Vitamin D3 for Life

Live Enlightened

Physiology

Vitamin D Target Genes and Circadian Gene-List Overlap: Study Summary

Previous related pageVitamin D Target Genes and Circadian Gene-List Overlap: Full StudyNext related pageVitamin D Target Genes and Circadian Gene-List Overlap: Full Study
Study at a glance

What did researchers compare about vitamin D and daily gene rhythms?

Researchers measured gene activity in blood cells from 25 healthy adults before and 24 hours after a one-day vitamin D3 treatment. They compared the responding genes with lists of genes showing daily or seasonal variation in other studies. These lists came from different people and different sampling methods, not one combined trial.

How many vitamin D-responsive genes appeared on the daily-rhythm list?

Of 361 vitamin D-responsive genes, 87 also appeared on the daily-rhythm list. This overlap was larger than expected under the analysis. Eighteen appeared on the seasonal list, but that overlap was not statistically significant. Among the daily-rhythm overlap, 70 genes decreased in activity and 17 increased. The study did not show that vitamin D activated 87 body-clock genes or made their activity follow a daily rhythm.

Did the study explain why people responded differently?

Participants showed different patterns of gene response, but the resulting groups were created from the same small dataset. They were not confirmed groups that could be used to choose treatment. Evidence about nearby vitamin D receptor binding came from a separate cell-line experiment. It supported possible explanations without proving the full mechanism in the participants.

Does the gene overlap identify a better time to take vitamin D?

Two samples taken 24 hours apart cannot describe a complete daily rhythm or show a change in its timing, strength or length. The study did not measure sleep or compare taking vitamin D in the morning with taking it in the evening. Breakfast and lunch were simply the times used in the study. These findings do not establish an ideal time to take vitamin D, personalised supplement treatment or an improvement in disrupted sleep and waking patterns.

Read the full article below ↓

A human blood-cell analysis found that vitamin D-responsive genes overlapped more than expected with a separate circadian gene list. The result suggests a molecular connection, but it does not demonstrate that vitamin D reset the body clock, improved sleep or worked best at a particular dosing time. For the detailed analysis, see Vitamin D Target Genes and Circadian Gene-List Overlap: Full Study.

This VD3FL analysis uses the complete principal article, its figures, three supplementary figures and two supplementary workbooks. The study concerns blood-cell gene expression.

What the researchers compared

Maissan and Carlberg analysed gene expression before and 24 hours after a one-day vitamin D3 protocol in 25 healthy Finnish adults. The total dose was 80,000 IU, split between breakfast and lunch.

They compared 361 vitamin D-responsive genes with circadian and seasonal lists from different studies. The vitamin D experiment used peripheral blood mononuclear cells; the timing datasets came from different people and sampling designs. These were related datasets, not one combined intervention trial.

The main result

Eighty-seven vitamin D targets overlapped the circadian list, significantly more than expected under the analysis model. Eighteen overlapped the seasonal list, which was not a significant enrichment. Of the 87 circadian-overlapping targets, 70 decreased in expression and 17 increased.

The finding therefore concerns overlap and expression responses within Vitamin D and Gene Expression. It does not mean 87 core clock genes were activated. Neither an increase nor a decrease automatically establishes a beneficial effect.

The study also found clusters of different participant responses. Those groups were generated from the same small dataset and were not validated categories for choosing individual treatment.

What the receptor evidence means

The investigators examined receptor-related regulatory evidence from a separate cell-line experiment. Nearby binding regions can support hypotheses about Vitamin D Receptors, but proximity does not prove the complete regulatory pathway in the human participants.

One gene name differs between parts of the main text. The checked figure and supplementary workbook support CSRNP1, rather than treating CSRNP1 and CSRNP2 as interchangeable. Main and supplementary significance thresholds also need to remain distinct.

Why this does not establish a dosing time

Two blood samples 24 hours apart do not reveal a complete daily oscillation. There was no comparison of morning and evening dosing, no sleep outcome and no direct demonstration of changed circadian phase, amplitude or period.

The result adds a molecular research question to Vitamin D and Circadian Biology. It does not show that supplementation can substitute for light-related timing information or repair sleep-wake disruption. Breakfast and lunch were protocol details, not proven optimal times.

Conclusion

The study supports enriched overlap between vitamin D responses and circadian-associated genes in blood-related datasets. Demonstrating a changed clock, improved sleep or useful personalised treatment will require different measurements and independent confirmation.

Scientific sources

Maissan P, Carlberg C. Circadian Regulation of Vitamin D Target Genes Reveals a Network Shaped by Individual Responsiveness. Nutrients. 2025;17(7):1204. DOI 10.3390/nu17071204; PMID 40218962.

Related reading

Original sources