeding and formula feeding have been associated with DP. Studies should focus on understanding the nature of this relationship, that is, whether this relationship is due to mechanical forces associated with bottle-feeding or whether a reduction in, or lack of, breast milk intake or a lack of complimentary foods alongside breast milk results in nutritional differences that impact skull development [66].

As our study also highlighted an association between obesity and DP, research on other early-life or environmental exposures should be conducted to elucidate their effects on growth and development, particularly skull growth and head shape [67,68]. Finally, randomized controlled trials, although considered the gold standard study design for obtaining reliable evidence of an intervention’s effectiveness, should not be conducted for the interventions herein that relate to risk factors for DP development that have already been assessed through meta-analysis.

However, randomized controlled trials could provide further evidence for an intervention: if ethically appropriate: where the evidence for a particular risk factor is relatively weak, such as when only a single cohort study has provided the evidence for a risk factor’s influence on the development of DP.

Source: Conclusions
Authors’ abstract

Background

Plagiocephaly is defined as an asymmetrical distortion of the skull, resulting in an oblique trapezoid or parallelogram head shape. Deformational plagiocephaly (DP) is caused by forces acting on one side of the back of the head, distorting normal skull symmetry.

Objective

The aims of this systematic review and meta-analysis were to critically assess the evidence for nonobstetric risk factors for DP and to make evidence-based recommendations for reducing the prevalence of DP.

Methods

The selection criterion was studies reporting risk factors for DP. Case reviews, case series, expert opinions, and systematic reviews were excluded. PubMed and Web of Science were searched from August 21, 2010, to August 21, 2022. Publication bias was assessed using funnel plots. Meta-analyses were presented using forest plots.

Results

A total of 19 studies (cohort studies: n=13, 68%; case-control studies: n=5, 26%; and cross-sectional studies: n=1, 5%) with a total of 14,808 participants were included. Of the 43 investigated potential nonobstetric factors, 16 (37%) were associated with DP. Of these 16 factors, 12 (75%) had odds ratios (ORs) with 95% CIs not crossing 1: insufficient vitamin D intake (OR 7.15, 95% CI 3.77-13.54), head position preference (OR 4.75, 95% CI 3.36-6.73), bottle-only feeding (OR 4.65, 95% CI 2.70-8.00), reduced tummy time (OR 3.51, 95% CI 1.71-7.21), sleeping position (OR 3.12, 95% CI 2.21-4.39), fewer motor milestones reached by the age of 6 months (OR 2.56, 95% CI 1.66-3.96), obesity (OR 2.45, 95% CI 1.02-5.90), maternal education level (OR 1.66, 95% CI 1.17-2.37), male sex (OR 1.51, 95% CI 1.07-2.12), formula feeding (OR 1.51, 95% CI 1.00-2.27), head circumference (OR 1.22, 95% CI 1.06-1.40), and mechanical ventilation (OR 1.10, 95% CI 1.00-1.14).

No evidence of publication bias was detected.

Conclusions

This study provides a comprehensive assessment of the nonobstetric factors associated with DP and presents 11 evidence-based recommendations for reducing its prevalence. The primary limitation is that only publication bias was assessed.

Trial Registration

PROSPERO CRD42020204979; https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/display_record.php? ID=CRD42020204979

Read the full paper

Introduction

Background

Plagiocephaly is defined as an asymmetrical distortion of the skull resulting in an oblique trapezoid or parallelogram head shape when viewed from the vertex position in the axial plane [1]. The severity of skull asymmetry can range from minimal focal flattening on one side of the cranial vault to severe deformation affecting the entire cranial vault, skull base, and facial skeleton. Plagiocephaly arises via 2 main mechanisms: premature fusion of ≥1 of the cranial sutures (craniosynostosis) or external mechanical forces acting on the cranial vault, which results in a distortion of the normally symmetric craniofacial skeleton (deformational plagiocephaly [DP]).

In craniosynostotic plagiocephaly involving any of the paired coronal or lambdoid sutures, the restriction of skull vault growth occurs perpendicular to the fused suture (Virchow’s law) [2,3]. Isolated craniosynostosis involving premature fusion of a single coronal suture results in an anterior plagiocephaly with brow retrusion on the affected side; similarly, craniosynostosis of a single lambdoid suture will restrict posterior cranial growth on the same side. The asymmetry is often accentuated as the remaining unfused sutures expand to enable accommodation of the rapidly growing infant brain.

The majority of patients with craniosynostosis do not have an identifiable genetic cause, but this proportion is increased in patients with >1 suture involved [2,3].

Alternatively: and far more commonly: plagiocephaly is caused by deformational forces acting on one side of the back of the head, which distorts the normal symmetry of the skull in the absence of skull growth restriction due to craniosynostosis [4]. This deformity is characterized by a parallelogram-type deformity. This appears clinically as mild to severe occipital flattening, with or without ipsilateral anterior shift of the ear and orbital involvement [5]. The flattening of the posterior neurocranium, resulting from the external forces applied to the head, has led to the condition also being referred to as “flat head syndrome” [6].

The importance of external forces can be seen in the close relationship between DP and sleeping position [7], among other factors that may influence external head forces [8-12].

Objectives

Since the 1980s, “back to sleep” campaigns have successfully publicized the benefits of supine sleeping for reducing the risk of sleep-related death, including sudden infant death syndrome [13]. Although these campaigns reduced the incidence of sudden infant death syndrome by 40%, an undesirable consequence has been an increase in the referrals of cases of DP, leading to more referrals to specialist centers [14,15]. The majority of cases of DP will resolve without intervention, and surgical treatment is not required [16].

However, in a subset of children, DP persists, even into teenage years [17]. Although physiotherapy and helmet therapy may play a role in improving head shape and limiting other long-term effects [18,19], understanding the factors that increase the risk of DP may help to prevent DP from developing. The aims of this systematic review and meta-analysis were to critically assess the evidence for risk factors for DP and to make evidence-based recommendations for reducing the prevalence of DP.

This study was previously presented as a meeting abstract at the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health Conference on June 15, 2021.

Methods

The study protocol, analysis, and reporting were conducted in line with the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) 2020 guidelines [20-22]. The protocol was registered with PROSPERO (CRD42020204979).

Search Strategy

A search of PubMed and Web of Science was performed covering the period from August 21, 2010, to August 21, 2022 (this included an initial search from August 21, 2010, to August 20, 2020, and an update search from August 21, 2010, to August 20, 2022, to ensure that the list of included studies was as up to date as possible). The combination of PubMed and Web of Science provides >97.5% coverage of published literature [23,24].

To balance comprehensive coverage with a pragmatic approach to ensure that the study was completed with limited available resources, additional databases were not searched, and hand searching and gray literature searches were also not performed. The search terms included “plagiocephaly” AND “risk factor.”

Study Eligibility

Study titles and abstracts were screened and assessed for relevance by a single reviewer (CRTH, NB, or AN). Specifically, original studies were included if they assessed risk factors for DP. Studies in a non-English language, those involving nonhuman subjects, and low-quality or nonoriginal studies (meeting abstracts, reviews, case series, case reports, and editorials) were excluded. Duplicates were identified by assessing study titles and removed manually by CRTH. Full-text review was performed after screening by a single reviewer (CRTH, NB, or AN).

Studies not reporting nonobstetric risk factors for DP were excluded. Studies reporting preventive measures such as tummy time were included. However, studies involving treatments such as physical therapy and helmet therapy were not included. As screening was performed by a single reviewer, there were no discrepancies to be resolved.

Data Extraction and Reporting

Data extraction and reporting followed the PRISMA guidelines. However, due to resource limitations, data from eligible full-text articles were extracted by a single reviewer (CRTH, NB, or AN). The main outcomes of interest were odds ratios (ORs) and risk ratios (RRs) with 95% CIs, or significant associations, for risk factors for DP (or biomarkers for DP; eg, oblique diameter difference index). These outcomes were split into factors that were associated with DP and those that were not. Other items extracted from the eligible studies included authors, country of study, funding source, study design, study aims, total participants, percentage female, population assessed, age at baseline, and selection criteria.

Meta-Analysis

A meta-analysis of ORs and RRs for factors associated with DP was performed. The inconsistency index (Ι2) and a Q statistic for chi-square significance for specific df were calculated to assess interstudy heterogeneity. Both fixed effects and random effects were reported. P values for 95% CIs were calculated. Excel (Microsoft Corp) and Prism (GraphPad Software) were used for statistical analysis.

Funnel Plots

Publication bias was assessed using funnel plots of ORs and RRs for DP risk factors against study precision (1/SE). The Egger test for asymmetry was conducted using linear regression, with P<.05 indicating publication bias [25].

Results

Overview

The searches of PubMed and Web of Science yielded 159 articles; after removing 35 (22%) duplicates, 124 (78%) articles were screened based on abstract content. Of these 124 articles, 77 (62.1%) were not relevant. Full-text screening of the remaining 47 articles resulted in the exclusion of 20 (43%) irrelevant articles (these did not report nonobstetric risk factors for DP), 3 (6%) non-English articles, and 5 (11%) articles that were not accessible. Thus, of the initial 159 articles, 19 (11.9%) were eligible for inclusion in this study (Figure 1).

The characteristics of the included studies are presented in Table 1.

Figure 1

PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) 2020 flow diagram for study eligibility and inclusion.

Figure image at the original source: open the original paper. This file is not included in this text import.
Table 1

Characteristics of the included studies.

Study; countryFunding sourceStudy designStudy aimsParticipants, n (% female)Population assessedAge at baselineSelection criteriaOutcomesFactors associated with DPa Factors not associated with DP
Aarnivala et al [26]; FinlandAlma and KA Snellman Foundation and The Foundation for Pediatric Research, FinlandRetrospective cohort studyTo assess risk factors for the development of DP and torticollis155 (51)Healthy newborns<72 h from birthHealthy newborns born between February 2012 and September 2013; newborns were excluded if they had chromosomal anomalies, cleft lip or palate, or craniosynostosisORsb and RRsc for risk factors for DPNRdRisk of developing DP was not associated with torticollis
Aarnivala et al [27]; FinlandAlma and KA Snellman FoundationProspective cohort studyTo assess risk factors for cranial deformation by measuring cranial asymmetry from age 3 to 12 mo using 3D stereophotogrammetry99 (47)Healthy newbornsRecruited at birthHealthy newborns included at birth residing within 20 minutes’ driving distance from Oulu University Hospital; infants with craniosynostosis, cleft lip and palate, or syndromic features were excludedORs and RRs for risk factors for DPDP at age 6 mo associated with position preference and imbalance in head rotation at age 3 mo; at age 6 mo, DP associated with reaching fewer motor milestones at age 6 mo; at age 12 mo, DP associated with position preference at age 3 mo and imbalance in head rotation at age 3 mo and 6 mo; at age 12 mo, DP associated with fewer motor milestones and spending more time supine on the floor at age 6 mo; position preference at age 3 mo associated with DP at age 12 mo; at age 6 mo, DP associated with position preference at age 3 mo and fewer motor milestones reached at age 6 mo; at age 12 mo, DP associated with position preference at age 3 moPosition preference at age 6 mo was not associated with DP at age 12 mo; there was no association between DP at age 12 mo and imbalance in head rotation at age 3 mo; no association with DP was also observed for primary sleeping position, time spent in carrier, bouncers, or car seats, time spent prone on the floor, pacifier use, illness history (acute otitis media and conditions requiring prolonged hospitalization), and duration of full breastfeeding
Ballardini et al [28]; ItalyPediatric department of the University of Ferrara in Ferrara, ItalyProspective cohort studyTo assess prevalence and risk factors for DP in full-term infants283 (53)Healthy newbornsAll infants: mean 11.6 (range 9.4-12.9) wk; infants with DP: mean 11.7 (range 10.0-12.8) wk; infants without DP: mean 11.6 (range 9.4-12.9) wkHealthy infants born at term presenting at a public immunization clinic in Ferrara at age 8 to 12 wk were included; infants affected by craniosynostosis, malformations, or neurological diseases or those admitted to the NICUe were excludedORs and RRs for risk factors for DPMaternal and infant risk factors associated with DP included maternal age, supine sleeping position, and head position preferenceMaternal and infant risk factors not associated with DP included infant sex, maternal origin, maternal education level, breast milk feeding, changing crib end, tummy time, and instruction about tummy time
Ifflaender et al [29]; GermanyThe Else Kröner-Fresenius FoundationCross-sectional studyTo assess head shape to determine the prevalence of symmetrical and asymmetrical head deformities and identify possible risk factors195 (48)Healthy newbornsMean postmenstrual age: 38.4 (SD 0.9) wkPreterm infants discharged from an intermediate care unit of a tertiary neonatal clinic in Dresden from April 2011 to January 2013 were included; all infants were included that were present on the ward at the time of measurement; those with peripheral cannula at the scalp or requiring supplemental oxygen, were excludedORs and RRs for risk factors for DPCranial vault asymmetry index ([diagonal A: diagonal B and diagonal A] × 100, where diagonal A >diagonal B) at term-equivalent age was higher (4.1%, IQR 1.9%-6.5%) in very preterm infants compared to late preterm infants and term infants; moderate or severe DP at term-equivalent age was associated with intracranial hemorrhage in preterm infants; duration of total respiratory support was higher in cases of DP compared to controls; duration of continuous positive airway pressure therapy was longer in cases of DP than in controlsNo association with DP was observed for sex, bronchopulmonary dysplasia, necrotizing enterocolitis, and duration of intermittent mandatory ventilation
Kim et al [30]; South KoreaNRCase-control studyTo determine risk factors for DP and its severity, including the association between DP and infant obesity as defined by BMI135 (40)Infants with cranial deformation on physical examination, with age: and sex-matched controls randomly selected from the national health screening system for infants and children (confirmed to have no cranial deformation on physical examination)2-12 moInfants aged 2-12 mo at the time of diagnosis of DP were included; infants with neuroimaging results positive for craniosynostosis were excluded; infants with insufficient clinical data, congenital muscular torticollis, congenital anomalies (eg, craniofacial or chromosomal anomalies), or birth injury were also excluded; age: and sex-matched controls (confirmed to have no cranial deformation on physical examination) were randomly selected from the national health screening systemORs and RRs for risk factors for DPFactors associated with DP included bottle-only feeding, reduced tummy time when awake, delayed motor development, and obesity at diagnosisFactors not associated with DP included; infant male sex; maternal age; macrocephaly at birth; and macrocephaly, underweight, or overweight at the time of diagnosis
Leung et al [31]; AustraliaNRProspective cohort studyTo assess association between DP and head orientation or head strength94 (59)Healthy newbornsMean 21.40 (SD 2.29) dHealthy newborns, born at full term (37-42 wk) between June 2011 and July 2013; infants were excluded for reasons related to low birth weight (<2500 g), congenital muscular torticollis, craniosynostosis, neurological insult, or other medical or orthopedic conditionsCorrelation between risk factor severity and DP severityDP at age 9 wk was associated with asymmetrical head orientation duration at age 3 wk and 6 wk; DP at age 9 wk was significantly associated with asymmetrical head orientation strength at age 3 wk and 6 wkNo association between DP and latency to turn head
Maniglio et al [32]; ItalyNRProspective cohort studyTo assess factors associated with DP to improve screening strategies to identify infants at risk of developing severe deformation4337 (NR)Infants with DP and controls without DP6-12 wkInfants born at the San Pietro Fatebenefratelli Hospital in Rome between January 2017 and September 2018 were included; infants with congenital deformations, born before 24 wk gestation, and infants who needed long intensive care treatment were excludedORs for risk factors for DPMaternal age was associated with DPMale sex was not associated with DP
Mawji et al [33]; CanadaThe Faculty of Graduate Studies at the University of Calgary in Calgary, Alberta, provided CAD $3000 (US $2670) for data collectionProspective cohort studyTo assess potential risk factors for DP in infants aged 7-12 wk in Calgary440 (40.7)Healthy full-term infants7-12 wk Healthy full-term infants (born at ≥37 wk gestation) ranging from age 7 to 12 wk who presented for immunization at a 2-mo well-child clinic in Calgary were includedORs and RRs for risk factors for DPSignificant difference in incidence of DP in infants placed supine to sleep compared with sleep in other positions (including prone; side; or a combination of supine, prone, or side); DP also associated with head position preference (right and left), maternal education level, and supine sleep positionNo association of DP with average length of time in Canada; infant feeding position; length of tummy time received; male infant sex; and mothers who had a language barrier
Nuysink et al [34]; NetherlandsNRProspective cohort studyTo assess predictive factors for DP in infants at corrected age >6 mo120 (45.8)Newborns admitted to the NICU at gestational age <30 wk or birthweight <1000 g<1 wkEligible infants were born in or referred to the level III neonatal intensive care unit within 1 week of birth between January 2009 and October 2010; infants born at gestational age <30 wk or birth weight <1000 g who visited the neonatal follow-up clinic were included; infants diagnosed with a disease or dysfunction leading to symptomatic asymmetry, such as a central nervous system disorder or congenital malformation, were excludedORs for risk factors for DPAssociation between DP and mechanical ventilation and chronic lung disease grade II in the neonatal periodNR
Launonen et al [35]; FinlandThe University of Oulu Scholarship Foundation, the Orthodontic Section of the Finnish Dental Association Apollonia, the Emil Aaltonen Foundation, the Alma, and KA Snellman Foundation, the Finnish Medical Foundation, and the Foundation for Pediatric Research in FinlandCase-control studyTo use 3D stereophotogrammetry to assess cranial growth, molding, and incidence of DP in preterm children compared to term-born children68 (32)Healthy newbornsPreterm (mean gestational age): 32.7 wk; term (mean gestational age): 40.0 wkInfants were considered eligible if they had no cheilopalatoschisis, craniosynostosis, or dysmorphic features and if they resided within Oulu region, Finland; all participants were born between 2012 and 2015 at Oulu University Hospital; the control group was randomly selected from a previously collected nonintervention cohort by computer-based random selection and matched for sexOCLRf mean differenceNRNo difference in head shape (OCLR) between preterm and full-term children or between sexes
Pogliani et al [36]; ItalyNRRetrospective cohort studyTo assess risk factors for DP at birth413 (50)Healthy newborns<72 h from birthNeonates at gestational age >33 wk born between May 2011 and January 2012; newborns with extreme low birth weight or presenting with major congenital malformations needing NICU transfer were excluded; children of mothers with a documented TORCHg infection were also excludedORs and RRs for risk factors for DPAssociation between DP and male sexNR
Roberts et al [37]; United KingdomNRRetrospective cohort studyTo test the hypothesis that ventriculoperitoneal shunt insertion significantly increases contralateral DP339 (42)Children aged 0-16 y with ventriculoperitoneal shuntsNRChildren aged 0-16 y with at least 1 follow-up scan from the surgical database at the pediatric neurosurgery department of Birmingham Children’s Hospital between 2006 and 2013; children without imaging were excludedORs and RRs for risk factors for DPDP was associated with occipital shunt placement; a statistically significant difference in the probability of becoming plagiocephalic between neonates and children aged 12-16 y was observed; boys were more likely to develop shunt-associated plagiocephaly than girlsNo difference in DP between neonates and infants, neonates and children aged 3-5 y, neonates and children aged 1-3 y, and neonates and children aged 5-12 y
Sheu et al [38]; United StatesCooperative agreement from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (U01DD000494) and Title V Maternal and Child Health Block Grant funds from the Health Resources and Services AdministrationRetrospective cohort studyTo assess factors that may explain a 9-fold increase in plagiocephaly in Texas from 1999 to 20076295 (38)Infants with DPNRCases identified using the Texas Birth Defects Registry with a definite diagnosis of DP (British Paediatric Association code 754.050), born between January 1, 1999, and December 31, 2007; cases of plagiocephaly with craniosynostosis were excludedMean difference or percentage difference for risk factors for DPLower maternal education level was associated with DPNo association of DP with maternal age or race and ethnicity, infant sex; mean age at DP diagnosis did not significantly change over time
Solani et al [39]; IranGrant funding from the Vice-Chancellor for Research, Kashan University of Medical Sciences, Kashan, IranCase-control studyTo determine the risk factors of positional plagiocephaly in healthy infants300 (NR)Healthy Iranian infants8-12 wkHealthy full-term (gestational age >37 wk) infants aged 8-12 wk who were referred to the pediatric neurology clinic at Shahid Beheshti Hospital in Kashan, affiliated with Kashan University of Medical Sciences, were includedORs for risk factors for DPFactors associated with DP included male sex, head circumference, and supine sleeping positionFirmness of headrest was not associated with DP
Tang et al [40]; United StatesNRProspective cohort studyTo assess the prevalence of DP in infants with NBPPh and spontaneous recovery from DP28 (50)Full-term infants aged >3 mo and <1 y with NBPPMean 3 (SD 3) moFull-term infants aged >3 mo and <1 y with NBPP; infants with neurological or congenital comorbidities in addition to NBPP, helmet therapy for plagiocephaly, and surgical procedures related to NBPP were excluded; infants with craniosynostosis were also excludedMean difference or percentage difference for risk factors for DPNRMaternal age and race (Black or White) were not associated with DP
Valkama et al [41]; FinlandNRCase-control studyTo assess the prevalence of DP in children with DDHi120 (56)Children with DDH with or without DPChildren with DDH: mean 8.0 (SD 1.4) y; matched controls: mean 7.9 (SD 1.3) yChildren with DDH from among newborn infants born at the Oulu University Hospital in Oulu, Finland, were included; preterm children and children with disabilities were excludedORs and RRs for risk factors for DP10.3% of the children with DDH and only 1.5% of the control children had DPOCLR was equal between children with DDH and controls; no association between side of DDH and DP
Van Vlimmeren et al [42]; NetherlandsGrant from the Scientific Committee of The Royal Dutch Association for Physiotherapy (BU002/10)Prospective cohort studyTo assess skull shape in healthy newborns until age 5.5 y in children with position preference at 7 wk and those without and in children with position preference who received pediatric physical therapy intervention and those who did not380 (53)Healthy newborns<48 h from birthHealthy newborns (gestational age ≥36 wk) born between December 2004 and September 2005 at Hospital Bernhoven; children with congenital muscular torticollis (Kaplan type 2 and 3), dysmorphism, or syndromes were excludedMean difference or percentage difference for risk factors for DPAssociation between DP and position preferenceNo association between potential risk factors (nursing, feeding, sleeping, and playing positioning habits) at age 7 wk and skull deformity at age 24 mo and 5.5 y; a trend toward significance between time spent playing prone (tummy time) at age 7 wk and the ODDIj percentage at age 24 mo
Weernink et al [43]; NetherlandsZonMw, the Netherlands Organization for Health Research and Development (170.992.501)Case-control studyTo assess the influence of adherence to recommendations for vitamin D supplement intake of 10 μg/d (400 IU) in the first months of life (child) on the occurrence of DP of the child at age 2-4 mo823 (46)Infants with DP and those without2-4 moChildren born between November 22, 2009, and June 9, 2010, with mild to severe DP from the Helmet Therapy Assessment in Deformed Skulls study; controls were included from a 2010 survey on infant milk feedingORs and RRs for risk factors for DPInsufficient vitamin D supplement intake during early infancy was associated with DP; maternal sociodemographic factors associated with DP included mother’s age and mother’s education level; infant factors associated with DP included male sex, formula feeding, and milk formula consumption after birthMaternal sociodemographic factors not significantly associated with DP included mother’s country of birth (other than the Netherlands); infant factors not associated with DP included time child spent outdoors
Van Cruchten et al [9]; NetherlandsNRCohort studyTo assess the impact of risk factors on the type and severity of DP184 (30.4)Infants seen at outpatient clinic with a parental concern for DP3-14 moExclusion criteria consisted of children aged >14 mo or <3 mo and other forms of cranial deformation, such as cranial synostosisDifferences in ODDI for risk factors for DPNegative correlation between age and ODDI; positive correlation between ODDI and position preference right and position preference left No association between ODDI and developmental delay, family history of DP, sex, and torticollis

aDP: deformational plagiocephaly.

bOR: odds ratio.

cRR: risk ratio.

dNR: not reported.

eNICU: neonatal intensive care unit.

fOCLR: oblique cranial length ratio.

gTORCH: toxoplasmosis, other (including infections such as syphilis, varicella-zoster, and parvovirus B19), rubella, cytomegalovirus, and herpes simplex virus.

hNBPP: neonatal brachial plexus palsy.

iDDH: developmental dysplasia of the hip.

jODDI: oblique diameter difference index.

Demographic Factors

Age

The study by van Cruchten et al [9] reported a negative correlation between age and oblique diameter difference index (a biomarker for DP). However, the study by Sheu et al [38] (which assessed factors associated with a 9-fold increase in plagiocephaly between 1999 and 2007 in Texas, United States) reported no association between age and DP. Finally, the study by Roberts et al [37], which assessed DP in children with ventriculoperitoneal shunts, reported that being aged 12 to 16 years at the time of shunt insertion was associated with DP.

Sex

Of the 19 studies, 4 (21%) demonstrated an association between male sex and DP [33,36,39,44], 1 (5%) reported borderline association [37], and 7 (37%) reported no association between male sex and DP [9,28-30,32,35,38]. Of these 12 studies, 6 (50%) [29,30,33,36,39,43] reported ORs, and a meta-analysis of these ORs revealed interstudy heterogeneity (I2=68.5%; Q statistic=15.89; df=6).

The pooled fixed and random effects ORs for DP related to male sex were 1.71 (95% CI 1.43-2.04; P<.001) and 1.51 (95% CI 1.07-2.12; P=.02), respectively (Figure 2A [29,30,33,36,39,43]). Asymmetry analysis of the funnel plot excluded publication bias (P=.12; Figure 2B).

Figure 2

Meta-analysis and funnel plot for male sex. (A) Forest plot of odds ratios for deformational plagiocephaly related to male sex with fixed and random effects. (B) Funnel plot with linear regression test of asymmetry. The blue line indicates random effects. *Mild to moderate deformational plagiocephaly (DP; univariate analysis); **severe DP (univariate analysis).

Figure image at the original source: open the original paper. This file is not included in this text import.
Race

Race was investigated by Tang et al [40], who included a cohort of children with brachial plexus palsy. In this group, race was not associated with DP that developed after brachial plexus injury.

Developmental Factors

Developmental Delay

Developmental delay was investigated as a risk factor for DP by van Cruchten et al [9], who concluded that developmental delay was not associated with DP.

Developmental Dysplasia of the Hip

Developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) was investigated as a risk factor for DP by Valkama et al [41], who assessed the prevalence of DP in children with DDH. DDH was associated with DP compared to controls without DDH.

Head Circumference

Head circumference was investigated by Solani et al [39], who concluded that it was associated with DP (OR 1.22, 95% CI 1.06-1.40).

Motor Milestones

Reaching fewer motor milestones by age 6 months was investigated as a risk factor by 2 (11%) of the 19 included studies [27,30]. The first study reported that reaching fewer motor milestones by age 6 months was associated with DP (adjusted OR [aOR] 2.35, 95% CI 1.25-4.42) [27]. The second study found an association between delay in motor development and DP [30]. A meta-analysis of the ORs from these studies identified no interstudy heterogeneity (I2=0%; Q statistic=1.67; df=3; Figure 3A [27,30]).

The pooled fixed and random effects ORs for DP related to delayed motor milestones were both 2.56 (95% CI 1.66-3.96; P<.001). Asymmetry analysis of the funnel plot excluded publication bias (P=.18; Figure 3B).

Figure 3

Meta-analysis and funnel plot for reaching fewer motor milestones by age 6 months. (A) Forest plot of odds ratios for deformational plagiocephaly related to reaching fewer motor milestones by age 6 months with fixed and random effects. (B) Funnel plot with linear regression test of asymmetry. The blue line indicates fixed effects. *Adjusted OR (aOR) for deformational plagiocephaly (DP; multivariate analysis); **odds ratio (OR) for mild to moderate DP (only univariate analysis available); ***aOR for severe DP (multivariate analysis).

Figure image at the original source: open the original paper. This file is not included in this text import.
Overweight and Underweight

Being overweight at diagnosis of DP was investigated as a risk factor for DP by Kim et al [30], who reported that being overweight at diagnosis was not associated with DP. The same study reported that being underweight at diagnosis was also not associated with DP.

Dietary Factors

Bottle-Only Feeding

Bottle-only feeding was investigated by Kim et al [30], who demonstrated that bottle-only feeding was associated with DP (aOR 4.65, 95% CI 2.70-8.00).

Breast Feeding

The duration of exclusive breast feeding was investigated by Aarnivala et al [27], who demonstrated that the duration of exclusive breast feeding was not associated with DP.

Formula Feeding

Formula feeding was investigated by Weernink et al [43], who reported that children who developed DP by age 2 to 4 months were more likely to be formula fed (aOR 1.51, 95% CI 1.00-2.27).

Vitamin D Intake

Vitamin D intake in infants was investigated by Weernink et al [43], who reported that children who developed DP by age 2 to 4 months were more likely to have insufficient vitamin D intake (aOR 7.15, 95% CI 3.77-13.54).

Maternal Factors

Maternal Age

Of the 19 included studies, 3 (16%) demonstrated an association between maternal age and DP [28,32,43]. However, 3 (16%) of the 19 studies reported no association [30,38,40]. Only 1 (17%) of these 6 studies reported an OR indicating that increased maternal age was a protective factor for the development of DP (OR 0.94, 95% CI 0.91-0.97) [43].

Maternal Education Level

Of the 19 included studies, 3 (16%) demonstrated an association between maternal education level and DP [33,38,43], and 1 (5%) reported no significant association [28]. Only 2 (67%) of the 3 studies reported ORs [33,43]. Of these 2 studies, 1 (50%) indicated that low maternal education level was an adverse factor in the development of DP (aOR 1.97, 95% CI 1.19-3.26) [43], while 1 (50%) suggested that postsecondary education was not a protective factor (OR 0.71, 95% CI 0.43-1.16) [33].

The OR from the former was used in a meta-analysis with the inverse OR from the latter, which demonstrated no interstudy heterogeneity (I2=0%; Q statistic=0.86; df=1; Figure 4 [33,43]). The pooled fixed effects OR for DP related to low education level was 1.66 (95% CI 1.17-2.37; P<.005).

Figure 4

Meta-analysis for maternal education level. *Reciprocal odds ratio (OR) for postsecondary education.

Figure image at the original source: open the original paper. This file is not included in this text import.
Maternal Language Barriers

The study by Ballardini et al [28] investigated whether infants with mothers who experience a language barrier when receiving medical advice had a higher rate of DP. The study suggested that maternal language barrier was not associated with DP in the infant.

Maternal Race and Country of Origin

Of the 19 included studies, 3 (16%) investigated whether DP was associated with maternal race and country of origin [28,38,43]. All 3 studies suggested that maternal race and country of origin was not associated with DP in the infant.

Length of Time in the Country of Study

The study by Mawji et al [33] investigated whether the length of time spent by mothers in the country in which the study was conducted was associated with DP. The study reported that length of time in the country of study was not associated with DP.

Pacifier Use

Pacifier use by mothers in healthy infants was investigated as a risk factor for DP by Aarnivala et al [27], who reported that pacifier use was not associated with DP.

Tummy Time Instructions

The study by Ballardini et al [28] investigated whether DP was associated with mothers receiving instructions about tummy time. The study reported that receiving instructions about tummy time was not associated with DP.

Medical and Surgical Factors

Bronchopulmonary Dysplasia

Bronchopulmonary dysplasia was investigated as a risk factor for DP by Ifflaender et al [29], who included a cohort of infants born prematurely. The study reported that bronchopulmonary dysplasia was not associated with DP.

Chronic Lung Disease

Chronic lung disease grade II was investigated by Launonen et al [34], who also assessed DP risk factors in infants born prematurely. The study reported that chronic lung disease grade II was associated with DP.

Family History of DP

Family history of DP was investigated by van Cruchten et al [9]. The study suggested that family history of DP was not associated with DP.

History of Illness

History of illness was investigated by Aarnivala et al [27]. The study suggested that history of illness was not associated with DP.

Intracranial Hemorrhage

Intracranial hemorrhage was investigated by Ifflaender et al [29], who assessed DP risk factors in infants born prematurely. The study reported that intracranial hemorrhage was not associated with DP.

Macrocephaly

Macrocephaly at birth was investigated by Kim et al [30]. The study suggested that macrocephaly at birth was not associated with DP. Macrocephaly at diagnosis of DP was also investigated, and it was found that this factor too was not associated with DP (OR 1.38, 95% CI 0.63-3.04) [30]. A lack of association was reported for subgroups with mild to moderate DP (OR 1.48, 95% CI 0.62-3.53) and severe DP (OR 1.19, 95% CI 0.04-3.58) [30].

Mechanical Ventilation

Of the 19 included studies, 2 (11%) demonstrated an association between mechanical ventilation and the development of DP in preterm infants [29,34]. Of these 2 studies, 1 (50%) reported an OR of 1.10 (95% CI 1.00-1.14) for mechanical ventilation [34]. The other study also suggested that the duration of total respiratory support (continuous positive airway pressure and intermittent mandatory ventilation) and the duration of continuous positive airway pressure alone were associated with DP, while intermittent mandatory ventilation alone was not associated with DP [29].

Necrotizing Enterocolitis

Necrotizing enterocolitis was investigated by Ifflaender et al [29], who included a cohort of infants born prematurely. The study reported that necrotizing enterocolitis was not associated with DP.

Obesity

Obesity at diagnosis of DP was investigated by Kim et al [30]. Obesity at diagnosis of DP was defined as BMI >97th percentile. The study concluded that obesity at diagnosis of DP was associated with DP (aOR 2.45, 95% CI 1.02-5.90). The study also suggested that obesity at diagnosis of DP was associated with severe DP (aOR 4.10, 95% CI 1.42-11.90) but was not associated with mild to moderate DP (aOR 2.29, 95% CI 0.86-6.05).

Occipital Shunt Placement

Occipital shunt placement was investigated by Roberts et al [37], who concluded that occipital shunt placement was associated with DP compared to frontal shunt placement.

Torticollis

Torticollis was investigated by 3 (16%) of the 19 included studies, all of which reported no association between torticollis and DP [9,26,38].

Positional and Environmental Factors

Carriers, Bouncers, Car Seats, and Headrests

Time spent in carriers, bouncers, and car seats was investigated by Aarnivala et al [27], who reported that time spent in carriers, bouncers, and car seats was not associated with DP. Firmness of headrest was investigated by Solani et al [39], who reported that firmness of headrest was not associated with DP (OR 1.31, 95% CI 0.72-2.37).

Change of Crib End

Change of crib end (ie, alternating the infant’s sleeping position by placing their head at different ends of the crib) was investigated as a risk factor for DP by 2 (11%) of the 19 included studies [33,42]. Both studies suggested that change of crib end was not associated with DP.

Feeding Position

Feeding position was investigated as a risk factor for DP by 2 (11%) of the 19 included studies [33,42]; both demonstrated that feeding position was not associated with DP.

Latency in Head Turning

Latency in head turning was investigated by Leung et al [31], who concluded that latency in head turning was not associated with DP.

Playing Position

Playing position was investigated by van Vlimmeren et al [42], who demonstrated that playing position was not associated with DP.

Head Position Preference

Head position preference was investigated by 6 (32%) of the 19 included studies, all of which demonstrated an association between head position preference and DP [9,27,28,31,33,42]. Of these 6 studies, 2 (33%) [33,34] reported ORs, and a meta-analysis of these ORs revealed negligible interstudy heterogeneity (I2=27.6%; Q statistic=2.76; df=3) (Figure 5A [33,34]). The pooled fixed and random effects ORs for DP related to head position preference were 4.75 (95% CI 3.36-6.73; P<.001) and 4.96 (95% CI 3.10-7.93; P<.001), respectively.

Asymmetry analysis of the funnel plot excluded publication bias (P=.28; Figure 5B).

Figure 5

Meta-analysis and funnel plot for head position preference. (A) Forest plot of odds ratios for deformational plagiocephaly related to head position preference with fixed and random effects. (B) Funnel plot with linear regression test of asymmetry. The blue line indicates fixed effects.

Figure image at the original source: open the original paper. This file is not included in this text import.
Sleeping Position

Sleeping position (supine vs prone) was investigated by 3 (16%) of the 19 included studies [28,33,39]. Of these 3 studies, 2 (67%) demonstrated an association between supine sleeping and DP [33,39], while 1 (33%) reported a protective effect from prone sleeping (OR 0.13, 95% CI 0.03-0.40) or side sleeping (OR 0.22, 95% CI 0.05-0.71) [28]. The ORs from 2 (67%) [33,39] of the 3 studies were used with the inverse OR from the third study [28] in a meta-analysis, which demonstrated negligible interstudy heterogeneity (I2=19.1%; Q statistic=2.47; df=3; Figure 6A [28,33,39]).

The pooled fixed and random effects ORs for DP related to sleeping position were 3.12 (95% CI 2.21-4.39; P<.001) and 3.22 (95% CI 2.14-4.84; P<.001), respectively. Asymmetry analysis of the funnel plot excluded publication bias (P=.20; Figure 6B).

Figure 6

Meta-analysis and funnel plot for supine sleeping position. (A) Forest plot of odds ratios for deformational plagiocephaly related to supine sleeping position with fixed and random effects. (B) Funnel plot with linear regression test of asymmetry. The blue line indicates fixed effects. *Supine versus prone; **reciprocal prone versus supine; ***reciprocal side versus supine.

Figure image at the original source: open the original paper. This file is not included in this text import.
Time Spent Prone on the Floor

The study by Aarnivala et al [27] investigated time spent prone on the floor and reported no association with DP.

Tummy Time

Tummy time was investigated by 4 (21%) of the 19 included studies [28,30,33,42]. Of these 4 studies, 1 (25%) reported an association between reduced tummy time when awake and DP (aOR 3.51, 95% CI 1.71-7.21) [30]. The remaining studies (3/4, 75%) reported that tummy time was not associated with DP but provided no ORs [28,33,42].

Time Spent Outdoors

Time spent outdoors was investigated by Weernink et al [43], who reported no association with DP.

Time Spent Supine on the Floor

Time spent supine on the floor was investigated as a risk factor for DP by Aarnivala et al [27], who reported that children with DP at age 12 months spent more time supine on the floor at age 6 months.

Summary of Nonobstetric Factors Associated With DP

A summary of 16 nonobstetric factors associated with DP is presented in Table 2. ORs are provided for 12 (75%) of these 16 nonobstetric factors.

Table 2

Odds ratios (ORs) for factors associated with deformational plagiocephaly. ORs are reported from single studies unless marked with a superscript (“a” or “b”) indicating pooled ORs from fixed or random effects meta-analyses.

FactorsOR (95% CI)References
Insufficient vitamin D intake7.15 (3.77-13.54)[42]
Head position preference4.75a (3.36-6.73)[33,34]
Bottle-only feeding4.65 (2.70-8.00)[30]
Reduced tummy time3.51 (1.71-7.21)[30]
Sleeping position3.12 (2.21-4.39)[28,33,39]
Fewer motor milestones by age 6 mo2.56a (1.66-3.96)[27,30]
Obesity (BMI >97th percentile)2.45 (1.02-5.90)[30]
Maternal education level1.66a (1.17-2.37)[33,43]
Male sex1.51b (1.07-2.12)[29,30,33,36,43]
Formula feeding1.51 (1.00-2.27)[43]
Head circumference1.22 (1.06-1.40)[39]
Mechanical ventilation1.10 (1.00-1.14)[34]
Chronic lung disease grade IINRc[34]
DDHdNR[41]
Maternal ageNR[28,32,43]
Time spent supineNR[27]

aOR from a fixed effects meta-analysis where interstudy heterogeneity was <50%.

bOR from a random effects meta-analysis where interstudy heterogeneity was ≥50%.

cNR: not reported.

dDDH: developmental dysplasia of the hip.

Discussion

Principal Findings

This study assessed evidence of association with DP for 43 nonobstetric factors (demographic factors: n=3, 7%; developmental factors: n=6, 14%; dietary factors: n=4, 9%; maternal factors: n=8, 19%; medical and surgical factors: n=11, 26%; and positional and environmental factors: n=11, 26%). Of these 43 factors, 16 (37%) were associated with DP (demographic factors [male sex]: n=1, 6%; developmental factors [DDH, head circumference, and delay in motor milestones]: n=3, 19%; dietary factors [bottle-only feeding, formula feeding, and vitamin D intake]: n=3, 19%; maternal factors [maternal age and maternal education level]: n=2, 12%; medical and surgical factors [chronic lung disease grade II, mechanical ventilation, and obesity at diagnosis of DP]: n=3, 19%; and positional and environmental factors [head position preference, sleeping position, reduced tummy time, and time spent supine on the floor]: n=4, 25%).

With the notable exceptions of maternal age, mechanical ventilation, and tummy time, these associations were either supported by nonconflicting evidence or a meta-analysis that resolved conflicting evidence into an association. Of the 16 factors, 12 (75%) had ORs that ranged from 1.10 (mechanical ventilation) to 7.15 (insufficient vitamin D intake). Of the 5 factors assessed by meta-analysis (male sex, reaching fewer motor milestones by age 6 months, maternal education level, head position preference, and sleeping position), only 1 (20%; male sex) was associated with interstudy heterogeneity (≥50%).

No evidence of publication bias was detected.

Evidence-Based Recommendations

Strategies to reduce the prevalence of DP have included guidance about the infant’s environment, positioning, and handling, with the goal of creating a nonrestrictive environment that promotes spontaneous and unhindered physical movement and symmetrical motor development [27,45].

On the basis of the evidence presented in this study, the following 11 recommendations, presented in order of importance, are offered with the aim of reducing the prevalence of DP.

First, to ensure bone health in infants, it is critical that vitamin D intake is adequate [46]. Vitamin D level should be assessed regularly during development, and dietary supplementation should be considered if vitamin D level is low.

Second, during the first months of life, babies develop a head position preference [47], and this preference is more often to the right [44,48]. The increased compressive forces on one side of the head for prolonged periods causes flattening on the side being compressed. It has been proposed that the position of the fetus in the later stages of pregnancy may, in part, be responsible for position preference [28,49]. However, there is also evidence that position preference can be modified by varying head position during sleep to encourage equal distribution of pressure [50].

Other strategies to mitigate head position preference should be used, such as gently moving the infant’s head to the unfavored side when asleep or physical therapy with or without kinesiological tape to reduce tightness in the neck muscles to facilitate easier neck turning [51,52].

Third, sufficient tummy time should be provided to strengthen the infant’s head, neck, and arms and reduce time spent supine when awake.

Fourth, as infants tend to turn away from windows and toward the center of a room, it is recommended to alternate the infant’s sleeping position by placing their head at different ends of the crib. This concept is supported by 2 studies suggesting no association between crib end change and DP [33,42]. However, it is important to state that the lack of association between crib end change and DP does not necessarily mean that changing the crib end will provide an effective treatment for established DP; it may merely help to reduce the risk of DP developing.

Fifth, although bottle-only feeding should not be discouraged, it is recommended to alternate feeding positions, using both the dominant and nondominant sides when holding the infant. Bottle feeding, as opposed to exclusively breast feeding, may be positively associated with obesity (which has also been identified as a risk factor for DP) [53]. This coassociation may, in part, explain the association of bottle-only feeding with DP.

Sixth, although formula feeding should also not be discouraged, it is recommended to alternate feeding positions. It has been suggested by Weernink et al [43] that this particular risk factor is associated with lower maternal education level. Similar to bottle feeding, formula feeding, as opposed to exclusively breast feeding, may be positively associated with obesity (itself a risk factor for DP) [53].

Seventh, if motor milestones are delayed, infants should be referred for specialist assessment by a pediatrician. Similarly, obesity (BMI >97th percentile) should be identified and managed by a specialist pediatrician.

Eighth, to mitigate the impact of low maternal education level, educational resources and face-to-face education outlining factors associated with DP, as well as recommendations to reduce their impact, should be provided to all families at the 6-week postnatal infant check-up, with particular emphasis on those with low educational levels. A lower maternal education level results in worse health outcomes in infancy and later life [54]; although improving the education level of future mothers should be a national priority, there are other factors associated with low education level that may be immediately modifiable.

These include access to information and access to resources [55].

Ninth, Information should be provided to families that male infants are at higher risk of DP. Losee et al [49] suggested that male infants tend to have larger, less flexible heads at birth, which are more likely to become deformed by compressive forces in utero and in the birth canal. Families should be particularly encouraged to engage with strategies to mitigate DP in male infants.

Tenth, information should be provided to families that infants with greater head circumference are at higher risk of DP. Families should be particularly encouraged to engage with strategies to mitigate DP in these infants. 

Eleventh, information should also be provided to families that infants who have had mechanical ventilation are at higher risk of DP. Families and care teams of infants requiring mechanical ventilation should be encouraged to engage with strategies to mitigate DP in these infants.

Alternative strategies for mitigating the impact of DP, such as helmet therapy, although costly for individuals and health care systems, may help avoid more invasive strategies [56]. It has been demonstrated that education provided by health care professionals, such as health visitors, midwives, and nurses, can successfully reduce the prevalence of DP [57]. Adopting these recommendations may lead to a reduction in the prevalence of DP.

Strengths of This Study

The strengths of this study include a robust methodology. The protocol was registered with PROSPERO, and the reporting was in line with the PRISMA 2020 guidelines [22]. The databases searched provided >97.5% coverage [23]. Standardized data extraction was performed to minimize errors. Meta-analysis was performed where data allowed. Funnel plots suggested that publication bias did not impact the results; thus, a trim-and-fill analysis was not necessary to correct for asymmetry [58].

This study represents the most comprehensive analysis of nonobstetric factors associated with DP published to date. A systematic review by Bialocerkowski et al [59] only identified 5 factors associated with DP, of which 3 (60%) were nonobstetric factors (male sex, supine position, and neck problems) [59]. Another systematic review by De Bock et al [60] identified male sex, supine sleeping position, limited neck rotation, head position preference, lower level of activity, and reduced tummy time as the most important risk factors [60].

By contrast, our study provides evidence of association for 16 factors and confirms the association of male sex, supine sleeping position, head position preference, and reduced tummy time with DP.

A more recent systematic review by Inchingolo et al [61] provided only 2 recommendations to mitigate the impact of nonobstetric risk factors for DP: at least 30 minutes of tummy time and the use of a passive sleep curve mattress to improve harmonious skull growth. In addition, it did not include meta-analyses to support these recommendations. By contrast, our study makes 11 recommendations for nonobstetric factors to reduce the prevalence of DP. The systematic review by Inchingolo et al [61] also did not assess publication bias.

Our review suggested that none of the recommendations were influenced by publication bias.

Limitations of This Study

To ensure the completion of the study, additional databases were not searched, and hand searching and gray literature searches were also not performed. This inevitably limited the comprehensiveness of this study, although no systematic review can claim to be truly comprehensive because this would necessitate continual inclusion of newly published studies. The search terms were designed to be specific yet pragmatic to ensure the completion of the work with limited resources; thus, some studies may have been overlooked. Due to resource limitations, it was not possible to record more detailed reasons for the exclusion of screened articles other than not reporting risk factors for DP.

Resource constraints also prevented the screening process from being conducted by 2 independent reviewers. Instead, abstract and full-text screening was performed by a single reviewer. This impacts the reproducibility of the study due to the increased potential for errors in study selection when screening is undertaken by a single reviewer. That said, because the selection criteria were clearly set out, errors due to the application of these criteria during the screening process are likely to have had minimal impact on the study outcomes.

In addition, it was not feasible, due to resource limitations, to contact study authors to attempt to collect raw data if a study did not report ORs for a risk factor. This may have limited the data that could have been used in meta-analysis. If contacting authors had been feasible, more factors could potentially have been analyzed quantitively to resolve discrepancies between the included studies. This represents a significant limitation of our study.

These factors may, in part, account for the apparent disparities reported in our results compared to other literature. These disparities include the apparent lack of association between developmental delay and DP [9], while demonstrating a significant association between reaching fewer motor milestones and DP [27,30]. A recent systematic review by Martinuik et al [62] included 19 studies that assessed the association between developmental delay and DP. Notwithstanding the fact that the authors included multiple studies that used the same study population more than once, a positive association between developmental delay and DP was reported in a majority of the studies [62].

The fact that our study did not demonstrate a similar association may, in part, be due to the inclusion of studies that assessed different populations, as well as methodological limitations in our search strategy that limited the identification of studies that may have met our eligibility criteria. Another study of a large primary care cohort of 77,108 patients has provided further evidence in support of an association between developmental delay and DP [63]. That said, the literature remains conflicting, with other studies unable to demonstrate an association between presence or degree of developmental delay and DP [64].

Commentators have highlighted the fact that most studies are retrospective and observational by design, and this limits conclusions about the correlative versus causative relationship between developmental delay and DP [65].

Another disparity reported in our study is that torticollis was not associated with DP [9,26,38]. A number of literature reviews have previously reported an association between congenital muscular torticollis and DP [8,59]. Although these studies were published a decade or so ago, it logically follows that if other positional factors, such as head position preference and sleeping position, have been found in more contemporaneous studies to be significantly associated with DP [28,33,34,39], then torticollis would also be expected to be found to be associated with DP.

These conflicts reported in the literature may be due to the limitations of individual study design or differences between different study populations. Therefore, we recommend interpreting with caution the lack of association between torticollis and DP reported in our study, given the lack of a mechanistic explanation that reconciles this result with other positional factors that were found to be associated with DP.

In this review, we have included a study involving patients who developed plagiocephaly after ventriculoperitoneal shunt insertion [37]. Although the authors characterized the plagiocephaly as “positional,” implying that external forces had caused the skull deformity, an alternative hypothesis is that shunt-associated plagiocephaly is a different disease entity from DP [37]. This study has been included for comprehensiveness [37], but the results should be interpreted with caution alongside those of other studies.

Finally, another limitation includes the lack of a Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) assessment of evidence quality, which impacts the certainty of the conclusions and recommendations set out in this study.

Conclusions

In summary, this study provides the most comprehensive meta-analytic assessment of nonobstetric factors associated with DP published to date. It offers 11 evidence-based recommendations that can be adopted by health care systems globally to reduce the prevalence of DP. Future research should focus on investigating factors for which the literature is conflicting but quantitative data are lacking to enable meta-analyses to be performed; for example, maternal age was the only factor reported to be protective against DP, but conflicting studies reported that there was no association without providing quantitative data.

Thus, maternal age as a protective factor for DP should be investigated further to provide quantitative data for meta-analytic approaches to determine its protective effect. Further research should also address the nature of specific relationships between risk factors and DP; for example, both bottle-only feeding and formula feeding have been associated with DP. Studies should focus on understanding the nature of this relationship, that is, whether this relationship is due to mechanical forces associated with bottle-feeding or whether a reduction in, or lack of, breast milk intake or a lack of complimentary foods alongside breast milk results in nutritional differences that impact skull development [66].

As our study also highlighted an association between obesity and DP, research on other early-life or environmental exposures should be conducted to elucidate their effects on growth and development, particularly skull growth and head shape [67,68]. Finally, randomized controlled trials, although considered the gold standard study design for obtaining reliable evidence of an intervention’s effectiveness, should not be conducted for the interventions herein that relate to risk factors for DP development that have already been assessed through meta-analysis.

However, randomized controlled trials could provide further evidence for an intervention: if ethically appropriate: where the evidence for a particular risk factor is relatively weak, such as when only a single cohort study has provided the evidence for a risk factor’s influence on the development of DP.

Authors' Contributions: CRTH developed the methodology, performed screening and data extraction, performed data analysis, interpreted the results, and wrote and edited the manuscript. NB performed screening and data extraction, interpreted the results, and wrote and edited the manuscript. AN performed screening and data extraction, interpreted the results, and edited the manuscript. FJBD interpreted the results and edited the manuscript. JO conceived of the study, interpreted the results, and edited the manuscript.

Conflicts of Interest: CRTH and AN received consultancy fees from Advanced Orthomolecular Research in Calgary, Alberta, and their family members work for the aforementioned company, which, although not directly connected to this research, produces nutraceutical compounds, including vitamin D, which is part of the subject matter of this research. All other authors declare no other conflicts of interest.

Multimedia Appendix 1

PRISMA 2020 checklist.

Supplement file at the original source: open the original paper. This file is not included in this text import.

Abbreviations

aOR

adjusted odds ratio

DDH

developmental dysplasia of the hip

DP

deformational plagiocephaly

GRADE

Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation

OR

odds ratio

PRISMA

Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses

RR

risk ratio

Data Availability

All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this paper.

1 Ehret FW Whelan MF Ellenbogen RG Cunningham ML Gruss JS Differential diagnosis of the trapezoid-shaped head Cleft Palate Craniofac J 2004 0141 1 13 9 10.1597/02-053 14697075 02-053 14697075
2 Delashaw JB Persing JA Broaddus WC Jane JA Cranial vault growth in craniosynostosis J Neurosurg 1989 0270 2 159 65 10.3171/jns.1989.70.2.0159 2913214 2913214
3 Johnson D Wilkie AO Craniosynostosis Eur J Hum Genet 2011 0419 4 369 76 10.1038/ejhg.2010.235 21248745 ejhg2010235 21248745 PMC3060331
4 Jung BK Yun IS Diagnosis and treatment of positional plagiocephaly Arch Craniofac Surg 2020 0421 2 80 6 10.7181/acfs.2020.00059 32380806 acfs.2020.00059 32380806 PMC7206465
5 Holowka MA Reisner A Giavedoni B Lombardo JR Coulter C Plagiocephaly severity scale to aid in clinical treatment recommendations J Craniofac Surg 2017 0528 3 717 22 10.1097/SCS.0000000000003520 28468155 00001665-201705000-00033 28468155
6 Kalra R Walker ML Posterior plagiocephaly Childs Nerv Syst 2012 0928 9 1389 93 10.1007/s00381-012-1784-y 22872253 22872253
7 Marshall JM Shahzad F Safe sleep, plagiocephaly, and brachycephaly: assessment, risks, treatment, and when to refer Pediatr Ann 2020 100149 10 e440 7 10.3928/19382359-20200922-02 33034660 33034660
8 Kuo AA Tritasavit S Graham Jr JM Congenital muscular torticollis and positional plagiocephaly Pediatr Rev 2014 0235 2 79 87 10.1542/pir.35-2-79 24488831 35/2/79 24488831
9 van Cruchten C Feijen MM van der Hulst RR Demographics of positional plagiocephaly and brachycephaly; risk factors and treatment J Craniofac Surg 2021 32 8 2736 40 10.1097/SCS.0000000000007811 34231510 00001665-202112000-00042 34231510
10 van Vlimmeren LA van der Graaf Y Boere-Boonekamp MM L'Hoir MP Helders PJ Engelbert RH Risk factors for deformational plagiocephaly at birth and at 7 weeks of age: a prospective cohort study Pediatrics 2007 02119 2 e408 18 10.1542/peds.2006-2012 17272603 119/2/e408 17272603
11 Joganic JL Lynch JM Littlefield TR Verrelli BC Risk factors associated with deformational plagiocephaly Pediatrics 2009 12124 6 e1126 33 10.1542/peds.2008-2969 19917588 peds.2008-2969 19917588
12 Oh AK Hoy EA Rogers GF Predictors of severity in deformational plagiocephaly J Craniofac Surg 2009 0320 Suppl 1 685 9 10.1097/SCS.0b013e318193d6e5 19190504 19190504
13 de Luca F Hinde A Effectiveness of the 'Back-to-Sleep' campaigns among healthcare professionals in the past 20 years: a systematic review BMJ Open 2016 09306 9 e011435 10.1136/bmjopen-2016-011435 27694485 bmjopen-2016-011435 PMC5051431 27694485
14 Turk AE McCarthy JG Thorne CH Wisoff JH The "back to sleep campaign" and deformational plagiocephaly: is there cause for concern? J Craniofac Surg 1996 017 1 12 8 10.1097/00001665-199601000-00006 9086896 9086896
15 Argenta LC David LR Wilson JA Bell WO An increase in infant cranial deformity with supine sleeping position J Craniofac Surg 1996 017 1 5 11 10.1097/00001665-199601000-00005 9086895 9086895
16 Esparza J Hinojosa J García-Recuero I Romance A Pascual B Martínez de Aragón A Surgical treatment of isolated and syndromic craniosynostosis. Results and complications in 283 consecutive cases Neurocirugia (Astur) 2008 1219 6 509 29 10.1016/s1130-1473(08)70201-x 19112545 3 19112545
17 Roby BB Finkelstein M Tibesar RJ Sidman JD Prevalence of positional plagiocephaly in teens born after the "Back to Sleep" campaign Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2012 05146 5 823 8 10.1177/0194599811434261 22241785 0194599811434261 22241785
18 van Wijk RM van Vlimmeren LA Groothuis-Oudshoorn CG Van der Ploeg CP Ijzerman MJ Boere-Boonekamp MM Helmet therapy in infants with positional skull deformation: randomised controlled trial BMJ 2014 0501348 g2741 10.1136/bmj.g2741 24784879 bmj.g2741 24784879 PMC4006966
19 Di Chiara A La Rosa E Ramieri V Vellone V Cascone P Treatment of deformational plagiocephaly with physiotherapy J Craniofac Surg 2019 1030 7 2008 13 10.1097/SCS.0000000000005665 31232996 31232996
20 Cumpston M Li T Page MJ Chandler J Welch VA Higgins JP Thomas J Updated guidance for trusted systematic reviews: a new edition of the Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2019 100310 ED000142 10.1002/14651858.ED000142 31643080 31643080 PMC10284251
21 Moher D Liberati A Tetzlaff J Altman DG Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement PLoS Med 2009 07216 7 e1000097 10.1371/journal.pmed.1000097 19621072 19621072 PMC2707599
22 Page MJ McKenzie JE Bossuyt PM Boutron I Hoffmann TC Mulrow CD Shamseer L Tetzlaff JM Akl EA Brennan SE Chou R Glanville J Grimshaw JM Hróbjartsson A Lalu MM Li T Loder EW Mayo-Wilson E McDonald S McGuinness LA Stewart LA Thomas J Tricco AC Welch VA Whiting P Moher D The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews BMJ 2021 0329372 n71 10.1136/bmj.n71 33782057 33782057 PMC8005924
23 Bramer WM Giustini D Kramer BM Comparing the coverage, recall, and precision of searches for 120 systematic reviews in Embase, MEDLINE, and Google Scholar: a prospective study Syst Rev 2016 03015 1 39 10.1186/s13643-016-0215-7 26932789 10.1186/s13643-016-0215-7 26932789 PMC4772334
24 Falagas ME Pitsouni EI Malietzis GA Pappas G Comparison of PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, and Google Scholar: strengths and weaknesses FASEB J 2008 0222 2 338 42 10.1096/fj.07-9492LSF 17884971 fj.07-9492LSF 17884971
25 Sterne JA Egger M Funnel plots for detecting bias in meta-analysis: guidelines on choice of axis J Clin Epidemiol 2001 1054 10 1046 55 11576817 S0895-4356(01)00377-8 11576817 10.1016/s0895-4356(01)00377-8
26 Aarnivala HE Valkama AM Pirttiniemi PM Cranial shape, size and cervical motion in normal newborns Early Hum Dev 2014 0890 8 425 30 10.1016/j.earlhumdev.2014.05.007 24951081 S0378-3782(14)00131-5 24951081
27 Aarnivala H Vuollo V Harila V Heikkinen T Pirttiniemi P Holmström L Valkama AM The course of positional cranial deformation from 3 to 12 months of age and associated risk factors: a follow-up with 3D imaging Eur J Pediatr 2016 12175 12 1893 903 10.1007/s00431-016-2773-z 27624627 10.1007/s00431-016-2773-z 27624627
28 Ballardini E Sisti M Basaglia N Benedetto M Baldan A Borgna-Pignatti C Garani G Prevalence and characteristics of positional plagiocephaly in healthy full-term infants at 8-12 weeks of life Eur J Pediatr 2018 10177 10 1547 54 10.1007/s00431-018-3212-0 30030600 10.1007/s00431-018-3212-0 30030600
29 Ifflaender S Rüdiger M Konstantelos D Wahls K Burkhardt W Prevalence of head deformities in preterm infants at term equivalent age Early Hum Dev 2013 1289 12 1041 7 10.1016/j.earlhumdev.2013.08.011 24016482 S0378-3782(13)00200-4 24016482
30 Kim E Kim KE Jeon J Sheen YH Lee H Yoon SY Kim NH Choi KM Delayed motor development and infant obesity as risk factors for severe deformational plagiocephaly: a matched case-control study Front Pediatr 2020 8 582360 10.3389/fped.2020.582360 33262962 33262962 PMC7686236
31 Leung AY Mandrusiak A Watter P Gavranich J Johnston LM Clinical assessment of head orientation profile development and its relationship with positional plagiocephaly in healthy term infants: a prospective study Early Hum Dev 2016 0596 31 8 10.1016/j.earlhumdev.2016.03.001 27031440 S0378-3782(16)30005-6 27031440
32 Maniglio P Noventa M Tartaglia S Petracca M Bonito M Ricciardi E Ambrosini G Buzzaccarini G Laganà AS The Obstetrician Gynecologist's role in the screening of infants at risk of severe plagiocephaly: prevalence and risk factors Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol 2022 05272 37 42 10.1016/j.ejogrb.2022.03.011 35279639 S0301-2115(22)00243-3 35279639
33 Mawji A Vollman AR Fung T Hatfield J McNeil DA Sauvé R Risk factors for positional plagiocephaly and appropriate time frames for prevention messaging Paediatr Child Health 2014 1019 8 423 7 10.1093/pch/19.8.423 25382999 25382999 PMC4220526
34 Nuysink J Eijsermans MJ van Haastert IC Koopman-Esseboom C Helders PJ de Vries LS van der Net J Clinical course of asymmetric motor performance and deformational plagiocephaly in very preterm infants J Pediatr 2013 09163 3 658 65.e1 10.1016/j.jpeds.2013.04.015 23706356 S0022-3476(13)00432-0 23706356
35 Launonen AM Aarnivala H Kyteas P Vuollo V Heikkinen T Kau CH Pirttiniemi P Harila V Valkama AM A 3D follow-up study of cranial asymmetry from early infancy to toddler age after preterm versus term birth J Clin Med 2019 10118 10 387 92 10.3390/jcm8101665 31614700 jcm8101665 31614700 PMC6832468
36 Pogliani L Cerini C Vivaldo T Duca P Zuccotti GV Deformational plagiocephaly at birth: an observational study on the role of assisted reproductive technologies J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med 2014 0227 3 270 4 10.3109/14767058.2013.814629 23773121 23773121
37 Roberts SA Symonds JD Chawla R Toman E Bishop J Solanki GA Positional plagiocephaly following ventriculoperitoneal shunting in neonates and infancy-how serious is it? Childs Nerv Syst 2017 0233 2 275 80 10.1007/s00381-016-3275-z 27848003 10.1007/s00381-016-3275-z 27848003 PMC5352750
38 Sheu SU Ethen MK Scheuerle AE Langlois PH Investigation into an increase in plagiocephaly in Texas from 1999 to 2007 Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 2011 08165 8 708 13 10.1001/archpediatrics.2011.42 21464373 archpediatrics.2011.42 21464373
39 Solani B Talebian Ardestani M Boroumand H Ostadmohammadi V Hallajnejad M Kashani Zade M Loghman A Talebian Ardestani A Risk factors associated with positional plagiocephaly in healthy Iranian infants: a case-control study Iran J Child Neurol 2022 16 2 85 92 10.22037/ijcn.v16i1.28524 35497110 PMC9047834 35497110
40 Tang M Gorbutt KA Peethambaran A Yang L Nelson VS Chang KW High prevalence of cranial asymmetry exists in infants with neonatal brachial plexus palsy J Pediatr Rehabil Med 2016 11309 4 271 7 10.3233/PRM-160396 27935564 PRM396 27935564
41 Valkama AM Aarnivala HI Sato K Harila V Heikkinen T Pirttiniemi P Plagiocephaly after neonatal developmental dysplasia of the hip at school age J Clin Med 2019 12199 1 21 10.3390/jcm9010021 31861739 jcm9010021 31861739 PMC7019875
42 van Vlimmeren LA Engelbert RH Pelsma M Groenewoud HM Boere-Boonekamp MM der Sanden MW The course of skull deformation from birth to 5 years of age: a prospective cohort study Eur J Pediatr 2017 01176 1 11 21 10.1007/s00431-016-2800-0 27815732 10.1007/s00431-016-2800-0 27815732 PMC5219011
43 Weernink MG van Wijk RM Groothuis-Oudshoorn CG Lanting CI Grant CC van Vlimmeren LA Boere-Boonekamp MM Insufficient vitamin D supplement use during pregnancy and early childhood: a risk factor for positional skull deformation Matern Child Nutr 2016 0112 1 177 88 10.1111/mcn.12153 25382635 25382635 PMC6860055
44 Hopkins B Lems YL Van Wulfften Palthe T Hoeksma J Kardaun O Butterworth G Development of head position preference during early infancy: a longitudinal study in the daily life situation Dev Psychobiol 1990 0123 1 39 53 10.1002/dev.420230105 2340956 2340956
45 Cavalier A Picot MC Artiaga C Mazurier E Amilhau M Froye E Captier G Picaud J Prevention of deformational plagiocephaly in neonates Early Hum Dev 2011 0887 8 537 43 10.1016/j.earlhumdev.2011.04.007 21664772 S0378-3782(11)00167-8 21664772
46 Pawley N Bishop NJ Prenatal and infant predictors of bone health: the influence of vitamin D Am J Clin Nutr 2004 1280 6 Suppl 1748S 51S 10.1093/ajcn/80.6.1748S 15585799 S0002-9165(22)03778-9 15585799
47 Vles J van Zutphen S Hasaart T Dassen W Lodder J Supine and prone head orientation preference in term infants Brain Dev 1991 13 2 87 90 10.1016/s0387-7604(12)80112-4 1892225 S0387-7604(12)80112-4 1892225
48 Rönnqvist L Hopkins B Head position preference in the human newborn: a new look Child Dev 1998 0269 1 13 23 10.1111/j.1467-8624.1998.tb06129.x 9499553 9499553
49 Losee JE Mason AC Dudas J Hua LB Mooney MP Nonsynostotic occipital plagiocephaly: factors impacting onset, treatment, and outcomes Plast Reconstr Surg 2007 05119 6 1866 73 10.1097/01.prs.0000259190.56177.ca 17440367 00006534-200705000-00033 17440367
50 Glasgow TS Siddiqi F Hoff C Young PC Deformational plagiocephaly: development of an objective measure and determination of its prevalence in primary care J Craniofac Surg 2007 0118 1 85 92 10.1097/01.scs.0000244919.69264.bf 17251842 00001665-200701000-00016 17251842
51 van Vlimmeren LA Helders PJ van Adrichem LN Engelbert RH Torticollis and plagiocephaly in infancy: therapeutic strategies Pediatr Rehabil 2006 9 1 40 6 10.1080/13638490500037904 16352505 J602W26884M545P3 16352505
52 Greve KR Goldsbury CM Simmons EA Infants with congenital muscular torticollis requiring supplemental physical therapy interventions Pediatr Phys Ther 2022 070134 3 335 41 10.1097/PEP.0000000000000906 35616484 00001577-202207000-00013 35616484
53 Ardic C Usta O Omar E Yıldız C Memis E Effects of infant feeding practices and maternal characteristics on early childhood obesity Arch Argent Pediatr 2019 0201117 1 26 33 10.5546/aap.2019.eng.26 10.5546/aap.2019.eng.26 30652443 30652443
54 Ross CE Mirowsky J The interaction of personal and parental education on health Soc Sci Med 2011 0272 4 591 9 10.1016/j.socscimed.2010.11.028 21227556 S0277-9536(10)00822-1 21227556 PMC3049298
55 Moon RY LoCasale-Crouch J Turnbull KL Colson E Kellams A Heeren T Kerr S Hauck FR Corwin MJ Investigating mechanisms for maternal education disparities in enacting health-promoting infant care practices Acad Pediatr 2020 20 7 926 33 10.1016/j.acap.2020.03.008 32201345 S1876-2859(20)30128-5 32201345 PMC7483851
56 Marchac A Arnaud E Di Rocco F Michienzi J Renier D Severe deformational plagiocephaly: long-term results of surgical treatment J Craniofac Surg 2011 0122 1 24 9 10.1097/SCS.0b013e3181f7dd4a 21187754 21187754
57 Lennartsson F Nordin P Nonsynostotic plagiocephaly: a child health care intervention in Skaraborg, Sweden BMC Pediatr 2019 020619 1 48 10.1186/s12887-019-1405-y 30727985 10.1186/s12887-019-1405-y 30727985 PMC6364473
58 Duval S Tweedie R Trim and fill: a simple funnel-plot-based method of testing and adjusting for publication bias in meta-analysis Biometrics 2000 0656 2 455 63 10877304 10877304 10.1111/j.0006-341x.2000.00455.x
59 Bialocerkowski AE Vladusic SL Wei Ng C Prevalence, risk factors, and natural history of positional plagiocephaly: a systematic review Dev Med Child Neurol 2008 0850 8 577 86 10.1111/j.1469-8749.2008.03029.x 18754894 DMCN3029 18754894
60 De Bock F Braun V Renz-Polster H Deformational plagiocephaly in normal infants: a systematic review of causes and hypotheses Arch Dis Child 2017 06102 6 535 42 10.1136/archdischild-2016-312018 28104626 archdischild-2016-312018 28104626
61 Inchingolo AA Inchingolo AM Piras F Malcangi G Patano A Di Pede C Netti A Ciocia AM Corriero A Semjonova A Azzollini D De Ruvo E Viapiano F Ferrara I Palmieri G Campanelli M Mancini A De Leonardis N Avantario P Buongiorno S Fatone MC Costa S Montenegro V Tartaglia GM Rapone B Bordea IR Scarano A Lorusso F Palermo A Di Venere D Inchingolo F Dipalma G A systematic review of positional plagiocephaly prevention methods for patients in development Applied Sciences 2022 110412 21 11172 10.3390/app122111172
62 Martiniuk AL Vujovich-Dunn C Park M Yu W Lucas BR Plagiocephaly and developmental delay: a systematic review J Dev Behav Pediatr 2017 0138 1 67 78 10.1097/DBP.0000000000000376 28009719 00004703-201701000-00009 28009719
63 Rohde JF Goyal NK Slovin SR Hossain J Pachter LM Di Guglielmo MD Association of positional plagiocephaly and developmental delay within a primary care network J Dev Behav Pediatr 2021 42 2 128 34 10.1097/DBP.0000000000000860 33538454 00004703-202102000-00007 33538454 PMC8833012
64 Fontana SC Daniels D Greaves T Nazir N Searl J Andrews BT Assessment of deformational plagiocephaly severity and neonatal developmental delay J Craniofac Surg 2016 1127 8 1934 6 10.1097/SCS.0000000000003014 28005729 00001665-201611000-00006 28005729
65 Andrews BT Fontana SC Correlative vs. causative relationship between neonatal cranial head shape anomalies and early developmental delays Front Neurosci 2017 11 708 10.3389/fnins.2017.00708 29311788 29311788 PMC5742118
66 Ha EK Lee SW Kim JH Lee E Cha HR Han BE Shin J Han MY Associations between delayed introduction of complementary foods and childhood health consequences in exclusively breastfed children Nutrients 2023 073115 15 3410 10.3390/nu15153410 37571347 nu15153410 37571347 PMC10421357
67 Rasmussen SH Shrestha S Bjerregaard LG Ängquist LH Baker JL Jess T Allin KH Antibiotic exposure in early life and childhood overweight and obesity: a systematic review and meta-analysis Diabetes Obes Metab 2018 062520 6 1508 14 10.1111/dom.13230 29359849 29359849
68 Ha EK Kim JH Park D Lee E Lee SW Jee HM Shin YH Han MY Personal exposure to total VOC is associated with symptoms of atopic dermatitis in schoolchildren J Korean Med Sci 2022 022837 8 e63 10.3346/jkms.2022.37.e63 35226421 37.e63 35226421 PMC8885456
Publication and source details

Original title: Assessing the Evidence for Nonobstetric Risk Factors for Deformational Plagiocephaly: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Christopher Robert Timothy Hillyar; Natalie Bishop; Anjan Nibber; Frances Jean Bell-Davies; Juling Ong

Interactive Journal of Medical Research · 2024

Corresponding Author: Christopher Robert Timothy Hillyar christopher.hillyar@gtc.ox.ac.uk©Christopher Robert Timothy Hillyar, Natalie Bishop, Anjan Nibber, Frances Jean Bell-Davies, Juling Ong. Originally published in the Interactive Journal of Medical Research (https://www.i-jmr.org/), 18.09.2024.2024https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work, first published in the Interactive Journal of Medical Research, is properly cited. The complete bibliographic information, a link to the original publication on https://www.i-jmr.org/, as well as this copyright and license information must be included.

Repository JATS snapshot; version as supplied

Source retrieved: 2026-11-11T03:39:52.638224+00:00

DOI: 10.2196/55695 · PMC11447428