Vitamin D3 for Life

Live Enlightened

Research libraryVitamin D3 For Life
Study design and methods

Secondary relevance to vitamin D This paper mainly addresses another topic and also reports a vitamin D analysis, result or scientific synthesis.

This paper mainly addresses another topic and also reports a vitamin D analysis, result or scientific synthesis.

Why this paper is included

Supporting source evidence:

Therefore, no statement was possible on the risk of inadequate intakes and additional research is required to study the (in)adequacy.Median habitual intakes of children aged 1: or 2-year-old YCF non-users and users compared to the adequate intake (AI) and upper level (UL)YCF non-usersYCF usersMicronutrientAIaULMedian habitual intake (95% CI)b,cEvaluation risk inadequate intaked% > UL (95% CI)cMedian habitual intake (95% CI)b,cEvaluation risk inadequate intaked% > UL (95% CI)cVitamin A (µg RAE)300/350 to 492 (448 to 538)LR: 570 (492 to 650)LR: Vitamin A (µg retinol): 800379 (339 to 419): 8.9 (3.6 to 13.8)448 (382 to 515): 11.4 (1.4 to 20.1)Vitamin A (µg beta-carotene): : 1091 (882 to 1296): : 1078 (725 to 1467): : Vitamin B1 (mg)0.3 to 0.6 (0.6 to 0.6)LR: 0.7 (0.6 to 0.7)LR: Vitamin B2 (mg)0.5 to 1.0 (0.9 to 1.0)LR: 1.1 (1.0 to 1.2)LR: Vitamin B3 (mg)4 to 7.9 (7.6 to 8.2)LR: 7.9 (7.2 to 8.6)LR: Vitamin B6 (mg)0.450.9 (0.9 to 1.0)LR0 (0 to 0)0.9 (0.9 to 1.0)LR0 (0 to 0)Total folate (µg)85 to 131 (126 to 137)LR: 162 (151 to 174)LR: Folic acid (µg): 2002.3 (0.6 to 4.3): 0 (0 to 0)39.1 (33.8 to 44.2)-0 (0 to 0)Vitamin B12 (µg)0.7 to 2.4 (2.3 to 2.6)LR: 2.2 (1.9 to 2.4)LR: Vitamin C (mg)25/30 to 63 (59 to 67)LR: 81 (74 to 88)LR: Vitamin D (µg)10/3e502.0 (1.8 to 2.1)NSP/NSP0 (0 to 0)7.5 (6.5 to 8.4)NSP / LR0 (0 to 0)Vitamin E (mg)4/51006.4 (6.1 to 6.7)LR0 (0 to 0)7.7 (7.0 to 8.3)LR0 (0 to 0)Calcium (mg)500 to 671 (644 to 699)LR667 (622 to 708)LR: Copper (mg)0.3/0.410.7 (0.7 to 0.7)LR1.7 (0.2 to 3.5)0.7 (0.7 to 0.8)LR5.1 (0 to 10.1)Iron (mg)8 to 5.2 (4.9 to 5.4)NSP: 8.0 (7.5 to 8.5)CIAI: Magnesium (mg)85/120 to 174 (169 to 180)LR: 164 (154 to 174)LR: Potassium (mg)1400/1800 to 1806 (1751 to 1862)1 year: LR2 year: CIAI: 1670 (1572 to 1772)1 year: LR2 year: CIAI: Phosphorus (mg)470 to 824 (798 to 851)LR: 741 (694 to 786)LR: Selenium (µg)20/256021 (20 to 22)1 year: CIAI2 year: NSP0 (0 to 0)23 (20 to 27)CIAI0 (0 to 0.2)Zinc (mg)5/675.3 (5.1 to 5.4)1 year: CIAI2 year: NSP8.7 (4.6 to 12.7)6.2 (5.8 to 6.5)1 year: LR2 year: CIAI27.9(15.3 to 38.5)LR low risk, NSP no statement possible, CIAI 95% confidence interval of median intake includes AIaFor vitamin A, C, E, copper, magnesium, potassium, selenium and zinc different AI values for the 1: and for the 2-year-olds were establishedbMedian habitual intake of 1: and 2-year-oldscSignificant higher median habitual intakes or higher proportions above the UL between non-users and users are displayed as bolddEvaluation of risk on inadequate intakes separately performed for 1: and 2-year-oldseTwo AI-values for vitamin D, where 3 µg/day indicates adequate vitamin D intake with enough sun exposure and 10 µg/day if this amount of sun exposure is not met

Source: Adherence to the dietary reference values of users and non-users of YCF. View original paper

Relevance classification does not establish study quality, causation or editorial approval.

Study design Study design awaiting verification.

Study design awaiting verification

The available source does not establish a sufficiently clear study design.

Meta-analysis unclear · Blinding unclear / not reported · Human research reported

How this paper was classified

Automatic source-based classification; awaiting editorial verification. This is not a quality score.

Data from the Dutch National Food Consumption Survey (2012 to 2016; n = 440 children aged 1 to 2 year old) and the Dutch Food Composition Database (NEVO version 2016) were used to assess micronutrient intakes.

Source: Abstract.

View supporting evidence in the original paper

What the study types mean
Systematic review
Uses explicit methods to identify, assess and summarise research on a defined question.
Scoping review
Maps the extent and characteristics of research on a topic.
Narrative review
Discusses existing research; systematic-review methods have not been established by this classification.
Review / evidence synthesis
Reviews existing research; the exact review methods need further assessment.
Randomised controlled trial
Assigns participants or groups to comparison interventions by chance.
Non-randomised intervention study
Examines an intervention without random allocation.
Cohort study
Examines exposures and outcomes over time within a defined group.
Case-control study
Compares people with an outcome against people without it, examining exposures.
Cross-sectional study
Examines a population at a particular point in time.
Observational study
Observes exposures and outcomes without assigning the exposure; the subtype is not established here.
Case report
Describes an individual case.
Case series
Describes a group of individual cases.
Secondary analysis
Analyses existing study data; this paper is not automatically another independent trial.
Laboratory study
Investigates biological processes in a laboratory setting.
Qualitative study
Examines experiences or meanings using qualitative methods.
Genetic instrumental-variable study
Uses genetic variation as an instrument to investigate relationships; this is not a randomised treatment trial.
Study protocol
Describes planned methods and is not evidence that the planned study has reported results.
Multiple reported designs
More than one design is explicitly reported; examine the supporting methods.
Study design awaiting verification
The available source does not establish a sufficiently clear study design.

Meta-analysis combines numerical results from studies. Blinding describes who was unaware of treatment allocation. Neither is a separate quality grade. Study design, vitamin D relevance and document format are independent filters.

Full studies

Consumption of young child formulae in the Netherlands

Study design awaiting verification · European Journal of Nutrition · 2022

Original publication title

Consumption of young child formulae in the Netherlands

Marjolein H. de Jong; Eline L. Nawijn; Janneke Verkaik-Kloosterman

© The Author(s) 2022

Original publication · Publisher record · CC BY 4.0

Source wording retained. Formatting, section navigation and display-title punctuation adapted for this research record.

Authors’ conclusion

One-fifth of the young children in the Netherlands use YCF. Although YCF increases micronutrient intake, for most of the micronutrients a low risk of inadequate intakes exists among users as well as non-users of YCF. For most micronutrients the additional intake from fortified YCF seems unnecessary to achieve adequate intakes. The consumption of YCF increased the risk of excessive zinc intakes. It is important that the addition of micronutrients to YCF is regulated, to prevent excessive intakes.

An extract from the source publication. Read it in context.

At a glance

Abstract: What objectives does the paper state?

Adequate micronutrient intakes are essential for young children. Special young child formulae (YCF) intended for children from 1 year old are available in the Dutch market. Since YCF are enriched with many micronutrients, it has the potential to have a beneficial effect on young children, or might pose a risk on excessive micronutrient intakes. The current study investigated the characteristics of YCF users, and the effect of YCF use on micronutrient intakes.

Source: Purpose

Study methods

What methods does the paper describe?

Survey population

In the Dutch National Food Consumption Survey (DNFCS) 2012 to 2016, data were collected on food consumption of the Dutch population (N = 4313, 1 to 79 yr.). A detailed description of the DNFCS 2012 to 2016 is described elsewhere [8].

The current study focused on children aged 1 to 2 year old. Food consumption of children was estimated by interviewing parents or caretakers about their child’s food consumption. For all children, two 24-h recalls on non-consecutive days were performed by trained dieticians using GloboDiet (IARC©; former EPIC-Soft). Height and weight were measured on the first recall day. Body mass index (BMI) was calculated per child as the body weight divided by the height squared (kg/m2) and categorized into seriously underweight and underweight, normal weight and overweight and obesity.

Categorization was based on age-specific BMI cutoff values specified for gender and month of age [9]. With a general questionnaire, other general information of the participants was collected. Various background factors, such as educational level, native country, family size, and various general characteristics of the diet, such as special diets and eating habits were also recorded. The degree of urbanisation was divided in extremely urbanised (2500 or more addresses/km2), strongly (1500 to 2500 addresses/km2), moderately (1000 to 1500 addresses/km2), hardly (500 to 1000 addresses/km2) and not urbanised (fewer than 500 addresses/km2), as distinguished by Statistics Netherlands (CBS) [10].

The highest education qualification of the head of the household was recorded.

Definition YCF

YCF were defined as milk: or plant-based drinks fortified with micronutrients and intended as the replacement of infant formula and follow-up formulas, designed for children aged 1 year and older. No distinction between milk-based YCF and plant-based YCF was made as there were only three children using plant-based YCF. Users of YCF were considered as user when they consumed at least one time a YCF product on at least one of the recall days.

Food groups

Mean consumption in g/day from all food groups (according to the GloboDiet classification system [8]) was calculated for users and non-users of YCF separately. The GloboDiet classification consists of 18 main: and 78 subgroups. To study if non-users of YCF consume more regular milk than YCF users, also the mean intake from milk and breast milk was calculated. Milk included regular cow milk (skimmed, semi-skimmed and full fat), raw milk, buttermilk, milk enriched with calcium, semi-skimmed lactose free milk, full fat goat milk, almond milk, soymilk and rice milk.

Breastmilk could only be quantified if the milk was pumped and then fed to the child. If the milk was not pumped, the quantity was assumed to be 70 ml for each feeding, based on the declining breast milk intake for older infants as assumed by the EFSA [11].

Contribution of YCF to total micronutrient intake

Food consumption data from DNFCS 2012 to 2016 was linked to the Dutch Food Composition Database (NEVO; NEVO-online version 2016/5.0, RIVM, Bilthoven, 2016, with additions for the DNFCS 2012 to 2016) to estimate micronutrient intakes. Consumption data of YCF were linked to brand specific NEVO codes. To classify a formula as YCF, each NEVO code consumed within DNFCS 2012 to 2016 was checked to see it was YCF and not infant formula or follow-up formula. In this study we only considered the micronutrient intake from foods, intake from dietary supplements was excluded.

The impact of YCF consumption was studied by calculating the contribution of YCF to total micronutrient intake. For these analyses, only the recall days on which a YCF was consumed were included. This means if a user consumed YCF on only one recall day, only that day was included.

Assessment of risk on inadequate and excessive micronutrient intakes

The dietary reference values (DRV) adopted in 2015 by the Health Council of the Netherlands from the DRVs established by the Health Council of the Netherlands in 2000, 2003 and 2012, by the Nordic Council in 2012 and by the EFSA in 2006 were used in this study to assess the risk of inadequate and excessive intakes [1, 12Not reported16]. An estimated average requirement (EAR) is a reference value sufficient for half of the population [17].

When scientific evidence is insufficient to establish an EAR, an adequate intake (AI) is proposed. This reference value is sufficient for almost everyone in the population. All the DRVs for adequate intake used in this study were AIs. For vitamin D, the AI for both sufficient as insufficient sunlight exposure was used for all children, as the amount of sunlight exposure for each child was unknown. To assess the risk on excessive intakes, the tolerable upper levels (UL) were used.

Statistical analysis

To produce results representative of the Dutch population (in calendar year 2014) a weighting factor was applied in the analyses. This weighting factor included socio-demographic factors, as well as season and day of the week. As children were overrepresented in the study population (half of the study population consisted of children), the weight factor had a large impact on the population size after weighing. This weighted study population was used for the analysis of 1 to 2 year olds in current study.

General characteristics of YCF-users and non-users were compared with a Chi-Square test. The level of significance was corrected for multiple comparisons using the Bonferroni correction [18]. A p value < 0.007 was considered to indicate a statistically significant difference between the groups.

Mean consumption from food groups was calculated from the mean consumption of 2 recall days per participant for YCF users and non-users separately. The proportion of consumers of each food (sub)group was calculated as the number of users within food (sub)group divided by total subjects within the YCF non-user or user group. The percentage of difference in mean consumption within the food groups between the YCF non-users and users was assessed. Mean consumption from different food (sub)groups between users and non-users of YCF were compared using the Wilcoxon-Mann: Whitney test.

The level of significance was corrected for multiple comparison using the Bonferroni correction and a p value < 0.0005 was considered as statistically significant.

Calculation of the contribution of YCF to total micronutrient intake and the habitual intakes was performed for the micronutrients calcium, copper, iron, magnesium, phosphorus, potassium, selenium, zinc, vitamin A (retinol, retinol activity equivalents (RAE) and beta-carotenes), vitamins B1, B2, B3, B6, B12, C, D and E, and folate (total folate (both naturally present and folic acid)), calcium, copper, iron, magnesium, phosphorus, potassium, selenium and zinc. For vitamin A expressed as RAE, 1 μg RAE was assumed to be equal to 1 μg retinol, 12 μg β-carotene and 24 μg other carotenoids [17].

Folate equivalents were calculated as the amount of folate naturally present in foods (in μg) and 1.7 times the amount of folic acid in enriched foods (in μg) [19].

For all micronutrients studied, the habitual intake (also referred to as usual intake) distribution was estimated by correcting the data for the within-person variation using the Statistical Program to Assess Dietary Exposure (SPADE version 4.0.85 of 16 December 2020) using R version 4.0.3. Intakes were age-dependently modelled for 1: and 2-year-olds, using the 1-part model.

The adequacy was only qualitatively assessed using an ‘adequate intake’ (AI), as no ‘estimated average requirement’ (EAR) was established for young children. A habitual median intake above the AI was considered as a low risk of inadequate micronutrient intake. If the median habitual intake was below the adequate intake, no statement about the adequacy could be made. If the 95% confidence interval (CI) of the median intake included the AI, we assumed a low risk of inadequacy. This assessment was made for 1: and 2-year-olds separately, based on the age-specific habitual intakes.

Additionally, the proportion of the population with a habitual micronutrient intake above the UL was estimated. A proportion larger than 2.5% was considered high. Lower proportions were considered tolerable.

Habitual intakes and proportions above the upper level (UL) of users and non-users were compared by estimating the difference between users and non-users and calculating 95% CIs for these differences, based on 200 bootstrap iterations, similar to Dekkers and Slob [20]. If the 95% CI for difference did not include zero, habitual intakes or proportions above UL were considered as statistically different between users and non-users.

Statistical analyses were performed using SAS version 9 (Windows version 6.3.9600), unless stated otherwise.

Source: Methods Source: Methods Source: Methods Source: Methods Source: Methods Source: Methods

Results: Characteristics of YCF users

Among the Dutch 1: and 2-year-olds, 21% were found to be users of YCF (Table 1). All the characteristics studied were comparable for users and non-users of YCF.

Table 1

Characteristics of YCF non-users and users for 1: and 2-year-oldsa

YCF non-usersYCF usersP valuec
Unweighted
(n = 347)
Weighted
(n = 75)b
Unweighted
(n = 93)
Weighted
(n = 20)b
Sex0.1850
 Boys176 (51%)38 (51%)51 (55%)12 (59%)
 Girls171 (49%)37 (49%)42 (45%)8 (41%)
BMI0.2157

 (Extremely-)

Underweight

32 (9%)8 (11%)4 (4%)1 (5%)
 Normal weight286 (83%)61 (81%)83 (19%)17 (89%)
Overweight/obesity28 (8%)7 (9%)5 (5%)1 (6%)
Educational leveld0.3178
 Low14 (4%)6 (8%)3 (3%)1 (5%)
 Middle98 (22%)27 (36%)30 (32%)9 (45%)
 High235 (67%)42 (56%)60 (65%)10 (51%)
Urbanisatione0.0398
 Extremely/strongly149 (43%)36 (47%)54 (58%)12 (62%)
 Moderately77 (22%)15 (19%)17 (18%)3 (16%)
 Hardly/not121 (35%)25 (33%)22 (24%)4 (21%)
Ethnicity0.9145
 Dutch319 (92%)68 (91%)82 (88%)18 (89%)
 Western immigrant8 (2%)2 (2%)3 (3%)0 (2%)
 Non-Western immigrant20 (6%)5 (7%)8 (9%)2 (8%)
Season (First recall day)0.2004
 Spring94 (27%)21 (27%)14 (15%)3 (16%)
 Summer71 (20%)18 (24%)23 (25%)6 (30%)
 Autumn80 (23%)19 (25%)23 (25%)5 (26%)
 Winter102 (29%)18 (24%)33 (35%)5 (27%)
Recall days0.6288
 Weekend/week157 (45%)36 (47%)41 (44%)9 (48%)
 Only week125 (36%)26 (35%)31 (33%)6 (31%)
 Only weekend65 (19%)13 (18%)21 (23%)4 (21%)

aWeighted for socio-demographic factors, season and day of the week. As children were overrepresented in the original sample, the weight factor had a large impact on the study population size

bAs a result of the use of a weight factor, results needed to be rounded to numbers without decimals, resulting into some groups of non-users and/or users with an n not equal to 75 and/or 20

cP value calculated with the Chi-square. P < 0.007 was considered statistical significant after the Bonferroni correction

dHighest educational level of the parents

eExtremely/strongly urbanised: > 1500 addresses/km2, moderately urbanised: 1000 to 1500 addresses/km2, hardly/not urbanised: < 1000 addresses/km2 [10]

Source: Characteristics of YCF users

Results: Consumption within food (sub)groups

YCF users had a 25% significantly lower mean consumption of the food group non-alcoholic beverages among YCF users compared to non-users. Besides, YCF users seemed to have a 32% higher dairy consumption compared to YCF non-users from the subgroup ‘non-fermented milk and milk beverages’, which included YCF products as well as regular milk (Table 2). Among YCF users there were fewer consumers of regular milk (cow/goat/plant based), compared to YCF non-users (30%-point lower). Additionally, the regular milk consumers among the YCF users consumed on average 23% less compared to the regular milk consumers among YCF non-users YCF.

Table 2

Mean consumption (in grams) of foods within food (sub-)groups of YCF non-users and users aged 1 to 2 years old

Food (sub-)groupaYCF non-usersYCF users% of difference of mean consumption (%)dp valuee
Proportion of consumers (%)bMean consumption (g/day)cProportion of consumers (%)bMean consumption (g/day)c
Potatoes79687962− 80.389
 Unclassified, mixed and other tubers243527− 370.075
 Potatoes797963− 80.475
Vegetables94689559− 130.201
 Unclassified, mixed salad/vegetables18362230− 160.214
 Leafy vegetables (except cabbages)24441728− 350.381
 Fruiting vegetables64516945− 120.649
 Root vegetables31473840− 160.362
 Cabbages31613244− 280.084
 Mushrooms13131310− 280.991
 Grain and pod vegetables11311617− 450.086
 Leek, onion, garlic40115210− 90.362
 Stalk vegetables, sprouts710916560.524
Legumes759135900.987
Fruits, nuts, seeds and olives9816210016410.994
 Fruits9415191148− 20.570
 Fruit compote279440106130.146
 Nuts, peanuts, seeds51455− 630.052
 Peanut butter, nut/seeds spread2916231750.604
 Olives213218370.699
Dairy100400100476190.055
 Unclassified and mixed dairy products5120196− 200.523
 Non fermented milk and milk beverages8827299359320.002
  Milk (cow/goat/plant-based)f8825659196− 230.012
  Breastmilkf43385164− 520.371
 Fermented milk, milk beverages and yoghurt3621625210− 30.922
 Milk substitutes and milk substitute products51886183− 30.764
 Yoghurt4012131104− 140.158
 Fromage blanc, petits suisses23812969− 140.152
 Cheeses (including spread cheeses)70236821− 70.468
 Cream desserts, puddings (milk based)431502616380.175
 Unclassified creams03315− 840.540
 Dairy creams and creamers1113107− 490.592
 Ice cream (milk based)1042924− 410.193
 Sorbet/water ice1254825− 540.001
Cereals100102100101− 20.554
 Flours, starches, flakes, semolina23163013− 160.698
 Pasta, rice, other grains5054615400.887
 Bread99759870− 70.376
 Crispbread, rusks34102911150.338
 Breakfast cereals30294524− 190.004
 Dough and pastry650329− 430.386
Meat97459438− 170.057
 Unclassified and combined meat and meat products335254560.561
 Unclassified, mixed and other mammals932917− 480.128
 Beef20282219− 330.339
 Pork17361226− 290.332
 Chicken, hen28303629− 60.282
 Turkey, young turkey223720− 150.337
 Hot processed meat56493749− 10.925
 Cold processed meat6820552140.581
 Hot meat substitutes230219− 370.556
 Cold meat substitutes218323300.897
Fish1754155630.837
 Fish847957220.948
 Crustaceans, molluscs234250470.817
 Fish products, fish in crumbs961552− 140.749
Eggs34312026− 170.457
Fat and oils1001210011− 80.381
 Unclassified and combined fats174152− 500.048
 Vegetable oils503674110.561
 Butter167176− 100.628
 Margarines and cooking fats92118410− 50.638
 Other animal fats (including fish oils)0222− 81
Sugar and sweets90208218− 130.362
 Sugar225122− 550.005
 Jam, jelly, marmelade21213015− 270.911
 Honey7642− 680.205
 Other sweet spread287297− 50.614
 Sweet sauce, sweet topping for desserts1400n/a
 Syrup (incl. from can and for beverages)51275− 610.189
 Unclassified and other chocolate confectionery28101712250.808
 Chocolate tablet1312515240.185
 Chocolate candy bars226221− 190.868
 Chocolate spread and chocolate powder2422202450.403
 Chocolate confectionery71300n/a
 Confectionery non chocolate4412301310.241
Cakes and biscuits82288223− 170.134
 Cakes, pies, pastries, puddings (non milk)32382532− 180.177
 Dry cakes, sweet biscuits75207718− 90.178
Non-alcoholic beverages100590100443− 250.0003
 Fruit and vegetable juices32919030149330.138
 Carbonated/soft/isotonic drinks, diluted8845480364810.002
 Tea2118317126190.035
 Herbal tea11219782100.007
 Waters7417784170860.882
Condiments65175716− 20.424
 Unclassified or combined condiments and sauces1152351370.136
 Other and mixed sauces34201320− 10.874
 Tomato sauces16182023260.467
 Dressing sauces, mayonnaises and similar22131215160.732
 Mayonnaise-based spreads321316− 200.267
 Spices, herbs and flavourings1010− 490.540
 Unclassified and combined condiments213283110.172
 Vinegar1123981
Soups and stocks131121186− 230.661
 Soups6112279− 290.956
 Stocks11721170− 30.606
Savoury snacks46214730420.397
 Unclassified or combined snacks0110n/a
 Savoury snacks, biscuits and crisps43153919320.759
 Savoury filled buns, croissants855967200.832

Bold that indicates the non-alcoholic beverages with p-value 0.0003

aFoods categorised according to the GloboDiet food groups classification system

bCalculated as proportion of YCF (non-)users who consumed a food within the food (sub-)group on at least 1 of the recall days

cMean consumption of users of the specific (sub-)group, weighted for socio-demographic factors, season and day of the week

dDifference calculated as the mean consumption of YCF users divided by the mean consumption of non-YCF users *100%

eP value calculated with the Wilcoxon: Mann: Whitney test. P < 0.0005 was considered statistical significant after the Bonferroni correction. Bold indicates a statistically significant different mean consumption

fNo GloboDiet-subgroup

For most food groups, the proportion of consumers within each food group was equal among the YCF users and YCF non-users (Table 2). A higher proportion of consumers within the YCF user group (≥ 5%-point) were observed for the legumes group, and a lower proportion (≤ 5%-point) for the meat, eggs, sugar and sweets, and condiments groups compared to non-users of YCF. Within the subgroups, more variation of the proportion consumers between the YCF users and non-users was observed.

The proportion of consumers was especially higher among YCF users for breakfast cereals and vegetables oils and lower for other: and mixed sauces and hot-and cold processed meats, compared to non-users of YCF.

Source: Consumption within food (sub)groups Source: Consumption within food (sub)groups

Contribution of YCF to total micronutrient intake

Results: Contribution of YCF to total micronutrient intake

The intake of YCF contributed to the total intake of all micronutrients (Fig. 1). The median contribution to total micronutrient intake among users of YCF was the highest for vitamin D (median: 76%). For most of the other micronutrients, the median contribution to the total intake varied between 0 and 50%. The 0% value being for copper, as the contribution of other foods to total copper is higher. The variation in contribution among subjects was the largest for vitamin A (retinol) and vitamin B12, ranging from 10 to almost 90% (P5-P95).

Fig. 1

Contribution of YCF to the total micronutrient intake of the users (1 to 2 yrs old) of YCF. Upper whisk: P95, upper part boxplot: P75, middle line boxplot: P50, lower part boxplot: P25, lower whisk: P5

Figure image at the original source: open the original paper. This file is not included in this text import.

Source: Contribution of YCF to total micronutrient intake

Adherence to the dietary reference values of users and non-users of YCF

Results: Adherence to the dietary reference values of users and non-users of YCF

For most micronutrients, the median habitual intake of users as well as non-users of YCF was above the adequate intake (AI), indicating a low risk of inadequate micronutrient intakes in the Dutch 1 to 2 year olds (Table 3). For YCF non-users and users, the 95% CI of the median potassium (2-year-olds) and selenium (1-year-olds) intake included the AI. For these nutrients, a low risk on inadequate intakes is likely. For all children, the median habitual intake of vitamin D was below the AI.

Therefore, no statement was possible on the risk of inadequate intakes and additional research is required to study the (in)adequacy.

Table 3

Median habitual intakes of children aged 1: or 2-year-old YCF non-users and users compared to the adequate intake (AI) and upper level (UL)

YCF non-usersYCF users
MicronutrientAIaULMedian habitual intake (95% CI)b,cEvaluation risk inadequate intaked% > UL (95% CI)cMedian habitual intake (95% CI)b,cEvaluation risk inadequate intaked% > UL (95% CI)c
Vitamin A (µg RAE)300/350Not reported492 (448 to 538)LRNot reported570 (492 to 650)LRNot reported
Vitamin A (µg retinol)Not reported800379 (339 to 419)Not reported8.9 (3.6 to 13.8)448 (382 to 515)Not reported11.4 (1.4 to 20.1)
Vitamin A (µg beta-carotene)Not reportedNot reported1091 (882 to 1296)Not reportedNot reported1078 (725 to 1467)Not reportedNot reported
Vitamin B1 (mg)0.3Not reported0.6 (0.6 to 0.6)LRNot reported0.7 (0.6 to 0.7)LRNot reported
Vitamin B2 (mg)0.5Not reported1.0 (0.9 to 1.0)LRNot reported1.1 (1.0 to 1.2)LRNot reported
Vitamin B3 (mg)4Not reported7.9 (7.6 to 8.2)LRNot reported7.9 (7.2 to 8.6)LRNot reported
Vitamin B6 (mg)0.450.9 (0.9 to 1.0)LR0 (0 to 0)0.9 (0.9 to 1.0)LR0 (0 to 0)
Total folate (µg)85Not reported131 (126 to 137)LRNot reported162 (151 to 174)LRNot reported
Folic acid (µg)Not reported2002.3 (0.6 to 4.3)Not reported0 (0 to 0)39.1 (33.8 to 44.2)-0 (0 to 0)
Vitamin B12 (µg)0.7Not reported2.4 (2.3 to 2.6)LRNot reported2.2 (1.9 to 2.4)LRNot reported
Vitamin C (mg)25/30Not reported63 (59 to 67)LRNot reported81 (74 to 88)LRNot reported
Vitamin D (µg)10/3e502.0 (1.8 to 2.1)NSP/NSP0 (0 to 0)7.5 (6.5 to 8.4)NSP / LR0 (0 to 0)
Vitamin E (mg)4/51006.4 (6.1 to 6.7)LR0 (0 to 0)7.7 (7.0 to 8.3)LR0 (0 to 0)
Calcium (mg)500Not reported671 (644 to 699)LR667 (622 to 708)LRNot reported
Copper (mg)0.3/0.410.7 (0.7 to 0.7)LR1.7 (0.2 to 3.5)0.7 (0.7 to 0.8)LR5.1 (0 to 10.1)
Iron (mg)8Not reported5.2 (4.9 to 5.4)NSPNot reported8.0 (7.5 to 8.5)CIAINot reported
Magnesium (mg)85/120Not reported174 (169 to 180)LRNot reported164 (154 to 174)LRNot reported
Potassium (mg)1400/1800Not reported1806 (1751 to 1862)

1 year: LR

2 year: CIAI

Not reported1670 (1572 to 1772)

1 year: LR

2 year: CIAI

Not reported
Phosphorus (mg)470Not reported824 (798 to 851)LRNot reported741 (694 to 786)LRNot reported
Selenium (µg)20/256021 (20 to 22)

1 year: CIAI

2 year: NSP

0 (0 to 0)23 (20 to 27)CIAI0 (0 to 0.2)
Zinc (mg)5/675.3 (5.1 to 5.4)

1 year: CIAI

2 year: NSP

8.7 (4.6 to 12.7)6.2 (5.8 to 6.5)

1 year: LR

2 year: CIAI

27.9

(15.3 to 38.5)

LR low risk, NSP no statement possible, CIAI 95% confidence interval of median intake includes AI

aFor vitamin A, C, E, copper, magnesium, potassium, selenium and zinc different AI values for the 1: and for the 2-year-olds were established

bMedian habitual intake of 1: and 2-year-olds

cSignificant higher median habitual intakes or higher proportions above the UL between non-users and users are displayed as bold

dEvaluation of risk on inadequate intakes separately performed for 1: and 2-year-olds

eTwo AI-values for vitamin D, where 3 µg/day indicates adequate vitamin D intake with enough sun exposure and 10 µg/day if this amount of sun exposure is not met

Higher median habitual intakes were observed for YCF users compared to non-users for vitamin B1, B2, C, D, E, total folate, iron and zinc (Table 3). Of these nutrients, the higher intake of vitamin D (when the assumption of sufficient sunlight exposure is made), iron and zinc (2 year olds) resulted in an AI within or above the 95% CI of the median habitual intake. AI remained below 95% CI of the median intake for non-users. The higher micronutrient intakes of users resulted in higher percentages of children with intakes above the UL for zinc for users (28%) versus non-users (9%).

Lower median habitual intakes were observed for YCF users compared to non-users for potassium and phosphorus (Table 3). These lower intakes did not necessitate a different statement on the risk on inadequate intakes.

Source: Adherence to the dietary reference values of users and non-users of YCF Source: Adherence to the dietary reference values of users and non-users of YCF Source: Adherence to the dietary reference values of users and non-users of YCF

Discussion

About one fifth of the Dutch children aged 1: and 2 years old could be considered to be a YCF user. YCF contributed to the daily intake of all micronutrients studied. In general, for most micronutrients (vitamin A, B1, B2, B3, B6, B12, C, E, total folate, calcium, copper, magnesium, potassium, phosphorus, selenium (1-year-olds) and zinc (1-year-olds)) young children (users of YCF as well as non-users) had a low risk of inadequate intakes.

The higher micronutrient intakes among YCF users only resulted in median intakes above or equal to the AI for vitamin D (and then only if sufficient sunlight exposure was assumed), iron, selenium (2-year-olds) and zinc (2-year-olds). No equivalent statement was possible for the non-users of YCF. For most of the other micronutrients for which higher intakes were observed among users, the non-users already had a low risk of inadequate micronutrient intakes and therefore a higher intake did not change these conclusions.

As there were fewer consumers of regular milk and non-alcoholic beverages among users of YCF and these consumers had a lower intake of these foods, YCF was probably used as a substitute for regular milk and other drinks. Cow-, goat-, or plant-based milks are rich in micronutrients just like YCF. However the micronutrient composition differs slightly. According to the Dutch Food Composition Database, cow-, goat-, or plant-based milk do not contain copper, iron, vitamin D and E, while YCF does [19].

Additionally, the selenium, zinc, vitamin A and C-content of YCF is higher than regular milk. This may at least partly explain the higher habitual vitamin C, D, E, iron and zinc-intakes among users of YCF. On the other hand, cow-, goat-, or plant-based milks have a higher calcium, potassium, magnesium, phosphorus, and beta-carotene-content, possibly explaining why non-users had higher habitual potassium and phosphorus intakes. When we replaced the YCF intakes of YCF users with cow milk, habitual iron, vitamin A, B1, B3, C, D, E, total folate, copper, selenium and zinc intakes decreased and calcium, vitamin B12, potassium and phosphorus intakes increased.

This, however, only resulted in additional median intakes below the AI for iron, selenium (2-year-olds) and vitamin D (when sufficient sunlight was assumed) for YCF users. For all other micronutrients the conclusions when comparing to the AI remained the same as when YCF was consumed. These findings suggest milk consumed as a substitute for YCF results into the same conclusions for most of the micronutrients when comparing to dietary reference values as when YCF was consumed.

Our study showed that the median contribution of YCF to total iron intake was almost 40%. Iron intakes were higher among YCF users compared to non-users and resulted in low risk of inadequate intakes for 1-year-olds. Therefore, YCF has the potential to positively impact iron intakes of young children. A recent study by Sacri et al. (2021) support these findings as French children with higher serum ferritine levels are more often YCF users [21]. In an intervention study funded by the YCF-industry, Akkermans et al. (2017) showed that among Dutch, German and English children aged 12 to 36 months receiving YCF, baseline serum ferritine levels did not change after 20 weeks, while those receiving a non-fortified alternative had lower baseline levels [22].

Our study also found vitamin D-intakes were higher among YCF users, however median intakes were only above the AI for vitamin D for YCF users when sufficient sunlight exposure was assumed. This study does not conclude if sufficient sunlight can be assumed for Dutch children. Vitamin D levels raised among YCF users in the trial by Akkermans et al. (2017), decreasing vitamin D deficiency to 14%, while this increased in the control group to 33% [22]. For children in the Netherlands, a vitamin D supplement of 10 µg/day is advised [23]. 62% of the children aged 1 to 2-year old within the DNFCS 2012 to 2016 adhered to this advice on at least one of the recall days.

Among YCF users this proportion was slightly higher, with 70% compared to 60% among the non-users of YCF. An increase in the proportion of young children achieving the levels advised on all days can result in median habitual intakes above the AI and therefore a low risk on inadequate intakes within the population.

Since 2016, it is clear that YCF does not fall under EU legislation for specific groups, but should be considered as regular fortified food [5, 6]. According to the Dutch government, fortified foods including YCF are not necessary for young children when the food patterns of children are divers and adequate [7]. When there is a risk of insufficient intakes, fortified foods, including YCF, could play a role. The Dutch government therefore intends to create specific legislation for YCF, including maximum micronutrient amounts, but this has not yet been published.

This study showed YCF users had a larger risk of excessive intakes for zinc. The proportion above the UL among YCF users was three times higher compared to the non-users. Of the young children within the DNFCS 2012 to 2016, 15% consumed a zinc supplement on one of the recall days, and among YCF this was 10%. From the DNFCS 2012 to 2016, it was shown zinc intakes from supplements contributes to on average 4% of the total zinc intake of children aged 1 to 3 year old.

In current study, nearly 30% of the 1 to 2-year-olds have intakes above the UL. Supplement intake was not correlated with high zinc intakes from food, therefore this proportion may be even higher when supplements are also considered. For the other nutrients, dietary supplements contributed 0 to 8% to the total micronutrient intakes. Therefore, no changes in the conclusions on the risk of inadequate or excessive intakes in this population group were expected from when only intake from foods were considered.

Dietary reference values are generally set for age-groups rather than age-years. For children, the values are often extrapolated from values set for adults based on body weight or body surface. This study only considered 1 to 2-year-old children, as they are the main consumers of YCF. We compared the intakes of 1-and 2-year-olds with DRVs for larger age groups, i.e., 1 to 3-year-olds or 2 to 5-year-olds. Body weight differences are large among these younger age categories, possibly resulting in incorrect statements on inadequacy or excessive intakes.

As a result, the AI is probably too high for 1-year-olds and correct for 2-year-olds. However, as we compared two groups within the same age categories, the reported difference is expected to be accurate. For example if an AI is set for 1 to 3-year-olds, generally a body weight of 2-year-olds is used for the extrapolation. If a group consisting of 1 to 3-year-olds is compared with this DRV, the overestimation of inadequacy among 1-year-olds is corrected with an underestimation among 3-year-olds. However, in our study we had only 1 to 2-year-olds consuming YCF.

Besides, the AI is a less strong DRV and has uncertainty. It is recommended to study the effect of correcting the DRV for the age-category for which the intake is studied, to see the effects of this problem.

As there were only three children using plant-based YCF in this study, we combined users of milk-based and plant-based YCF in the YCF user category. The micronutrient content of plant-based YCF differs from milk-based YCF, having some lower but also some higher content of specific micronutrients [19]. Although this difference in micronutrient content might change the risk on inadequate micronutrient intakes, also more information is needed on the dietary pattern of these children, as this may also differ between the milk-based and plant-based YCF users.

Due to the low number of children consuming plant-based YCF, we could not study if there were any differences in dietary patterns between the two groups. Future research should study differences in dietary patterns and the risk on inadequate micronutrient intakes in populations with larger amount of children consuming plant-based YCF.

This study was based on data from the DNFCS 2012 to 2016. Data from the DNFCS 2012 to 2016 are representative for the Dutch population and with the extensive questionnaire and interviews for dietary assessment, the intake of Dutch 1-and-2-year-olds can be accurately estimated. The food consumption information was linked to NEVO-database, a comprehensive database which includes most of the foods consumed within the Dutch population. The coverage of the micronutrient content of this database is high, as it is between 71% and 99%.

Micronutrient content was assumed to be zero if micronutrient content was not known, possibly resulting into underestimation of the true content. Food consumption data collected over two recall days is not representative for usual food consumption, as consumption may vary from day to day. With SPADE we could correct for these so-called within-person variances, resulting in habitual intakes of the population. These habitual intakes could be used to evaluate the adherence to the dietary reference values.

Source: Discussion Source: Discussion Source: Discussion Source: Discussion Source: Discussion Source: Discussion Source: Discussion Source: Discussion Source: Discussion

Results

Characteristics of YCF users

Among the Dutch 1: and 2-year-olds, 21% were found to be users of YCF (Table 1). All the characteristics studied were comparable for users and non-users of YCF.

Table 1

Characteristics of YCF non-users and users for 1: and 2-year-oldsa

YCF non-usersYCF usersP valuec
Unweighted
(n = 347)
Weighted
(n = 75)b
Unweighted
(n = 93)
Weighted
(n = 20)b
Sex0.1850
 Boys176 (51%)38 (51%)51 (55%)12 (59%)
 Girls171 (49%)37 (49%)42 (45%)8 (41%)
BMI0.2157

 (Extremely-)

Underweight

32 (9%)8 (11%)4 (4%)1 (5%)
 Normal weight286 (83%)61 (81%)83 (19%)17 (89%)
Overweight/obesity28 (8%)7 (9%)5 (5%)1 (6%)
Educational leveld0.3178
 Low14 (4%)6 (8%)3 (3%)1 (5%)
 Middle98 (22%)27 (36%)30 (32%)9 (45%)
 High235 (67%)42 (56%)60 (65%)10 (51%)
Urbanisatione0.0398
 Extremely/strongly149 (43%)36 (47%)54 (58%)12 (62%)
 Moderately77 (22%)15 (19%)17 (18%)3 (16%)
 Hardly/not121 (35%)25 (33%)22 (24%)4 (21%)
Ethnicity0.9145
 Dutch319 (92%)68 (91%)82 (88%)18 (89%)
 Western immigrant8 (2%)2 (2%)3 (3%)0 (2%)
 Non-Western immigrant20 (6%)5 (7%)8 (9%)2 (8%)
Season (First recall day)0.2004
 Spring94 (27%)21 (27%)14 (15%)3 (16%)
 Summer71 (20%)18 (24%)23 (25%)6 (30%)
 Autumn80 (23%)19 (25%)23 (25%)5 (26%)
 Winter102 (29%)18 (24%)33 (35%)5 (27%)
Recall days0.6288
 Weekend/week157 (45%)36 (47%)41 (44%)9 (48%)
 Only week125 (36%)26 (35%)31 (33%)6 (31%)
 Only weekend65 (19%)13 (18%)21 (23%)4 (21%)

aWeighted for socio-demographic factors, season and day of the week. As children were overrepresented in the original sample, the weight factor had a large impact on the study population size

bAs a result of the use of a weight factor, results needed to be rounded to numbers without decimals, resulting into some groups of non-users and/or users with an n not equal to 75 and/or 20

cP value calculated with the Chi-square. P < 0.007 was considered statistical significant after the Bonferroni correction

dHighest educational level of the parents

eExtremely/strongly urbanised: > 1500 addresses/km2, moderately urbanised: 1000 to 1500 addresses/km2, hardly/not urbanised: < 1000 addresses/km2 [10]

Consumption within food (sub)groups

YCF users had a 25% significantly lower mean consumption of the food group non-alcoholic beverages among YCF users compared to non-users. Besides, YCF users seemed to have a 32% higher dairy consumption compared to YCF non-users from the subgroup ‘non-fermented milk and milk beverages’, which included YCF products as well as regular milk (Table 2). Among YCF users there were fewer consumers of regular milk (cow/goat/plant based), compared to YCF non-users (30%-point lower). Additionally, the regular milk consumers among the YCF users consumed on average 23% less compared to the regular milk consumers among YCF non-users YCF.

Table 2

Mean consumption (in grams) of foods within food (sub-)groups of YCF non-users and users aged 1 to 2 years old

Food (sub-)groupaYCF non-usersYCF users% of difference of mean consumption (%)dp valuee
Proportion of consumers (%)bMean consumption (g/day)cProportion of consumers (%)bMean consumption (g/day)c
Potatoes79687962− 80.389
 Unclassified, mixed and other tubers243527− 370.075
 Potatoes797963− 80.475
Vegetables94689559− 130.201
 Unclassified, mixed salad/vegetables18362230− 160.214
 Leafy vegetables (except cabbages)24441728− 350.381
 Fruiting vegetables64516945− 120.649
 Root vegetables31473840− 160.362
 Cabbages31613244− 280.084
 Mushrooms13131310− 280.991
 Grain and pod vegetables11311617− 450.086
 Leek, onion, garlic40115210− 90.362
 Stalk vegetables, sprouts710916560.524
Legumes759135900.987
Fruits, nuts, seeds and olives9816210016410.994
 Fruits9415191148− 20.570
 Fruit compote279440106130.146
 Nuts, peanuts, seeds51455− 630.052
 Peanut butter, nut/seeds spread2916231750.604
 Olives213218370.699
Dairy100400100476190.055
 Unclassified and mixed dairy products5120196− 200.523
 Non fermented milk and milk beverages8827299359320.002
  Milk (cow/goat/plant-based)f8825659196− 230.012
  Breastmilkf43385164− 520.371
 Fermented milk, milk beverages and yoghurt3621625210− 30.922
 Milk substitutes and milk substitute products51886183− 30.764
 Yoghurt4012131104− 140.158
 Fromage blanc, petits suisses23812969− 140.152
 Cheeses (including spread cheeses)70236821− 70.468
 Cream desserts, puddings (milk based)431502616380.175
 Unclassified creams03315− 840.540
 Dairy creams and creamers1113107− 490.592
 Ice cream (milk based)1042924− 410.193
 Sorbet/water ice1254825− 540.001
Cereals100102100101− 20.554
 Flours, starches, flakes, semolina23163013− 160.698
 Pasta, rice, other grains5054615400.887
 Bread99759870− 70.376
 Crispbread, rusks34102911150.338
 Breakfast cereals30294524− 190.004
 Dough and pastry650329− 430.386
Meat97459438− 170.057
 Unclassified and combined meat and meat products335254560.561
 Unclassified, mixed and other mammals932917− 480.128
 Beef20282219− 330.339
 Pork17361226− 290.332
 Chicken, hen28303629− 60.282
 Turkey, young turkey223720− 150.337
 Hot processed meat56493749− 10.925
 Cold processed meat6820552140.581
 Hot meat substitutes230219− 370.556
 Cold meat substitutes218323300.897
Fish1754155630.837
 Fish847957220.948
 Crustaceans, molluscs234250470.817
 Fish products, fish in crumbs961552− 140.749
Eggs34312026− 170.457
Fat and oils1001210011− 80.381
 Unclassified and combined fats174152− 500.048
 Vegetable oils503674110.561
 Butter167176− 100.628
 Margarines and cooking fats92118410− 50.638
 Other animal fats (including fish oils)0222− 81
Sugar and sweets90208218− 130.362
 Sugar225122− 550.005
 Jam, jelly, marmelade21213015− 270.911
 Honey7642− 680.205
 Other sweet spread287297− 50.614
 Sweet sauce, sweet topping for desserts1400n/a
 Syrup (incl. from can and for beverages)51275− 610.189
 Unclassified and other chocolate confectionery28101712250.808
 Chocolate tablet1312515240.185
 Chocolate candy bars226221− 190.868
 Chocolate spread and chocolate powder2422202450.403
 Chocolate confectionery71300n/a
 Confectionery non chocolate4412301310.241
Cakes and biscuits82288223− 170.134
 Cakes, pies, pastries, puddings (non milk)32382532− 180.177
 Dry cakes, sweet biscuits75207718− 90.178
Non-alcoholic beverages100590100443− 250.0003
 Fruit and vegetable juices32919030149330.138
 Carbonated/soft/isotonic drinks, diluted8845480364810.002
 Tea2118317126190.035
 Herbal tea11219782100.007
 Waters7417784170860.882
Condiments65175716− 20.424
 Unclassified or combined condiments and sauces1152351370.136
 Other and mixed sauces34201320− 10.874
 Tomato sauces16182023260.467
 Dressing sauces, mayonnaises and similar22131215160.732
 Mayonnaise-based spreads321316− 200.267
 Spices, herbs and flavourings1010− 490.540
 Unclassified and combined condiments213283110.172
 Vinegar1123981
Soups and stocks131121186− 230.661
 Soups6112279− 290.956
 Stocks11721170− 30.606
Savoury snacks46214730420.397
 Unclassified or combined snacks0110n/a
 Savoury snacks, biscuits and crisps43153919320.759
 Savoury filled buns, croissants855967200.832

Bold that indicates the non-alcoholic beverages with p-value 0.0003

aFoods categorised according to the GloboDiet food groups classification system

bCalculated as proportion of YCF (non-)users who consumed a food within the food (sub-)group on at least 1 of the recall days

cMean consumption of users of the specific (sub-)group, weighted for socio-demographic factors, season and day of the week

dDifference calculated as the mean consumption of YCF users divided by the mean consumption of non-YCF users *100%

eP value calculated with the Wilcoxon: Mann: Whitney test. P < 0.0005 was considered statistical significant after the Bonferroni correction. Bold indicates a statistically significant different mean consumption

fNo GloboDiet-subgroup

For most food groups, the proportion of consumers within each food group was equal among the YCF users and YCF non-users (Table 2). A higher proportion of consumers within the YCF user group (≥ 5%-point) were observed for the legumes group, and a lower proportion (≤ 5%-point) for the meat, eggs, sugar and sweets, and condiments groups compared to non-users of YCF. Within the subgroups, more variation of the proportion consumers between the YCF users and non-users was observed.

The proportion of consumers was especially higher among YCF users for breakfast cereals and vegetables oils and lower for other: and mixed sauces and hot-and cold processed meats, compared to non-users of YCF.

Contribution of YCF to total micronutrient intake

The intake of YCF contributed to the total intake of all micronutrients (Fig. 1). The median contribution to total micronutrient intake among users of YCF was the highest for vitamin D (median: 76%). For most of the other micronutrients, the median contribution to the total intake varied between 0 and 50%. The 0% value being for copper, as the contribution of other foods to total copper is higher. The variation in contribution among subjects was the largest for vitamin A (retinol) and vitamin B12, ranging from 10 to almost 90% (P5-P95).

Fig. 1

Contribution of YCF to the total micronutrient intake of the users (1 to 2 yrs old) of YCF. Upper whisk: P95, upper part boxplot: P75, middle line boxplot: P50, lower part boxplot: P25, lower whisk: P5

Figure image at the original source: open the original paper. This file is not included in this text import.

Adherence to the dietary reference values of users and non-users of YCF

For most micronutrients, the median habitual intake of users as well as non-users of YCF was above the adequate intake (AI), indicating a low risk of inadequate micronutrient intakes in the Dutch 1 to 2 year olds (Table 3). For YCF non-users and users, the 95% CI of the median potassium (2-year-olds) and selenium (1-year-olds) intake included the AI. For these nutrients, a low risk on inadequate intakes is likely. For all children, the median habitual intake of vitamin D was below the AI.

Therefore, no statement was possible on the risk of inadequate intakes and additional research is required to study the (in)adequacy.

Table 3

Median habitual intakes of children aged 1: or 2-year-old YCF non-users and users compared to the adequate intake (AI) and upper level (UL)

YCF non-usersYCF users
MicronutrientAIaULMedian habitual intake (95% CI)b,cEvaluation risk inadequate intaked% > UL (95% CI)cMedian habitual intake (95% CI)b,cEvaluation risk inadequate intaked% > UL (95% CI)c
Vitamin A (µg RAE)300/350Not reported492 (448 to 538)LRNot reported570 (492 to 650)LRNot reported
Vitamin A (µg retinol)Not reported800379 (339 to 419)Not reported8.9 (3.6 to 13.8)448 (382 to 515)Not reported11.4 (1.4 to 20.1)
Vitamin A (µg beta-carotene)Not reportedNot reported1091 (882 to 1296)Not reportedNot reported1078 (725 to 1467)Not reportedNot reported
Vitamin B1 (mg)0.3Not reported0.6 (0.6 to 0.6)LRNot reported0.7 (0.6 to 0.7)LRNot reported
Vitamin B2 (mg)0.5Not reported1.0 (0.9 to 1.0)LRNot reported1.1 (1.0 to 1.2)LRNot reported
Vitamin B3 (mg)4Not reported7.9 (7.6 to 8.2)LRNot reported7.9 (7.2 to 8.6)LRNot reported
Vitamin B6 (mg)0.450.9 (0.9 to 1.0)LR0 (0 to 0)0.9 (0.9 to 1.0)LR0 (0 to 0)
Total folate (µg)85Not reported131 (126 to 137)LRNot reported162 (151 to 174)LRNot reported
Folic acid (µg)Not reported2002.3 (0.6 to 4.3)Not reported0 (0 to 0)39.1 (33.8 to 44.2)-0 (0 to 0)
Vitamin B12 (µg)0.7Not reported2.4 (2.3 to 2.6)LRNot reported2.2 (1.9 to 2.4)LRNot reported
Vitamin C (mg)25/30Not reported63 (59 to 67)LRNot reported81 (74 to 88)LRNot reported
Vitamin D (µg)10/3e502.0 (1.8 to 2.1)NSP/NSP0 (0 to 0)7.5 (6.5 to 8.4)NSP / LR0 (0 to 0)
Vitamin E (mg)4/51006.4 (6.1 to 6.7)LR0 (0 to 0)7.7 (7.0 to 8.3)LR0 (0 to 0)
Calcium (mg)500Not reported671 (644 to 699)LR667 (622 to 708)LRNot reported
Copper (mg)0.3/0.410.7 (0.7 to 0.7)LR1.7 (0.2 to 3.5)0.7 (0.7 to 0.8)LR5.1 (0 to 10.1)
Iron (mg)8Not reported5.2 (4.9 to 5.4)NSPNot reported8.0 (7.5 to 8.5)CIAINot reported
Magnesium (mg)85/120Not reported174 (169 to 180)LRNot reported164 (154 to 174)LRNot reported
Potassium (mg)1400/1800Not reported1806 (1751 to 1862)

1 year: LR

2 year: CIAI

Not reported1670 (1572 to 1772)

1 year: LR

2 year: CIAI

Not reported
Phosphorus (mg)470Not reported824 (798 to 851)LRNot reported741 (694 to 786)LRNot reported
Selenium (µg)20/256021 (20 to 22)

1 year: CIAI

2 year: NSP

0 (0 to 0)23 (20 to 27)CIAI0 (0 to 0.2)
Zinc (mg)5/675.3 (5.1 to 5.4)

1 year: CIAI

2 year: NSP

8.7 (4.6 to 12.7)6.2 (5.8 to 6.5)

1 year: LR

2 year: CIAI

27.9

(15.3 to 38.5)

LR low risk, NSP no statement possible, CIAI 95% confidence interval of median intake includes AI

aFor vitamin A, C, E, copper, magnesium, potassium, selenium and zinc different AI values for the 1: and for the 2-year-olds were established

bMedian habitual intake of 1: and 2-year-olds

cSignificant higher median habitual intakes or higher proportions above the UL between non-users and users are displayed as bold

dEvaluation of risk on inadequate intakes separately performed for 1: and 2-year-olds

eTwo AI-values for vitamin D, where 3 µg/day indicates adequate vitamin D intake with enough sun exposure and 10 µg/day if this amount of sun exposure is not met

Higher median habitual intakes were observed for YCF users compared to non-users for vitamin B1, B2, C, D, E, total folate, iron and zinc (Table 3). Of these nutrients, the higher intake of vitamin D (when the assumption of sufficient sunlight exposure is made), iron and zinc (2 year olds) resulted in an AI within or above the 95% CI of the median habitual intake. AI remained below 95% CI of the median intake for non-users. The higher micronutrient intakes of users resulted in higher percentages of children with intakes above the UL for zinc for users (28%) versus non-users (9%).

Lower median habitual intakes were observed for YCF users compared to non-users for potassium and phosphorus (Table 3). These lower intakes did not necessitate a different statement on the risk on inadequate intakes.

Source: Results Source: Results Source: Results Source: Results

Conclusion

One-fifth of the young children in the Netherlands use YCF. Although YCF increases micronutrient intake, for most of the micronutrients a low risk of inadequate intakes exists among users as well as non-users of YCF. For most micronutrients the additional intake from fortified YCF seems unnecessary to achieve adequate intakes. The consumption of YCF increased the risk of excessive zinc intakes. It is important that the addition of micronutrients to YCF is regulated, to prevent excessive intakes.

Source: Conclusion
Authors’ abstract

Purpose

Adequate micronutrient intakes are essential for young children. Special young child formulae (YCF) intended for children from 1 year old are available in the Dutch market. Since YCF are enriched with many micronutrients, it has the potential to have a beneficial effect on young children, or might pose a risk on excessive micronutrient intakes. The current study investigated the characteristics of YCF users, and the effect of YCF use on micronutrient intakes.

Methods

Data from the Dutch National Food Consumption Survey (2012 to 2016; n = 440 children aged 1 to 2 year old) and the Dutch Food Composition Database (NEVO version 2016) were used to assess micronutrient intakes. Habitual intakes of users and non-users of YCF were calculated using Statistical Program to Assess Dietary Exposure (SPADE) and compared.

Results

In the Netherlands, YCF was consumed by 21% of the 1 to 2-year-olds. YCF contributed mostly to total vitamin D intake (76%) and between 0 and 50% for other micronutrients. Higher vitamin A, B1, C, D, E, total folate, iron and zinc intakes were observed among users, and higher potassium and phosphorus intakes were found among non-users. Risk of inadequate intake was low among both users and non-users for most nutrients, and the only elevated risk of excessive intake found was for zinc among YCF users.

Conclusion

YCF increased micronutrient intake, however, for most of the micronutrients there is already a low risk of inadequate intake. YCF increased the risk of excessive zinc intake. It is important that the addition of micronutrients to YCF is regulated, to prevent excessive intake.

Read the full paper

Introduction

Adequate micronutrient (vitamins and mineral) intakes are essential for health [1]. Optimal nutrition is especially important for young children, as this is involved in healthy growth. Inadequate micronutrient intake may result in deficiency symptoms and eventually in deficiency diseases [2]. However, in addition to the risk of deficiency diseases, excessive micronutrient intakes can also be harmful and lead to adverse health effects on the long term [1].

A healthy diet can provide sufficient intake of micronutrients. This is also the case for young children, except for vitamin D and K, for which the Dutch government advises use of supplements [3]. For breastfed children, 150 µg vitamin K/day is advised in the first 12 weeks of life and for all children up to 4 years old 10 µg vitamin D/day is advised. To help parents providing micronutrients to young children, special formulas intended for children from 1 year old are available on the Dutch market.

These so-called young child formulas (YCF) are marketed as the replacement of infant formula and follow-up formulas, when children are 1 year old. Similar to infant: and follow-up formulas, YCF are milk: or plant-based drinks fortified with many micronutrients. Although YCF are available, there is no Dutch recommendation to use this type of product [4]. Dutch parents are advised to stop with follow-up formula after the first birthday of the child and to offer regular (plant-based) dairy to their children.

Unlike infant formula and follow-up formula, there is no specific legislation for the composition of YCF [5, 6]. Since 2016, YCF falls under the legislation for regular foods [5], meaning it has to meet the fortification rules for regular foods. However, with the current composition of the YCF, which is generally based on follow-up formula, these rules cannot be met. In the Dutch legislation there are limitations on which micronutrients can be added and at what level.

As YCF is such a specific type of food for a specific small population group, the Dutch government is working to produce guidance with minimum and maximum micronutrient contents for YCF [7].

Since YCF is enriched with many micronutrients, it has the potential to increase micronutrient intake and therefore might have a beneficial effect on young children. In the Dutch National Food Consumption Survey (DNFCS) 2012 to 2016, Van Rossum et al. (2020) did not find evidence of a low risk on inadequate vitamin D and iron intakes for young children [8]. On the other hand, the high micronutrient content might pose a risk on excessive intakes. Among Dutch young children, copper, zinc and vitamin A (retinol) intakes are high [8].

In this study, the contribution of YCF consumption on the micronutrient intake of children aged 1 to 2 year old was investigated. Characteristics of users of YCF were explored as well as the food pattern of (non-)users of YCF. Additionally, the contribution of YCF to the total micronutrient intakes was examined and the impact of YCF on the risk of inadequate or excessive intakes was investigated.

Methods

Survey population

In the Dutch National Food Consumption Survey (DNFCS) 2012 to 2016, data were collected on food consumption of the Dutch population (N = 4313, 1 to 79 yr.). A detailed description of the DNFCS 2012 to 2016 is described elsewhere [8].

The current study focused on children aged 1 to 2 year old. Food consumption of children was estimated by interviewing parents or caretakers about their child’s food consumption. For all children, two 24-h recalls on non-consecutive days were performed by trained dieticians using GloboDiet (IARC©; former EPIC-Soft). Height and weight were measured on the first recall day. Body mass index (BMI) was calculated per child as the body weight divided by the height squared (kg/m2) and categorized into seriously underweight and underweight, normal weight and overweight and obesity.

Categorization was based on age-specific BMI cutoff values specified for gender and month of age [9]. With a general questionnaire, other general information of the participants was collected. Various background factors, such as educational level, native country, family size, and various general characteristics of the diet, such as special diets and eating habits were also recorded. The degree of urbanisation was divided in extremely urbanised (2500 or more addresses/km2), strongly (1500 to 2500 addresses/km2), moderately (1000 to 1500 addresses/km2), hardly (500 to 1000 addresses/km2) and not urbanised (fewer than 500 addresses/km2), as distinguished by Statistics Netherlands (CBS) [10].

The highest education qualification of the head of the household was recorded.

Definition YCF

YCF were defined as milk: or plant-based drinks fortified with micronutrients and intended as the replacement of infant formula and follow-up formulas, designed for children aged 1 year and older. No distinction between milk-based YCF and plant-based YCF was made as there were only three children using plant-based YCF. Users of YCF were considered as user when they consumed at least one time a YCF product on at least one of the recall days.

Food groups

Mean consumption in g/day from all food groups (according to the GloboDiet classification system [8]) was calculated for users and non-users of YCF separately. The GloboDiet classification consists of 18 main: and 78 subgroups. To study if non-users of YCF consume more regular milk than YCF users, also the mean intake from milk and breast milk was calculated. Milk included regular cow milk (skimmed, semi-skimmed and full fat), raw milk, buttermilk, milk enriched with calcium, semi-skimmed lactose free milk, full fat goat milk, almond milk, soymilk and rice milk.

Breastmilk could only be quantified if the milk was pumped and then fed to the child. If the milk was not pumped, the quantity was assumed to be 70 ml for each feeding, based on the declining breast milk intake for older infants as assumed by the EFSA [11].

Contribution of YCF to total micronutrient intake

Food consumption data from DNFCS 2012 to 2016 was linked to the Dutch Food Composition Database (NEVO; NEVO-online version 2016/5.0, RIVM, Bilthoven, 2016, with additions for the DNFCS 2012 to 2016) to estimate micronutrient intakes. Consumption data of YCF were linked to brand specific NEVO codes. To classify a formula as YCF, each NEVO code consumed within DNFCS 2012 to 2016 was checked to see it was YCF and not infant formula or follow-up formula. In this study we only considered the micronutrient intake from foods, intake from dietary supplements was excluded.

The impact of YCF consumption was studied by calculating the contribution of YCF to total micronutrient intake. For these analyses, only the recall days on which a YCF was consumed were included. This means if a user consumed YCF on only one recall day, only that day was included.

Assessment of risk on inadequate and excessive micronutrient intakes

The dietary reference values (DRV) adopted in 2015 by the Health Council of the Netherlands from the DRVs established by the Health Council of the Netherlands in 2000, 2003 and 2012, by the Nordic Council in 2012 and by the EFSA in 2006 were used in this study to assess the risk of inadequate and excessive intakes [1, 12Not reported16]. An estimated average requirement (EAR) is a reference value sufficient for half of the population [17].

When scientific evidence is insufficient to establish an EAR, an adequate intake (AI) is proposed. This reference value is sufficient for almost everyone in the population. All the DRVs for adequate intake used in this study were AIs. For vitamin D, the AI for both sufficient as insufficient sunlight exposure was used for all children, as the amount of sunlight exposure for each child was unknown. To assess the risk on excessive intakes, the tolerable upper levels (UL) were used.

Statistical analysis

To produce results representative of the Dutch population (in calendar year 2014) a weighting factor was applied in the analyses. This weighting factor included socio-demographic factors, as well as season and day of the week. As children were overrepresented in the study population (half of the study population consisted of children), the weight factor had a large impact on the population size after weighing. This weighted study population was used for the analysis of 1 to 2 year olds in current study.

General characteristics of YCF-users and non-users were compared with a Chi-Square test. The level of significance was corrected for multiple comparisons using the Bonferroni correction [18]. A p value < 0.007 was considered to indicate a statistically significant difference between the groups.

Mean consumption from food groups was calculated from the mean consumption of 2 recall days per participant for YCF users and non-users separately. The proportion of consumers of each food (sub)group was calculated as the number of users within food (sub)group divided by total subjects within the YCF non-user or user group. The percentage of difference in mean consumption within the food groups between the YCF non-users and users was assessed. Mean consumption from different food (sub)groups between users and non-users of YCF were compared using the Wilcoxon-Mann: Whitney test.

The level of significance was corrected for multiple comparison using the Bonferroni correction and a p value < 0.0005 was considered as statistically significant.

Calculation of the contribution of YCF to total micronutrient intake and the habitual intakes was performed for the micronutrients calcium, copper, iron, magnesium, phosphorus, potassium, selenium, zinc, vitamin A (retinol, retinol activity equivalents (RAE) and beta-carotenes), vitamins B1, B2, B3, B6, B12, C, D and E, and folate (total folate (both naturally present and folic acid)), calcium, copper, iron, magnesium, phosphorus, potassium, selenium and zinc. For vitamin A expressed as RAE, 1 μg RAE was assumed to be equal to 1 μg retinol, 12 μg β-carotene and 24 μg other carotenoids [17].

Folate equivalents were calculated as the amount of folate naturally present in foods (in μg) and 1.7 times the amount of folic acid in enriched foods (in μg) [19].

For all micronutrients studied, the habitual intake (also referred to as usual intake) distribution was estimated by correcting the data for the within-person variation using the Statistical Program to Assess Dietary Exposure (SPADE version 4.0.85 of 16 December 2020) using R version 4.0.3. Intakes were age-dependently modelled for 1: and 2-year-olds, using the 1-part model.

The adequacy was only qualitatively assessed using an ‘adequate intake’ (AI), as no ‘estimated average requirement’ (EAR) was established for young children. A habitual median intake above the AI was considered as a low risk of inadequate micronutrient intake. If the median habitual intake was below the adequate intake, no statement about the adequacy could be made. If the 95% confidence interval (CI) of the median intake included the AI, we assumed a low risk of inadequacy. This assessment was made for 1: and 2-year-olds separately, based on the age-specific habitual intakes.

Additionally, the proportion of the population with a habitual micronutrient intake above the UL was estimated. A proportion larger than 2.5% was considered high. Lower proportions were considered tolerable.

Habitual intakes and proportions above the upper level (UL) of users and non-users were compared by estimating the difference between users and non-users and calculating 95% CIs for these differences, based on 200 bootstrap iterations, similar to Dekkers and Slob [20]. If the 95% CI for difference did not include zero, habitual intakes or proportions above UL were considered as statistically different between users and non-users.

Statistical analyses were performed using SAS version 9 (Windows version 6.3.9600), unless stated otherwise.

Results

Characteristics of YCF users

Among the Dutch 1: and 2-year-olds, 21% were found to be users of YCF (Table 1). All the characteristics studied were comparable for users and non-users of YCF.

Table 1

Characteristics of YCF non-users and users for 1: and 2-year-oldsa

YCF non-usersYCF usersP valuec
Unweighted
(n = 347)
Weighted
(n = 75)b
Unweighted
(n = 93)
Weighted
(n = 20)b
Sex0.1850
 Boys176 (51%)38 (51%)51 (55%)12 (59%)
 Girls171 (49%)37 (49%)42 (45%)8 (41%)
BMI0.2157

 (Extremely-)

Underweight

32 (9%)8 (11%)4 (4%)1 (5%)
 Normal weight286 (83%)61 (81%)83 (19%)17 (89%)
Overweight/obesity28 (8%)7 (9%)5 (5%)1 (6%)
Educational leveld0.3178
 Low14 (4%)6 (8%)3 (3%)1 (5%)
 Middle98 (22%)27 (36%)30 (32%)9 (45%)
 High235 (67%)42 (56%)60 (65%)10 (51%)
Urbanisatione0.0398
 Extremely/strongly149 (43%)36 (47%)54 (58%)12 (62%)
 Moderately77 (22%)15 (19%)17 (18%)3 (16%)
 Hardly/not121 (35%)25 (33%)22 (24%)4 (21%)
Ethnicity0.9145
 Dutch319 (92%)68 (91%)82 (88%)18 (89%)
 Western immigrant8 (2%)2 (2%)3 (3%)0 (2%)
 Non-Western immigrant20 (6%)5 (7%)8 (9%)2 (8%)
Season (First recall day)0.2004
 Spring94 (27%)21 (27%)14 (15%)3 (16%)
 Summer71 (20%)18 (24%)23 (25%)6 (30%)
 Autumn80 (23%)19 (25%)23 (25%)5 (26%)
 Winter102 (29%)18 (24%)33 (35%)5 (27%)
Recall days0.6288
 Weekend/week157 (45%)36 (47%)41 (44%)9 (48%)
 Only week125 (36%)26 (35%)31 (33%)6 (31%)
 Only weekend65 (19%)13 (18%)21 (23%)4 (21%)

aWeighted for socio-demographic factors, season and day of the week. As children were overrepresented in the original sample, the weight factor had a large impact on the study population size

bAs a result of the use of a weight factor, results needed to be rounded to numbers without decimals, resulting into some groups of non-users and/or users with an n not equal to 75 and/or 20

cP value calculated with the Chi-square. P < 0.007 was considered statistical significant after the Bonferroni correction

dHighest educational level of the parents

eExtremely/strongly urbanised: > 1500 addresses/km2, moderately urbanised: 1000 to 1500 addresses/km2, hardly/not urbanised: < 1000 addresses/km2 [10]

Consumption within food (sub)groups

YCF users had a 25% significantly lower mean consumption of the food group non-alcoholic beverages among YCF users compared to non-users. Besides, YCF users seemed to have a 32% higher dairy consumption compared to YCF non-users from the subgroup ‘non-fermented milk and milk beverages’, which included YCF products as well as regular milk (Table 2). Among YCF users there were fewer consumers of regular milk (cow/goat/plant based), compared to YCF non-users (30%-point lower). Additionally, the regular milk consumers among the YCF users consumed on average 23% less compared to the regular milk consumers among YCF non-users YCF.

Table 2

Mean consumption (in grams) of foods within food (sub-)groups of YCF non-users and users aged 1 to 2 years old

Food (sub-)groupaYCF non-usersYCF users% of difference of mean consumption (%)dp valuee
Proportion of consumers (%)bMean consumption (g/day)cProportion of consumers (%)bMean consumption (g/day)c
Potatoes79687962− 80.389
 Unclassified, mixed and other tubers243527− 370.075
 Potatoes797963− 80.475
Vegetables94689559− 130.201
 Unclassified, mixed salad/vegetables18362230− 160.214
 Leafy vegetables (except cabbages)24441728− 350.381
 Fruiting vegetables64516945− 120.649
 Root vegetables31473840− 160.362
 Cabbages31613244− 280.084
 Mushrooms13131310− 280.991
 Grain and pod vegetables11311617− 450.086
 Leek, onion, garlic40115210− 90.362
 Stalk vegetables, sprouts710916560.524
Legumes759135900.987
Fruits, nuts, seeds and olives9816210016410.994
 Fruits9415191148− 20.570
 Fruit compote279440106130.146
 Nuts, peanuts, seeds51455− 630.052
 Peanut butter, nut/seeds spread2916231750.604
 Olives213218370.699
Dairy100400100476190.055
 Unclassified and mixed dairy products5120196− 200.523
 Non fermented milk and milk beverages8827299359320.002
  Milk (cow/goat/plant-based)f8825659196− 230.012
  Breastmilkf43385164− 520.371
 Fermented milk, milk beverages and yoghurt3621625210− 30.922
 Milk substitutes and milk substitute products51886183− 30.764
 Yoghurt4012131104− 140.158
 Fromage blanc, petits suisses23812969− 140.152
 Cheeses (including spread cheeses)70236821− 70.468
 Cream desserts, puddings (milk based)431502616380.175
 Unclassified creams03315− 840.540
 Dairy creams and creamers1113107− 490.592
 Ice cream (milk based)1042924− 410.193
 Sorbet/water ice1254825− 540.001
Cereals100102100101− 20.554
 Flours, starches, flakes, semolina23163013− 160.698
 Pasta, rice, other grains5054615400.887
 Bread99759870− 70.376
 Crispbread, rusks34102911150.338
 Breakfast cereals30294524− 190.004
 Dough and pastry650329− 430.386
Meat97459438− 170.057
 Unclassified and combined meat and meat products335254560.561
 Unclassified, mixed and other mammals932917− 480.128
 Beef20282219− 330.339
 Pork17361226− 290.332
 Chicken, hen28303629− 60.282
 Turkey, young turkey223720− 150.337
 Hot processed meat56493749− 10.925
 Cold processed meat6820552140.581
 Hot meat substitutes230219− 370.556
 Cold meat substitutes218323300.897
Fish1754155630.837
 Fish847957220.948
 Crustaceans, molluscs234250470.817
 Fish products, fish in crumbs961552− 140.749
Eggs34312026− 170.457
Fat and oils1001210011− 80.381
 Unclassified and combined fats174152− 500.048
 Vegetable oils503674110.561
 Butter167176− 100.628
 Margarines and cooking fats92118410− 50.638
 Other animal fats (including fish oils)0222− 81
Sugar and sweets90208218− 130.362
 Sugar225122− 550.005
 Jam, jelly, marmelade21213015− 270.911
 Honey7642− 680.205
 Other sweet spread287297− 50.614
 Sweet sauce, sweet topping for desserts1400n/a
 Syrup (incl. from can and for beverages)51275− 610.189
 Unclassified and other chocolate confectionery28101712250.808
 Chocolate tablet1312515240.185
 Chocolate candy bars226221− 190.868
 Chocolate spread and chocolate powder2422202450.403
 Chocolate confectionery71300n/a
 Confectionery non chocolate4412301310.241
Cakes and biscuits82288223− 170.134
 Cakes, pies, pastries, puddings (non milk)32382532− 180.177
 Dry cakes, sweet biscuits75207718− 90.178
Non-alcoholic beverages100590100443− 250.0003
 Fruit and vegetable juices32919030149330.138
 Carbonated/soft/isotonic drinks, diluted8845480364810.002
 Tea2118317126190.035
 Herbal tea11219782100.007
 Waters7417784170860.882
Condiments65175716− 20.424
 Unclassified or combined condiments and sauces1152351370.136
 Other and mixed sauces34201320− 10.874
 Tomato sauces16182023260.467
 Dressing sauces, mayonnaises and similar22131215160.732
 Mayonnaise-based spreads321316− 200.267
 Spices, herbs and flavourings1010− 490.540
 Unclassified and combined condiments213283110.172
 Vinegar1123981
Soups and stocks131121186− 230.661
 Soups6112279− 290.956
 Stocks11721170− 30.606
Savoury snacks46214730420.397
 Unclassified or combined snacks0110n/a
 Savoury snacks, biscuits and crisps43153919320.759
 Savoury filled buns, croissants855967200.832

Bold that indicates the non-alcoholic beverages with p-value 0.0003

aFoods categorised according to the GloboDiet food groups classification system

bCalculated as proportion of YCF (non-)users who consumed a food within the food (sub-)group on at least 1 of the recall days

cMean consumption of users of the specific (sub-)group, weighted for socio-demographic factors, season and day of the week

dDifference calculated as the mean consumption of YCF users divided by the mean consumption of non-YCF users *100%

eP value calculated with the Wilcoxon: Mann: Whitney test. P < 0.0005 was considered statistical significant after the Bonferroni correction. Bold indicates a statistically significant different mean consumption

fNo GloboDiet-subgroup

For most food groups, the proportion of consumers within each food group was equal among the YCF users and YCF non-users (Table 2). A higher proportion of consumers within the YCF user group (≥ 5%-point) were observed for the legumes group, and a lower proportion (≤ 5%-point) for the meat, eggs, sugar and sweets, and condiments groups compared to non-users of YCF. Within the subgroups, more variation of the proportion consumers between the YCF users and non-users was observed.

The proportion of consumers was especially higher among YCF users for breakfast cereals and vegetables oils and lower for other: and mixed sauces and hot-and cold processed meats, compared to non-users of YCF.

Contribution of YCF to total micronutrient intake

The intake of YCF contributed to the total intake of all micronutrients (Fig. 1). The median contribution to total micronutrient intake among users of YCF was the highest for vitamin D (median: 76%). For most of the other micronutrients, the median contribution to the total intake varied between 0 and 50%. The 0% value being for copper, as the contribution of other foods to total copper is higher. The variation in contribution among subjects was the largest for vitamin A (retinol) and vitamin B12, ranging from 10 to almost 90% (P5-P95).

Fig. 1

Contribution of YCF to the total micronutrient intake of the users (1 to 2 yrs old) of YCF. Upper whisk: P95, upper part boxplot: P75, middle line boxplot: P50, lower part boxplot: P25, lower whisk: P5

Figure image at the original source: open the original paper. This file is not included in this text import.

Adherence to the dietary reference values of users and non-users of YCF

For most micronutrients, the median habitual intake of users as well as non-users of YCF was above the adequate intake (AI), indicating a low risk of inadequate micronutrient intakes in the Dutch 1 to 2 year olds (Table 3). For YCF non-users and users, the 95% CI of the median potassium (2-year-olds) and selenium (1-year-olds) intake included the AI. For these nutrients, a low risk on inadequate intakes is likely. For all children, the median habitual intake of vitamin D was below the AI.

Therefore, no statement was possible on the risk of inadequate intakes and additional research is required to study the (in)adequacy.

Table 3

Median habitual intakes of children aged 1: or 2-year-old YCF non-users and users compared to the adequate intake (AI) and upper level (UL)

YCF non-usersYCF users
MicronutrientAIaULMedian habitual intake (95% CI)b,cEvaluation risk inadequate intaked% > UL (95% CI)cMedian habitual intake (95% CI)b,cEvaluation risk inadequate intaked% > UL (95% CI)c
Vitamin A (µg RAE)300/350Not reported492 (448 to 538)LRNot reported570 (492 to 650)LRNot reported
Vitamin A (µg retinol)Not reported800379 (339 to 419)Not reported8.9 (3.6 to 13.8)448 (382 to 515)Not reported11.4 (1.4 to 20.1)
Vitamin A (µg beta-carotene)Not reportedNot reported1091 (882 to 1296)Not reportedNot reported1078 (725 to 1467)Not reportedNot reported
Vitamin B1 (mg)0.3Not reported0.6 (0.6 to 0.6)LRNot reported0.7 (0.6 to 0.7)LRNot reported
Vitamin B2 (mg)0.5Not reported1.0 (0.9 to 1.0)LRNot reported1.1 (1.0 to 1.2)LRNot reported
Vitamin B3 (mg)4Not reported7.9 (7.6 to 8.2)LRNot reported7.9 (7.2 to 8.6)LRNot reported
Vitamin B6 (mg)0.450.9 (0.9 to 1.0)LR0 (0 to 0)0.9 (0.9 to 1.0)LR0 (0 to 0)
Total folate (µg)85Not reported131 (126 to 137)LRNot reported162 (151 to 174)LRNot reported
Folic acid (µg)Not reported2002.3 (0.6 to 4.3)Not reported0 (0 to 0)39.1 (33.8 to 44.2)-0 (0 to 0)
Vitamin B12 (µg)0.7Not reported2.4 (2.3 to 2.6)LRNot reported2.2 (1.9 to 2.4)LRNot reported
Vitamin C (mg)25/30Not reported63 (59 to 67)LRNot reported81 (74 to 88)LRNot reported
Vitamin D (µg)10/3e502.0 (1.8 to 2.1)NSP/NSP0 (0 to 0)7.5 (6.5 to 8.4)NSP / LR0 (0 to 0)
Vitamin E (mg)4/51006.4 (6.1 to 6.7)LR0 (0 to 0)7.7 (7.0 to 8.3)LR0 (0 to 0)
Calcium (mg)500Not reported671 (644 to 699)LR667 (622 to 708)LRNot reported
Copper (mg)0.3/0.410.7 (0.7 to 0.7)LR1.7 (0.2 to 3.5)0.7 (0.7 to 0.8)LR5.1 (0 to 10.1)
Iron (mg)8Not reported5.2 (4.9 to 5.4)NSPNot reported8.0 (7.5 to 8.5)CIAINot reported
Magnesium (mg)85/120Not reported174 (169 to 180)LRNot reported164 (154 to 174)LRNot reported
Potassium (mg)1400/1800Not reported1806 (1751 to 1862)

1 year: LR

2 year: CIAI

Not reported1670 (1572 to 1772)

1 year: LR

2 year: CIAI

Not reported
Phosphorus (mg)470Not reported824 (798 to 851)LRNot reported741 (694 to 786)LRNot reported
Selenium (µg)20/256021 (20 to 22)

1 year: CIAI

2 year: NSP

0 (0 to 0)23 (20 to 27)CIAI0 (0 to 0.2)
Zinc (mg)5/675.3 (5.1 to 5.4)

1 year: CIAI

2 year: NSP

8.7 (4.6 to 12.7)6.2 (5.8 to 6.5)

1 year: LR

2 year: CIAI

27.9

(15.3 to 38.5)

LR low risk, NSP no statement possible, CIAI 95% confidence interval of median intake includes AI

aFor vitamin A, C, E, copper, magnesium, potassium, selenium and zinc different AI values for the 1: and for the 2-year-olds were established

bMedian habitual intake of 1: and 2-year-olds

cSignificant higher median habitual intakes or higher proportions above the UL between non-users and users are displayed as bold

dEvaluation of risk on inadequate intakes separately performed for 1: and 2-year-olds

eTwo AI-values for vitamin D, where 3 µg/day indicates adequate vitamin D intake with enough sun exposure and 10 µg/day if this amount of sun exposure is not met

Higher median habitual intakes were observed for YCF users compared to non-users for vitamin B1, B2, C, D, E, total folate, iron and zinc (Table 3). Of these nutrients, the higher intake of vitamin D (when the assumption of sufficient sunlight exposure is made), iron and zinc (2 year olds) resulted in an AI within or above the 95% CI of the median habitual intake. AI remained below 95% CI of the median intake for non-users. The higher micronutrient intakes of users resulted in higher percentages of children with intakes above the UL for zinc for users (28%) versus non-users (9%).

Lower median habitual intakes were observed for YCF users compared to non-users for potassium and phosphorus (Table 3). These lower intakes did not necessitate a different statement on the risk on inadequate intakes.

Discussion

About one fifth of the Dutch children aged 1: and 2 years old could be considered to be a YCF user. YCF contributed to the daily intake of all micronutrients studied. In general, for most micronutrients (vitamin A, B1, B2, B3, B6, B12, C, E, total folate, calcium, copper, magnesium, potassium, phosphorus, selenium (1-year-olds) and zinc (1-year-olds)) young children (users of YCF as well as non-users) had a low risk of inadequate intakes.

The higher micronutrient intakes among YCF users only resulted in median intakes above or equal to the AI for vitamin D (and then only if sufficient sunlight exposure was assumed), iron, selenium (2-year-olds) and zinc (2-year-olds). No equivalent statement was possible for the non-users of YCF. For most of the other micronutrients for which higher intakes were observed among users, the non-users already had a low risk of inadequate micronutrient intakes and therefore a higher intake did not change these conclusions.

As there were fewer consumers of regular milk and non-alcoholic beverages among users of YCF and these consumers had a lower intake of these foods, YCF was probably used as a substitute for regular milk and other drinks. Cow-, goat-, or plant-based milks are rich in micronutrients just like YCF. However the micronutrient composition differs slightly. According to the Dutch Food Composition Database, cow-, goat-, or plant-based milk do not contain copper, iron, vitamin D and E, while YCF does [19].

Additionally, the selenium, zinc, vitamin A and C-content of YCF is higher than regular milk. This may at least partly explain the higher habitual vitamin C, D, E, iron and zinc-intakes among users of YCF. On the other hand, cow-, goat-, or plant-based milks have a higher calcium, potassium, magnesium, phosphorus, and beta-carotene-content, possibly explaining why non-users had higher habitual potassium and phosphorus intakes. When we replaced the YCF intakes of YCF users with cow milk, habitual iron, vitamin A, B1, B3, C, D, E, total folate, copper, selenium and zinc intakes decreased and calcium, vitamin B12, potassium and phosphorus intakes increased.

This, however, only resulted in additional median intakes below the AI for iron, selenium (2-year-olds) and vitamin D (when sufficient sunlight was assumed) for YCF users. For all other micronutrients the conclusions when comparing to the AI remained the same as when YCF was consumed. These findings suggest milk consumed as a substitute for YCF results into the same conclusions for most of the micronutrients when comparing to dietary reference values as when YCF was consumed.

Our study showed that the median contribution of YCF to total iron intake was almost 40%. Iron intakes were higher among YCF users compared to non-users and resulted in low risk of inadequate intakes for 1-year-olds. Therefore, YCF has the potential to positively impact iron intakes of young children. A recent study by Sacri et al. (2021) support these findings as French children with higher serum ferritine levels are more often YCF users [21]. In an intervention study funded by the YCF-industry, Akkermans et al. (2017) showed that among Dutch, German and English children aged 12 to 36 months receiving YCF, baseline serum ferritine levels did not change after 20 weeks, while those receiving a non-fortified alternative had lower baseline levels [22].

Our study also found vitamin D-intakes were higher among YCF users, however median intakes were only above the AI for vitamin D for YCF users when sufficient sunlight exposure was assumed. This study does not conclude if sufficient sunlight can be assumed for Dutch children. Vitamin D levels raised among YCF users in the trial by Akkermans et al. (2017), decreasing vitamin D deficiency to 14%, while this increased in the control group to 33% [22]. For children in the Netherlands, a vitamin D supplement of 10 µg/day is advised [23]. 62% of the children aged 1 to 2-year old within the DNFCS 2012 to 2016 adhered to this advice on at least one of the recall days.

Among YCF users this proportion was slightly higher, with 70% compared to 60% among the non-users of YCF. An increase in the proportion of young children achieving the levels advised on all days can result in median habitual intakes above the AI and therefore a low risk on inadequate intakes within the population.

Since 2016, it is clear that YCF does not fall under EU legislation for specific groups, but should be considered as regular fortified food [5, 6]. According to the Dutch government, fortified foods including YCF are not necessary for young children when the food patterns of children are divers and adequate [7]. When there is a risk of insufficient intakes, fortified foods, including YCF, could play a role. The Dutch government therefore intends to create specific legislation for YCF, including maximum micronutrient amounts, but this has not yet been published.

This study showed YCF users had a larger risk of excessive intakes for zinc. The proportion above the UL among YCF users was three times higher compared to the non-users. Of the young children within the DNFCS 2012 to 2016, 15% consumed a zinc supplement on one of the recall days, and among YCF this was 10%. From the DNFCS 2012 to 2016, it was shown zinc intakes from supplements contributes to on average 4% of the total zinc intake of children aged 1 to 3 year old.

In current study, nearly 30% of the 1 to 2-year-olds have intakes above the UL. Supplement intake was not correlated with high zinc intakes from food, therefore this proportion may be even higher when supplements are also considered. For the other nutrients, dietary supplements contributed 0 to 8% to the total micronutrient intakes. Therefore, no changes in the conclusions on the risk of inadequate or excessive intakes in this population group were expected from when only intake from foods were considered.

Dietary reference values are generally set for age-groups rather than age-years. For children, the values are often extrapolated from values set for adults based on body weight or body surface. This study only considered 1 to 2-year-old children, as they are the main consumers of YCF. We compared the intakes of 1-and 2-year-olds with DRVs for larger age groups, i.e., 1 to 3-year-olds or 2 to 5-year-olds. Body weight differences are large among these younger age categories, possibly resulting in incorrect statements on inadequacy or excessive intakes.

As a result, the AI is probably too high for 1-year-olds and correct for 2-year-olds. However, as we compared two groups within the same age categories, the reported difference is expected to be accurate. For example if an AI is set for 1 to 3-year-olds, generally a body weight of 2-year-olds is used for the extrapolation. If a group consisting of 1 to 3-year-olds is compared with this DRV, the overestimation of inadequacy among 1-year-olds is corrected with an underestimation among 3-year-olds. However, in our study we had only 1 to 2-year-olds consuming YCF.

Besides, the AI is a less strong DRV and has uncertainty. It is recommended to study the effect of correcting the DRV for the age-category for which the intake is studied, to see the effects of this problem.

As there were only three children using plant-based YCF in this study, we combined users of milk-based and plant-based YCF in the YCF user category. The micronutrient content of plant-based YCF differs from milk-based YCF, having some lower but also some higher content of specific micronutrients [19]. Although this difference in micronutrient content might change the risk on inadequate micronutrient intakes, also more information is needed on the dietary pattern of these children, as this may also differ between the milk-based and plant-based YCF users.

Due to the low number of children consuming plant-based YCF, we could not study if there were any differences in dietary patterns between the two groups. Future research should study differences in dietary patterns and the risk on inadequate micronutrient intakes in populations with larger amount of children consuming plant-based YCF.

This study was based on data from the DNFCS 2012 to 2016. Data from the DNFCS 2012 to 2016 are representative for the Dutch population and with the extensive questionnaire and interviews for dietary assessment, the intake of Dutch 1-and-2-year-olds can be accurately estimated. The food consumption information was linked to NEVO-database, a comprehensive database which includes most of the foods consumed within the Dutch population. The coverage of the micronutrient content of this database is high, as it is between 71% and 99%.

Micronutrient content was assumed to be zero if micronutrient content was not known, possibly resulting into underestimation of the true content. Food consumption data collected over two recall days is not representative for usual food consumption, as consumption may vary from day to day. With SPADE we could correct for these so-called within-person variances, resulting in habitual intakes of the population. These habitual intakes could be used to evaluate the adherence to the dietary reference values.

Conclusion

One-fifth of the young children in the Netherlands use YCF. Although YCF increases micronutrient intake, for most of the micronutrients a low risk of inadequate intakes exists among users as well as non-users of YCF. For most micronutrients the additional intake from fortified YCF seems unnecessary to achieve adequate intakes. The consumption of YCF increased the risk of excessive zinc intakes. It is important that the addition of micronutrients to YCF is regulated, to prevent excessive intakes.

Acknowledgements

The authors would like to thank Alina Nicolae (National Institute for Public Health and Environment (RIVM)) for her help on the statistical analysis as well as Arnold Dekkers (RIVM) with his help regarding the analysis with SPADE.

Author contributions

MdJ, EN and JVK developed the research plan; MdJ performed the statistical analysis; the first draft of the manuscript was written by MdJ and all authors commented on previous versions of the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Funding

The present study was funded by the Netherlands Ministry of Health, Welfare and Sports. The Netherlands Ministry of Health, Welfare and Sports had no role in the design, analysis, interpretation or writing of this article.

Data availability

Data of the DNFCS 2012 to 2016 are available on request from https://www.rivm.nl/en/dutch-national-food-consumption-survey/data-on-request (Accessed on 20 May 2021).

Code availability

Not applicable.

Declarations

Conflict of interest

None of the authors has any conflicts of interest to declare.

Ethical approval

Ethical review and approval were waived for this study. The Utrecht University Medical Ethical Review Committee evaluated that the study from which the data were used was not subject to the Medical Research Involving Human Subjects Act (WMO) of the Netherlands (reference number 12 to 359/C).

References

1. EFSA (2006) Tolerable upper intake levels for vitamins and minerals. Scientific Committee on Food Scientific Panel on Dietetic Products, Nutrition and Allergies
2. WHO (2020) Factsheet Healthy diet. Available from: https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/healthy-diet. Accessed 12 Nov 2021
3. Health Council of the Netherlands (2009) Naar een voldoende inname van vitamines en mineralen (Towards an adequate intake of vitamins and minerals). Den Haag
4. Netherlands Nutrition Centre Should I offer young child formulae? [In Dutch: Moet ik speciale dreumesmelk of peutermelk geven?]. Available from: https://www.voedingscentrum.nl/nl/service/vraag-en-antwoord/kinderen-en-jongeren/moet-ik-speciale-dreumesmelk-of-peutermelk-geven-.aspx. Accessed 2 May 2022
5. Anonymous Regulation (EC) No 1925/2006: on the addition of vitamins and minerals and of other substances to foods Off J Eur Union 2006 L404 26 38
6. Anonymous (2013) Regulation (EU) No 609/2013 on food intended for infants and young children, food for special medical purposes, and total diet replacement for weight control and repealing Council Directive 92/52/EEC, Commission Directives 96/8/EC, 1999/21/EC, 2006/125/EC and 2006/141/EC, Directive 2009/39/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council and Commission Regulations (EC) No 41/2009 and (EC) No 953/2009
7. De minister voor Medische Zorg en Sport (2020) NVWA handhaving peutermelk vervolg 2020 (NVWA enforcement younc child formulae continuation 2020) [letter to parliament]
8. Van Rossum C, Buurma-Rethans E, Dinnissen C, Beukers M, Brants H, Dekkers A, Ocké M (2020) The diet of the Dutch. Results of the Dutch National Food Consumption Survey 2012 to 2016. Bilthoven: National Institute for Public Health and the Environment; publication no. RIVM-2020 to 0083
9. Cole TJ Lobstein T Extended international (IOTF) body mass index cut-offs for thinness, overweight and obesity Pediatr Obes 2012 7 284 294 10.1111/j.2047-6310.2012.00064.x 22715120
10. Statistics Netherlands (CBS) (2021) Degree of urbanisation. Available from: https://www.cbs.nl/en-gb/news/2007/07/young-people-live-in-cities-children-in-rural-areas/degree-of-urbanisation [link unavailable]. Accessed 23 Nov 2021
11. EFSA Panel on Dietetic Products Nutrition and Allergies (NDA)Turck D Bresson JL Burlingame B Dean T Fairweather-Tait S Heinonen M Hirsch-Ernst KI Mangelsdorf I McArdle HJ Naska A Neuhäuser-Berthold M Nowicka G Pentieva K Sanz Y Sjödin A Stern M Tomé D Van Loveren H Vinceti M Willatts P Fewtrell M Przyrembel H Titz A Valtueña Martínez S Scientific Opinion on the safety and suitability for use by infants of follow-on formulae with a protein content of at least 16 g/100 kcal Efsa J 2017 15 5 04781 10.2903/j.efsa.2017.4781 PMC7010188 32625487
12. Health Council of the Netherlands (2000) Dietary reference values: calcium, vitamin D, thiamin, riboflavin, niacin, pantothenic acid and biotin [In Dutch: Voedingsnormen: calcium, vitamine D, thiamine, riboflavine, niacine, pantotheenzuur en biotine]. The Hague: Health council of the Netherlands; publication no. 2000/12
13. Health Council of the Netherlands (2003) Dietary reference values: vitamin B6, folic acid and vitamin B12 [In Dutch: Voedingsnormen: vitamine B6, foliumzuur en vitamine B12]. The Hague: Health Council of the Netherlands; publication no. 2003/04
14. Health Council of the Netherlands (2012) Evaluation of the dietary reference values for vitamin D [In Dutch: Evaluatie van de voedingsnormen voor vitamine D]. The Hague: Health Council of the Netherlands; publication no. 2012/15
15. Health Council of the Netherlands (2014) Temporary dietary reference values [In Dutch: Tijdelijke voedingsnormen]
16. Nordic Council (2013) Nordic Nutrition Recommendations 2012: Part 1. Copenhagen: Nordic Council; publication no
17. Health Council of the Netherlands (2018) Dietary reference values for vitamins and minerals for adults [In Dutch: Voedingsnormen voor vitamines en mineralen voor volwassenen]
18. Shaffer JP Multiple hypothesis testing Ann Rev Psych 1995 46 561 584 10.1146/annurev.ps.46.020195.003021
19. NEVO (2019) NEVO online version 2019/6.0. Available from: http://www.rivm.nl/nevo_en/online/.2021
20. Dekkers AL Slob W Gaussian Quadrature is an efficient method for the back-transformation in estimating the usual intake distribution when assessing dietary exposure Food Chem Toxicol 2012 50 10 3853 3861 10.1016/j.fct.2012.06.044 22771820
21. Sacri AS Bocquet A de Montalembert M Hercberg S Gouya L Blondel B Ganon A Hebel P Vincelet C Thollot F Rallo M Gembara P Levy C Chalumeau M Young children formula consumption and iron deficiency at 24 months in the general population: a national-level study Clin Nutr 2021 40 1 166 173 10.1016/j.clnu.2020.04.041 32507584
22. Akkermans MD Eussen SR van der Horst-Graat JM van Elburg RM van Goudoever JB Brus F A micronutrient-fortified young-child formula improves the iron and vitamin D status of healthy young European children: a randomized, double-blind controlled trial Am J Clin Nutr 2017 105 2 391 399 10.3945/ajcn.116.136143 28052885
23. Health Council of the Netherlands (2015) Dutch dietary guidelines 2015. The Hague: Health Council of the Netherlands: publication no. 2015/24E
Publication and source details

Original title: Consumption of young child formulae in the Netherlands

Marjolein H. de Jong; Eline L. Nawijn; Janneke Verkaik-Kloosterman

European Journal of Nutrition · 2022

© The Author(s) 2022https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Open AccessThis article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.http://dx.doi.org/10.13039/501100002999Ministerie van Volksgezondheid, Welzijn en Sport

Repository JATS snapshot; version as supplied

Source retrieved: 2026-11-11T09:24:05.097837+00:00

DOI: 10.1007/s00394-022-02956-2 · PMC9899716